Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
White spots and the temptation to read more, August 24, 2001
This review is from: 1688: A Global History (Hardcover)
At first this book fascinates: a global view from one year in history. All those spotlight reports from all over the world make the reader realise what is happening at nearly the same moment in time: the establishment of a new dynasty's rule in China, the overthrow of the Stuarts in England, the departure of a Viceroy from Mexico ... Those are fascinating reports from 300 years ago, all with stories about individual people who left records: a nun in New Spain, a poet in Japan, a Jewish widow in Hamburg, a captured Turkish slave in the Balkans ... All those fates, all those stories make the reader want to learn more. Alas, this won't happen in this book. It is just a temptation to read other books, but not good history as such. For that it lacks a coherent structure; there is no theme beside the year 1688. Also there are too many white spots on the globe presented here. So not realy good history, but nevertheless a great book to be recomended!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting and broad coverage, June 20, 2005
John Wills has done a good job of presenting the whole world as it was in 1688. The coverage is necessarily incomplete--if Wills had identified every culture and conflict alive in that year there'd have been only a sentence on each. It's thorough even so, and by 1688 the world was truly a global network: the Spanish mining silver in Bolivia; the Dutch bloodily extracting spices from the Indonesian archipelagoes; the British making their first military probes into India. The Tsar of Russia visited London; there were Armenian traders in Lhasa, English scientists in Australia, and Jesuits almost everywhere.
The coverage is so broad that Wills cannot do any one story real justice. He copes with this by picking specific narratives and telling them in detail, interspersing these stories among the general cultural and historical background. He covers the progress of the great religions, and literature and science as well as the struggles for empire -- this was the age of Locke, Leibniz and Newton, after all. And 1688 is a good choice for other reasons: the English Revolution of that year is the hook on which Wills hangs much material about the religious strife of the seventeenth century, for example.
The writing is clear and transparent. The book's only real weak point is that nothing is described in much detail; nothing gets more than a few pages. The result is that when you've finished you feel more as if you'd been reading newspapers about the year than a history text. You don't feel you know these cultures in depth -- you know them the way a slightly educated contemporary might have known them: by reputation, with a few high points. However, I think that's a fine result for a book like this. It certainly made me want to read half a dozen more books to get more details. I don't think this is a good book to start with, though, if you don't already have some awareness of this period of history; it is not truly introductory for any of the cultures covered. For those interested, though, it is well able to whet your appetite for more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Worldwide history, February 17, 2002
Conventional histories discuss events taking place over time. In his brilliant, thought-provoking 1688, Wills turns that notion on its side by concentrating on what was happening worldwide in one particular year. Along with relatively familiar European occurrences, 1688 saw the Chinese emperor mourning a Flemish Jesuit astronomer, the great African trading crossroads of Timbuktu in decline and a French fleet failing to cow Algiers. Wills ingenuously claims that initially he wanted to avoid 1688 for fear that Britain's Glorious Revolution, which saw the deposition of James II and the accession of William III, would dominate, and that, finally, he was forced towards it by other stories he wanted to tell (he could hardly, however, have written about a neighbouring year and ignored the revolution). The year is early in Peter the Great's career, just after Newton's great publications and towards the end of the life of the Chinese writer Wang Fuzhi. Bemoaning colonisation's later impact on aboriginal tribes, which he asserts were happy with nothing, Wills tends to romanticise the non-western. Without exonerating Arab or African participants, he blames Europeans for the awfulness of the slave trade, yet barely discusses slavery in the Ottoman empire. Descriptions of, say, tolerant Muslim urbanisation need more caveats than they get here, but 1688 challenges western-centric prejudices in horizon- expanding fashion, and its erudite combination of brevity and scope make it an excellent popular history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|