98 of 99 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tight red box of 51 artists, October 20, 2009
This review is from: 111 Years of Deutsche Grammophon: 55 CD Anthology (Audio CD)
It is inevitable that keen collectors of DGG cds will face some duplication with this set, but I was positively surprised there is indeed a lot of records I have not listened or bought before (albeit they are so easily available). Such positive personal finds are Carmignola Vivaldi, Giulini/Doningo Opera gala, Gardiner/Monteverdi, Otter/Lamenti, Pires/Chopin, Pogorelich/Scarlatti to name a few. Only complete works are selected - not highlights or single moments (except aria recitals). Most cds are by contents the same as published in various series, typically "Originals" during the last years. As an example, in Pinnock's Vivaldi recording, some later bonus concertos are added to original cd which had only " 4 seasons"- the contents here is identical to "Originals" reissue, but cover is from the first cd version. All recordings I have listened seem to be very good, some exceptional like Gardiner's Monteverdi (earliest composer of the set with Praetorius) Vespers which is so rich in dynamic contrasts it can be almost problematic for some listeners! Yet, I liked the energy of Gardiner's interpretation very much and I am very happy to have also this set of Vespers. Well-filled (mostly) 55 cds is a huge amount of music and I have not have enough time to check everything, but just like to give my first impressions. I think masterings used are same as in the earlier editions of each cd before this set.
The red/yellow packet is very compact, cds in cardboards placed like archive cards towards opener - very nicely organized in alphabetical order by performer (Abbabo-Zimerman) - so the set is a sort of tribute to 51 selected artists of the label (Fournier, Gardiner, Pires and K.Richter are double cds) rather than to composers. The thick soft leaflet in the box summarize nicely works and a shortish essay "Chronology" (in English, German and French) telling highlights of all DGG decades, with some nice photos: factories, designing DGG logo, artists etc. Finishing quality is very impressive for the price, but there is no room for music text and translations.
One cannot have everything in 55 cds, but I think there might have been more space for modern music in the set. Now everything seem to end with Stravinsky Rite - with some exception of Pärt and Corigliano pieces in Grimaud cd! I think Sinopoli (also missing artist) recording of Manzoni or Frank Martin/Fischer recording would have added up something to the set and this lastly mentioned cd is also hard to find. Positive thing is quite many recent recordings are included, from artists Dudamel, Kozena, Lang Lang,Netrebko, Quasthoff and Villazon to name a few.
There are many great, old and dear classics: Furtwängler/Schumann 4th symphony, Fournier's Bach, Chopin by Argerich and Pollini, Horowitz in Moscow, Kleiber's Beethoven, Kempff, Oistrach, Rostropovich, Richter... and a marvelous Walcha all Bach organ recital - a personal favorite. There are only a few mono recordings from 1950's, one example Verdi's Requiem by Fricsay (1953) or Haydn 88 by Furtwängler (1951) which is the earliest recording in the set.
I recommend the set warmly - for starters and collectors as well. It is huge box of great music and at least fine interpretations - from the great traditional label. I guess the separate 111 Book will give more detailed view to interesting and quite complex history of DGG, but this leaflet is a good start.
It is sometimes very annoying to list the contents of cds in review, but here it is in edited form to save space and give you at least clue to get more details elsewhere (Years usually refer to recording year).
