Customer Reviews

10 Questions for the Dalai Lama

5 star:		(16)
4 star:		(11)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(4)

 

 

This is a very gentle documentary film of the most famous monk in the world, his humble origins and his joint role as spiritual and political leader of Tibetans.

It's combination of background and insertion of clips to illustrate points during the actual interview with his holiness enhances what would be to most people a relatively staid movie. What results is an interesting story of a man who insists that he is but a man despite everything which his many follwers wish upon him. He is his own person, someone who wishes his own privacy despite the pressure upon him to be a purely public figure.

The documentary also deals with real political difficulties, addressing the issue of China and accusing the Chinese government in all but name of the kidnap of the Panchen Lama, yet managing to maintain some degree of impartiality so that it avoids the charge of being mere propaganda.

We learn much too, of the filmmaker and his observations, especially where he notes that it is those with least who display outward signs of happiness while those who have the most are the least happy.

Overall this is well worth watching especially to gain some insight into the mind of one of the most influential men of the 20th Century. After having watched this film today, I was reminded of the famous remark of Stalin who is reported to have asked: "How many legions has the Pope?".
Perhaps China's current rulers would be advised to ask the same question about the Dalai Lama.

I was lucky enough to get to see '10 Questions' at a movie screening earlier this year. In hindsight, I had wondered if it might be a bit boring, but was I wrong! It was absolutely fascinating from beginning until end. Tha Dalai Lama is one incredible man and Rick Ray did an really nice job of capturing some beautiful images and putting together this film. I highly recommend '10 Questions' for anyone from age 5 on up. I hope that the DVD will have some good bonus features, too.

I do not as a rule buy DVD's. I rent them. I was shattering my behavior pattern when I bought 10 Questions for the Dalai Lama. Perhaps I might want to view this one more than once or share it.

It is not the answers to the 10 questions that makes this DVD a "keeper". Rather, it is Rick Ray's lively, sometimes colorful, sometimes starkly black-and-white, introduction to the history of the Dalai Lamas, the culture of Tibetan Buddhism and the politics and geography of Tibet, that holds the viewer's attention long before we are introduced to the current Dalai Lama.

The questions that remain for the viewer at the end of the film are as intriguing as the answers we hear. How does one balance nationalism and belief in one's wisdom tradition against love of all humanity and openness to new knowledge? The Dalai Lama provides his view but tempers that with his offering of himself as a limited human, rather than an all-knowing deity.

This viewer found the current Dalai Lama to be a quite lovable human. Others are invited to meet with him for a while in Rick Ray's film.

Travel "filmmaker" Rick Ray didn't seem to do the most basic kind of research about Buddhism or the Dalai Lama despite having had at least 3 full months to prepare. Due to his background as a travel filmmaker, perhaps he is used to oversimplifying complex subjects for easy digestion by a distraction-seeking audience. But when you are granted an audience with an extremely busy world figure and religious leader, you really should prepare properly. Shame on you, Rick Ray.

The resulting film is dull and superficial in the extreme, overflowing with random footage of people staring into the camera while the narrator drones on and on with his ill-informed hypothesizing about the human condition, full of platitudes about happy poor people and tales of feeling "close to heaven" inside a monastery.

And his 10 questions? Incredibly vague & simple minded stuff like "why do poor people seem to be happier than rich people?" and "how important is it to preserve tradition?" When speaking about Middle East tensions, the Dalai Lama says there is too much anger, hatred & negativity and that these high emotions need to first be "cooled down" before more constructive action can be taken on the serious issues facing them. He suggests (half jokingly) that festivals & picnics would be a good way of achieving this *first* step. The narration immediately proclaims: "so festivals were the answer to peace in the middle east". I cannot describe my utter disbelief when I heard that. I wanted to yell at my screen "THAT'S NOT WHAT HE SAID AT ALL!!" Not only has he done no research, but he apparently didn't pay any attention to the interview itself - either at the time or while editing.

Time and again, he seemed intent on squeezing the Dalai Lama into a preconceived box he's made for him. At one point, Rick Ray drones: "it might come as a surprise to learn that although he PROSCRIBES festivals as the answer for peace around the world, he personally dislikes them, especially when they're in his honor." In addition to repeating his obvious misinterpretation about festivals, no one who knows anything about the Dalai Lama would have been surprised by that - it's perfectly in line with his humility as someone who routinely describes himself as an ordinary person from a small town. As I continued watching the film, I got the distinct impression that Rick Ray was treating his subject almost as an idiot savant, wasting his time with ridiculously simple questions and offering to re-interpret the answers for the audience (and totally misinterpret it in the process).

To add to all this, the filmmaker has inserted himself into this film far too much. For example, he worries out loud about not wasting the precious 45 minutes he's been allowed for the interview and that if the Dalai Lama were to cut it short (because he's been known to do that if he senses you're a disingenuous fool), it would be the most humiliating experience of his life. I say "who cares?" He should have just spent his time PREPARING for the interview instead of narcissistically recording HIMSELF worrying about it out loud. This is not a documentary but an ill-informed, self-absorbed, not at all ready for prime time, grade school-level personal diary that should have been uploaded directly to YouTube. At best.

