3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Dissapointing, January 26, 2008
This review is from: 100 Classic Golf Tips (100 Golf Tips) (Hardcover)
For me, this book becomes more and more irritating the more I read it.
The drawing for tip 94 bares no relationship to the tip. One talks about leg strength while the drawing appears to be about using a wall for club head position. The drawing for tip 97 mentions teeing up on the right side, 'aim for the left' and 'you can now fade the ball', yet the drawing shows the ball flight to the left, surely a draw or hook?
Tip 83 "Bermuda Grain". "The more pronounced the grain, the more you'll have to account for it on your read and in your stroke". Thanks for that.
While the drawings are suburb in that Readers Digest 1950's way I am yet to be convinced that they are enough to really clarify the tip sometimes. Golf tips at best are often contradictory and perhaps more than realised, not neccessarily suitable for your type of body mechanics, particularly swing tips. After reading this book several times I am left wanting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
100 "tips" reduced to 3, August 29, 2010
This review is from: 100 Classic Golf Tips (100 Golf Tips) (Hardcover)
Want to continue the previous reviewers statements with this: The pictures don't match the "tips" for the majority of the 100, not just for the couple of examples given.
From the looks of things, the tips are nothing more that comments gleaned from interviews, probably a golf magazine. They are often presented out of context, or edited to be nearly incomprehensible in the form given. One has to be both well versed in golf lingo, and a mind reader to figure out what either the pro or the author is trying to say.
Combine that with pairing each "tip" with completely unrelated drawings and you have the makings of a completely useless book. Yes the drawings by Anthony Ravielli are excellent. But not when they don't match the tip. Also, there are frequently 2 or more examples given, but no correct version given. Your choice as to which drawing to follow. From the looks of things, the author grabbed what ever drawings the artist had produced, and then combined a supposed tip to go with each. All while obviously trying to capitalize on the artist's renown. They certainly didn't work together in this drivel. If the drawings match the tip, it appears to be a complete and rare fluke.
Here are my tips for this book.
1. If you love golf art, or can figure everything out by a single drawing alone, then go ahead and get this book. Consider the changing the title to read, "250 Drawings to Help You Figure Out How to Play Golf... Maybe."
2. This book is so bad, it will stop me from buying anything else written by Christopher Obetz in the future. It is at the least, an incompetant effort. At the most, an unethical attempt at grabbing a fast buck. Either way, it is bad enough for me to advise never even consider this author's offerings again.
3. If you still feel the need to get this book, although I can't imagine why, Border's was blowing them out new for $3.99 in their discounted book section. At $4 it was still a huge rip off, but you'll save money at least from the list price. I love Amazon and shop here all the time, but a buck is a buck.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No