1.CD Claudio Abbado: Brahms, Ungarische Tänze Nr. 1-21 (Wien PO/1982)
2.CD Amadeus Quartett: Beethoven, Streichquartette Nr. 7 & 15 (1959 / 1962)
3.CD Martha Argerich: Chopin, Preludes Nr. 1-26; Klaviersonate Nr. 3 op. 35 (1976)
4.CD Daniel Barenboim: Ravel, La Valse; Daphnis et Chloe-Suite Nr. 2; Pavane (Orchestre de Paris / 1981)
5.CD Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli: Debussy, Preludes Heft 1; Images I & II (1977)
6.CD Leonard Bernstein: Berstein, West Side Story / 1984)
7.CD Karl Böhm: Mozart, Requiem KV 626 (Mathis, Hamari, Ochmann, Wien PO/1971)
8.CD Pierre Boulez: Strawinsky, Le Sacre du Printemps; Der Feuervogel (Cleveland O, Chicago SO/1991)
9.CD G.Carmignola: Vivaldi, Violinkonzerte RV 190, 217, 303, 325, 331 (Venice Baroque O, A Marcon / 2005)
10.CD Placido Domingo / Carlo Maria Giulini: Opera Gala (Los Angeles PO, Giulini / 1981)
11.CD Gustavo Dudamel: Mahler, Symphonie Nr. 5 (Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra of Venezuela / 2006)
12.CD Emerson Quartet: Bach, Die Kunst der Fuge BWV 1080 für Streichquartett (2002)
13.CD Dietrich Fischer Dieskau: Schubert, Winterreise D. 911 (Gerald Moore, Klavier / 1971)
14.& 15.CD Pierre Fournier: Bach, Cellosuiten BWV 1007-1012 (1960)
16.CD Ferenc Fricsay: Verdi, Requiem (Stader, Radev, Krebs, Borg, RIAS SO/1953)
17.CD Wilhelm Furtwängler: Schumann, Symph. Nr. 4 / Haydn, Symphonie Nr. 88 (Berlin PO/1953 / 1951)
18.& 19.CD John Eliot Gardiner: Monteverdi, Vespro della beata vergine; Magnificat a sei voci (Monoyios, Pennicchi, Chance, Tucker, Robson, Monteverdi Choir, English Baroque Soloists / 1989)
20.CD Emil Gilels: Beethoven, Klaviersonaten Nr. 21, 23, 26 (1971-1974)
21.CD Reinhard Goebel: Bach, Orchestersuiten Nr. 2 & 5 / Pachelbel, Canon & Gigue in D/Händel, Sonate für 2 Violinen HWV 399 / Vivaldi, Sonate für 2 Violinen RV 63 (Musica Antiqua Köln / 1982)
22.CD Hélene Grimaud: Credo: Pärt, Credo for Piano, Choir & Orchestra / Beethoven, Piano Sonata Nr. 17 "Tempest"; Chorfantasie op. 80 / Corigliano, Fantasie (Swedish Radio Choir, Swe. RSO, E-P Salonen / 2002)
23.CD Hilary Hahn: Bach, Violinkonzerte BWV 1041-1043, 160 ((BWV 1043 für 2 Violinen; BWV 1060 für Violine & Oboe) (Hilary Hahn, Margaret Batjer, Allan Vogel, LA Chamber Orchestra, Jeffrey Kahane / 2003)
24.CD V. Horowitz: In Moscow: Scarlatti, Mozart, Rachmaninoff, Scriabin, Chopin, Schumann,etc (1985)
25.CD Eugen Jochum: Orff, Carmina Burana (Janowitz, Stolze, Fischer-Dieskau, O der D. Oper Berlin / 1968)
26.CD Herbert von Karajan: Beethoven, Symphonie Nr. 9; Coriolan-Ouvertüre op. 62 Berlin PO/1962)
27.CD Wilhelm Kempff: Beethoven, Klavierkonzerte Nr. 4 & 5 (Berlin PO, Leitner / 1962)
28.CD Carlos Kleiber: Beethoven, Symphonien Nr. 5 & 7 (Wien PO/1974 / 1975)
29.CD Magdalena Kozena: Handel Arien (Venice Baroque Orchestra, Andrea Marcon / 2006)
30.CD Rafael Kubelik: Dvorak, Symphonien Nr. 8 & 9 (Berlin PO/1967 / 1972)
31.CD Lang Lang: Tschaikowsky, Klavierkonzert Nr. 1 op. 23 / Mendelssohn, Klavierkonzert Nr. 1 op. 25 (Chicago SO, Daniel Barenboim / 2003)
32.CD Lorin Maazel: Mendelssohn, Symphonien Nr. 4 & 5 (Berlin PO/1961)
33.CD Mischa Maisky: Werke von Saint-Saens, Faure, Respighi, Dvorak, Glasunow, Tschaikowsky, Bruch, Strauss, Haydn (Orchestre de Paris, Bychkov / 1991)
34.CD Igor Markevitch: Cherubini, Anacreon-Ouvertüre / Auber, La Muette de Portici-Ouvertüre (Lamoureux Orchestra / 1958)
