Customer Reviews

1984

5 star:		(82)
4 star:		(33)
3 star:		(18)
2 star:		(14)
1 star:		(20)

 

 

Attention: For those who did not read George Orwell's classic dystopian novel "1984" in high school, college, or through personal initiative, please take the time to do so before diving into the soul shattering experience of the film version of this book, aptly titled "1984." I imagine that many viewers could experience lapses of extreme boredom if they do not have a sufficient understanding of newspeak, thoughtcrime, and the political dynamics of Oceania/Eastasia/Eurasia before experiencing this soul shattering film. You might even want to read a few items about communism and fascism before watching the movie. In any event, the book and film are chilling in their presentation of a world in the grip of pure totalitarianism.

Originally released in 1984, "1984" tells the story of Winston Smith. Smith lives and works in what used to be the city of London, before an atomic war swept away the world as we know it and ushered in the dark gloom of Big Brother. Smith spends his days working away in a booth at the Ministry of Information, constantly updating and rewriting the party organs in order to make history fit with present realities. In the course of a day's work, Winston routinely changes rationing promises, removes people labeled as "non-persons" from articles, and burns records. During his off hours, he sits in his ratty apartment under the constant surveillance of the state, which keeps an eye on him through a giant monitor in his living room and with hovering helicopters outside his window. Occasionally, Winston gets to attend giant party rallies where he and other members of INGSOC watch televised propaganda tapes about the endless war with Eastasia (or is it Eurasia?). Each day is bleak, filled with consumer shortages, the endless nattering of propaganda in the background ("War is Peace, Ignorance is Strength, Freedom is Slavery"), and dreams about his life as a child or a place in the countryside.

Unfortunately for Winston, he just cannot make himself accept the prevailing view, namely that one need only give oneself up to the party and never question anything INGSOC pronounces as truth. His job reconstructing history makes him acutely aware that the party lies incessantly, and in Winston's world losing faith in the party means losing one's life after visiting Room 101 in the Ministry of Love. To make matters worse, Winston catches the eye of the lovely Julia and quickly becomes embroiled in seditious activities that Big Brother more than frowns upon. After Winston falls in with a high party official named O'Brien, the downward spiral begins in earnest, leading to an interrogation that is definitely an upsetting viewing experience.

This film is by necessity an intensely character driven vehicle. Thankfully, director Michael Radford obtained the services of John Hurt and Richard Burton to play Winston and O'Brien. Hurt shines as the tortured Winston, looking as though he's on death's door while he trudges through another bland day in Oceania. Burton is properly menacing as the enigmatic O'Brien, playing his role of party thug with equal parts compassion (oddly enough) and threat. I know less about Suzanna Hamilton, the actress who plays Julia, although she does an admirable job working between two great film stars. Incidentally, this was Burton's last film role.

I loved the atmosphere of this film. Radford creates a dank, dingy London I wouldn't even think about strolling through without a full body protection suit. The ubiquitous audio and visual propaganda is a nice touch as well, creating a sense of total immersion in Winston's world. As Winston slogs through the bombed out backdrop of London on his way to work, the viewer becomes aware of the party's total grip on the people through the canard of total war. The omnipresent image of Big Brother should certainly bring a smirk to anyone familiar with Russian history, since the guy looks a lot like Lenin.

I noticed that the Eurythmics soundtrack, while advertised on the case and in the credits, is missing from the film. This did not bother me much since I first saw the film years ago and do not remember much about the soundtrack other than the excellent score by Dominic Muldowney... I feel sorry for those who looked forward to having that part of the soundtrack included in their purchase. Despite this omission, the film is very much worth the money.

Great imagery, great acting, and a great message about the evils of 20th century fascism and communism make "1984" a must have for any film lover. I'll watch John Hurt in nearly anything, but he really turns in a powerful performance here. Pick up this movie and watch for the warning signs!

"Nineteen Eighty-Four" (the actual on-screen title) is a rare example of a film adaptation of a book that faithfully transfers the visions and theme of the book's author, right down to even filming on the dates that the author specified (April-June 1984). George Orwell's frightening, hellish novel of a future where freedom has vanished, even from the minds of human beings, has been turned into an equally frightening film version. Its tale of a government that seeks to utterly crush the human spirit through propaganda, language, and fear, turning human beings into programmed machines, has never been more frightening than today. It is a book and movie for all times, as long as governments lie, tyrannies exist, and people surrender their freedoms in the name of fears, both real and imagined.

The casting couldn't be more perfect. John Hurt, looking worn and stretched past his years, is the ideal actor to play "little rebel" Winston Smith, who dares to think against the mysterious Big Brother and to fall in love. In his last film role, Richard Burton is like a glaring Greek Statue, stern and unflappable and scary. It's an unnerving and great performance. As for Suzanna Hamilton, Winston's love Julia, I was shocked when I first saw the movie: she matched exactly the image of Julia I had in my head when I read the book.

Director Michael Radford (who also directed "Il Postino") imagines the world of George Orwell exactly as the author would have if he had directed the film: as a wrecked vision of late-40s Britain if it had lost World War II. The set design is stunning, combing some high technology (video screens and computers) with rusty mid-forties technology (pneumatic tubes, rotary phones). Everywhere is decay and deprivation. Nothing really works, everything is bland and ugly in that awful, gray-stone block style that dominated Soviet and Chinese government architecture of the 1940s and 1950s. No doubt about it, the director understood where Orwell was coming from, and the models he was using.

Just like the book, "Nineteen Eighty-Four" is a film that will utterly devastate you, get under your skin, and change the way you look at the world. It is a masterpiece.