10 Questions for the Dalai Lama is an award-winning documentary DVD of ten soul-searching questions posed to His Holiness the Dalai Lama by filmmaker and explorer Rick Ray. Among the profound questions asked are "Why do the poor often seem happier than the rich?", "Must a society lose its traditions in order to move into the future?", and "How do you reconcile a commitment to non-violence when faced with violence?" Bonus features include an interview with the director, additional selected scenes, and an interview with Tenzin Geyche Tethong. An absolute "must-see" for practitioners of Buddhism, worthy of the highest recommendation for its thoughtful examination of both earthly and transcendental issues. 85 minutes, closed-captioned, color.

10 Questions is an entertaining introduction to Tibetan issues, but offers little revelatory to Buddhists or Tibetophiles.

American travel documentary filmmaker Rick Ray manages while shooting a project on India to arrange an interview with the Dalai Lama, a 45-minute meeting which he spins into a two hour documentary on the modern history of Tibet. Largely ignoring Buddhism, Ray filters political and cultural issues through his romanticized first person account of his three months in northern India.

The parade of cliches begins early on with Ray describing the Tibetans as people whose "spirit [is] rich beyond imagining." He sets off on the "journey of a lifetime" to immerse himself in Buddhism and live for a time in a Tibetan monastery. Along the way he finds that India "works in mysterious ways" and that in a monastery in Himachal Pradesh he had "somehow been transported closer to heaven."

The viewer is left to wonder, once safely through the platitudes, how Ray was affected by his experience. Perhaps he wasn't. Monastery life is little more than a prayer at dawn, a sand mandala, and a joke about butter tea. Of his Buddhist "immersion," we are presented with only a thumbnail review of the Buddha's enlightenment. Of his meeting with the Dalai Lama, he offers no conclusions. In the end, we are left to wonder why Ray went to such lengths to include so much of himself in the film when he has nothing to say.

Fortunately, the Dalai Lama does, though nothing he hasn't said at other times or other places or in one of his many books. Still, the wise old man whose laugh sounds a bit like Yoda's is always engaging (even if he isn't making any new points) and literally saves this film from irrelevancy.

Apparently 10 Questions has won a handful of film festival awards, a rather lamentable backhanded compliment to the Tibetans. Although the awards may attract the attention of those who might not otherwise be interested in Buddhism, the Dalai Lama, the Tibetan diaspora, or the occupation of Tibet, that festival judges see this film as worthy of award shows just how little Western audiences still know about these subjects.

#

I have long been an admirer of Tibetan culture and its particular form of Buddhism. I found this film to be absoultly delightful and informative. Everyone needs to be aware of Tibet's plight at the hand of the Chinese communist regime. The most insightful and gentle civilization on Earth is slowly being destroyed.

I'll be short here, because most has been said already by the other reviewer who gave one star. This is an incredibly badly researched film, superficial to the extreme, and full of embarrassing platitudes. Why do poor people seem so much happier than rich people? The filmmaker has apparently never actually bothered to get to know some of the poor people he refers to. A smiley face does not mean a happy life, especially in Asia.
To actually get the privilege to interview the Dalai Lama personally, and not even do the most basic homework first, is in my opinion an incredible show of disrespect for the Dalai Lama (who has a very busy schedule).
The film does seem to satisfy a certain Western desire for happy poor people and saintly Buddhist Tibetans, and perhaps this explains the many good reviews. But if you want to learn something about the Dalai Lama or the Tibetans, then better watch another film or better yet, read a book.

Superior. Rick Ray does an exceptional job of film making here.Title sounds like Oh , 2 guys sitting in a room talking.He takes it a long ways farther than that. First , he sorta takes us through a history of tibet and the finding of the 14th Dalai Lama. The actual interview is at the end of the movie and maybe 15 minutes. The other 70 minutes is a visual feast and excellent soundtrack traveling thru the story of the plight of the Tibetans. Very well done i rented it and watched it 2 or 3 times then i decided to buy it. If yu are a fan of the Dalai Lama this is an excellent archive to possess. The questions he poses are very well thot out and yu find yourself saying Omigosh! How will the Dalai Lama answer that one! Thot - provoking and inspirational visually stunning and excellent in production . unbeatable.
Bravo! Mr.Rick Ray. Bravo!

This documentary covers the film-maker's journey to have an audience with the Dalai Lama where he asks 10 questions. There is also offered here a lot of background exploration of Tibetan culture and history along with consideration of the life of the Dalai Lama and the political and human rights issues surrounding the Chinese occupation of Tibet. The background music and filming of locations throughout India and Tibet are impressive and the documentary is woven together nicely. Some rare old footage of the lama can be seen in this film and the questions and answers are nice catalysts for discussion and contemplation for those viewing this. I highly recommend this if you have any interest in Tibet or in Buddhism and even if you just are curious about religion, spirituality, politics, and history.