35.CD Paul McCreesh: Praetorius, Christmette (Lutherian Christmas Morning Mass ) (Gabrieli Consort & Players / 1993)
36.CD Marc Minkowski: Rameau, Une Symphonie imaginaire ((Suite of 20 Orchestral pieces from 11 Rameau-Operas,selected by Marc Minkowski) (Les Musiciens du Louvre / 2004)
37.CD Anne Sophie Mutter: Brahms, Konzert für Violine, Cello & Orchester op. 102; Violinkonzert op. 77 (Mutter, Meneses, Berlin PO, Karajan / 1983 / 1981)
38.CD Anna Netrebko: Opera Arias - Szenen & Arien von Mozart, Berlioz, Bellini, Donizetti, Puccini, Massenet, Gounod, Dvorak (Wien PO, GIanandrea Noseda / 2001)
39.CD David Oistrach: Tschaikowsky, Violinkonzert op. 35 / Wieniawski, 3 Etudes-Caprices / Sarasate, Navarra op. 33 (Staatskapelle Dresden, Gewandhausorchester Leipzig, Konwitschny / 1961)
40.CD Anne Sofie von Otter: Lamenti (Musica Antiqua Köln, Reinhard Goebel (1997)
41.CD Trevor Pinnock: Vivaldi, Concerti op. 8 Nr. 1-4, RV 548; Konzert für 2 Violinen RV 516 (Standage, Willcock, The English Consort / 1981)
42.& 43.CD Maria Joao Pires: Chopin, Nocturnes Nr. 1-21 (1995)
44.CD I. Pogorelich: Scarlatti, Klaviersonaten K. 1,8, 9,11,13,20,87,98,119,135,159,380,450,487,529 (1991)
45.CD Maurizio Pollini: Chopin, Etüden Nr. 1-24 (1971)
46.CD Thomas Quasthoff: Die Stimme - Arien & Duette von Lortzing, Wagner, Weber, Strauss (Quasthoff, Oelze, Orchester der Deutschen Oper Berlin, Thielemann / 2001)
47.& 48.CD Karl Richter: Bach, Messe h-moll BWV 232 / 1961)
49.CD Svjatoslav Richter: Rachmaninoff, Klavierkonzert Nr. 2, 6 Preludes (Warschau PO, Wislocki / 1959)
50.CD M.Rostropovich: Dvorak, Cellokonzert/ Tschaikowsky, Rokoko-Variationen (BPO, Karajan / 1968)
51.CD Bryn Terfel: The Vagabond - Vaughan Williams, Finzi, Butterworth, Ireland, (Malcolm Martineau, Klavier / 1994)
52.CD Rolando Villazon: Cielo e mar - Cilea, Donizetti, Gomes, Mercadante, Ponchielli, Verdi, Boito, Pietri (Giuseppe Verdi Chor & SO Mailand, Danielle Callegari / 2007)
53.CD Helmut Walcha: Bach, Toccata & Fuge d-moll BWV 565; Präludium & Fuge BWV 552; Triosonate BWV 525; Partita BWV 768; Choräle BWV 645-650 "Schübler-Choräle" (Orgel Laurenskerk Alkmaar / 1958-1963)
54.CD Fritz Wunderlich: Schumann, Dichterliebe, Beethoven, Schubert (Hubert Giesen, Klavier /1965)
55.CD Krystian Zimerman: Liszt, Klavierkonzerte Nr. 1 & 2; Totentanz für Klavier & Orchester (Boston SO, Ozawa / 1987)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
44 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A half-baked, self-important milestone, December 28, 2009
This review is from: 111 Years of Deutsche Grammophon: 55 CD Anthology (Audio CD)
My analysis of this set differs sharply from that of the uncritical chorus of praise that you'll find all over this page. In my opinion, this is a half-baked collection indeed, a non-cohesive, huge Whitmans' Sampler primarily promoting the label's product rather than honoring the artists in its long history (or composers for that matter - where are the pioneering recordings of Bruckner or indeed any Bruckner at all? Sibelius? Hindemith conducted by Hindemith? - and almost no Wagner whatsoever!). I don't know who selected the material or why exactly 55 CDs, but I do know that this compilation could and should have been much, much better. First of all, I must say that I find the 111 years theme rather contrived - but let it pass. What really bothers me is that the whole thing has the feel of a rush job put together by someone not up to the task, a person or committee from the marketing rather than the artistic section of the company. This could have been a great opportunity to celebrate the many musicians who have made Deutsche Grammophon one of the world's greatest labels for more than a century. Yet I am disappointed to find that so many great and significant artists are missing from the festivities. I have looked closely but I find no trace of Gil Shaham, Pinchas Zukerman, Geza Anda, Nathan Milstein, Neeme Jarvi, Tamas Vasary, Andres Segovia, Salvatore Accardo, Nicanor Zabaleta, Narciso Yepes, Agnes Baltsa, Grace Bumbry, Mirella Freni, Jessye Norman, and many other great and well-known artists who have so substantially contributed to the label. Herbert von Karajan is represented by yet another re-release of his 1962 recording of the Beethoven Ninth Symphony. A great recording indeed but so readily and constantly available as to prove a most unimaginative choice for this collection. A far better choice would have been the hard-to-find recording of Prokofiev's Fifth Symphony, easily the best recording the piece has ever had and one of DG's most stunning sonic productions ever. Or how about Karajan' last recording of Richard Strauss's Metamorphosen? He conducted the world premiere recording of the work and this last offering is absolutely incredible in its intensity and power. Nothing shows better the amazing beauty and sheen of the Berlin Philharmonic in its peak years. And speaking of great conductors, where the hell are Giuseppe Sinopoli, Andre Previn and James Levine?
I guess that the appearance of Leonard Bernstein's horrible, bombastic West Side Story mess was inevitable. I also understand that several of the celebrities du jour had to be included, such as Anna Netrebko, Gustavo Dudamel and Lang Lang. Fine, yet most of the artists that made the label famous during the crucial, developing years of the long-playing record are missing. No Rita Streich, Irmgard Seefried, Christa Ludwig, Thomas Stewart, Evelyn Lear, Hermann Prey, Hilde Gueden, Peter Schreier, Ralph Kirkpatrick, Hans Rosbaud, Wolgang Schneiderhan or Teresa Berganza, among other casualties. This shows not only carelessness but ingratitude and disrespect.
It would have been nice to have Carlo Maria Giluini's recording of Mahler's Ninth Symphony and the Boston Chamber Players's lovely album of Johann Strauss waltzes arranged by Schoenberg and Berg. That would have showed some imagination. Some of Eugen Jochum's Bruckner choral works would have been appreciated as well. Or Gundula Janowitz singing Wagner, Mozart, Schubert or Richard Strauss. At least they could have included Geza Anda's album of Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 21, one of the label's all-time best sellers!!!
The small booklet contains a rather shallow and insufficent overview of the company's history. Not bad but not great. I guess they want you to buy the big hard-bound (and very expensive) book.
I have complained enough, I guess. Don't get me wrong, I bought the box and I think it's all right for the purposes of a superficial anthology. And it includes several albums that I had missed through the years, at least on CD, such as Barenboim's superb Ravel. I just wish that a lot more intelligence and imagination and a lot less inflated self-congratulation had gone into creating this. The yellow label and its family of immortal artists deserve much better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No