(A note on the disc: Although they receive credit, the music by the Eurythmics has been completely removed, as per the wishes of the director. Since this is a no-frills DVD without much in the way of extras, there is no alternate music track to let people hear the original theatrical soundtrack. However, the film is much much better without the Eurythmics; they don't fit the style and feel of the film or the wonderful original music. Also, the washed-out photographic style of the original released has been changed to a more natural look; but this has been true of every version since the theatrical release. None of this should prevent you from getting hold of this wonderful movie.)

Michael Radford's film of George Orwell's novel is perhaps the greatest cinematic adaptation ever made from a well-known literary source, and it stands out as one of the most memorable and underrated British films of the past thirty years. Radford treats the book neither as grim political prophecy nor as Wellsian flight of sci-fi futurist speculation. Instead, we are presented with the ruined world of 1948 as seen through a glass darkly - NINETEEN EIGHTY-FOUR done straight as a kind of medieval morality play for the post-totalitarian age. The end credits inform us, with but a modest air of self-importance, that the picture was shot "in and around London, April-June 1984, at the exact place and time imagined by the author." And the uncanny meta-fictional parallels don't stop there: the actors are so close to Orwell's descriptions, they practically seem born for their roles.

Resembling a gaunt, ashen-faced figure out of Egon Schiele, John Hurt is ideally cast as Winston Smith. As Julia, Suzanna Hamilton (first seen as a lovelorn dairymaid in Polanski's TESS and then as the paralyzed daughter in BRIMSTONE AND TREACLE) has a haunting and mysteriously stirring presence. Beyond the bluff, two-dimensional gamine of the novel, she brings a genuine warmth, substance, and fascination to her character - a little reminiscent, at times, of a young Harriet Andersson sans the continental coquettishness. Her pale, wiry, broad-hipped body has a simple, unaffected, even startling beauty; and in her more physically revealing scenes (there are many in the film), she radiates all the tactile sensual grace of a nude by Munch or Degas.

The late Richard Burton, featured in his last screen role, is the oracular Thanatos to Hamilton's Eros. As the grand inquisitor, O'Brien, he inhabits this shadowy and inscrutable character with more than just a sly hint of the demon-plagued Jesuit priests he portrayed in THE EXORCIST II and ABSOLUTION. In a maliciously Swiftian twist of irony, the famous Burton voice - the voice of classical drama, of poetry, indeed, of all that is held to be ennobling and edifying about mankind's estate - becomes a subtle and precisely modulated instrument of dehumanization. His death shortly after completing work on the film lends it a particularly cruel and all-too-human pathos. When he says to Hurt, "you are thinking that my face is old and tired...and while I talk of power I am unable to prevent the decay of my own body," the lines in Burton's craggy, weathered face speak volumes for him. It's an exquisite swan-song performance, patient and quietly devastating.

In addition to the superb ensemble cast, much credit is due to production designer Allan Cameron and cinematographer Roger Deakins, who shoots everything in a grainy, desaturated monochrome of blues and greys. The stark high-contrast photography often evokes the power and purity of Dreyer and Bresson, and there is even one extraordinary shot of a battered and delirious Hurt awaiting torture that is an unmistakable homage to Falconetti's famous haircutting scene in LA PASSION DE JEANNE D'ARC. Also notable is Dominic Muldowney's operatic score, an ingenious and even moving parody of Elgar's patriotic overtures and Prokofiev's Stalinist anthems. But it is Phyllis Logan (the star of Radford's first feature, ANOTHER TIME, ANOTHER PLACE, and a supporting player in Mike Leigh's SECRETS AND LIES) who provides the film with one its most caustic conceits. As the unseen voice of the Telescreen Announcer, her incessant nannyish hectoring suggests a more shrill caricature of Margaret Thatcher.

The film is impressive less for its fidelity to its source than its harrowingly vivid sense of realism, and how unobtrusively Radford manages to transcend the faults and contradictions of the novel to create an entirely plausible dystopian vision with a life of its own. That in itself makes NINETEEN EIGHTY-FOUR a great and original piece of filmmaking - its seamless perfection is still practically unequaled in the English-language cinema of recent years.

If I had known this DVD version was going to have a different soundtrack than the original U.S. release, I would not have purchased it! With all due respect for the director Michael Radford, the Eurythmics soundtrack is what makes this movie very, very good, in a disturbing way. I agree with other reviewers that MGM should have provided the option to choose the soundtrack. And frankly, I don't think customers should have to read about others disappointments in DVD purchases before clicking the BUY button. If the Eurythmics were not going to be featured on the soundtrack it should have been made very obvious in the ad. In fact the DVD case and the movie titles say music by Eurythmics and Dominic Muldowney! This seems to be happening a lot with DVD's. Movies hit the theaters, people fall in love with them as they are originally seen, then DVD's are sold with changes from the way they were first seen and remembered. This becomes infuriating given the cost of DVD's especially when replacing VHS tapes and getting stuck with a changed movie. I purchased this "1984" DVD for the Eurythmics musical score, as well as the movie itself and it's two great actors Richard Burton and John Hurt. I understand the VHS tape version has the Eurythmics soundtrack, therefore I recommend it over the DVD.

Aside from that, having read the book several times, the movie is an excellent adaptation that follows the original story in feeling and bewilderment, with only minor changes that comes with making a movie from a great novel. I urge everyone who sees this movie for the first time to read the book for many more interesting little details, all of which makes this story a very frightening one since it could become very real someday. Maybe by 2084?

Let me start by stating that the transfer on this disc is right on the money, revealing every gritty detail in the London of 1984 (both story-wise and, in fact, also when and where this movie was filmed)
Orwell's 1984 contains a message for us all, and on the day this film is banned - worry.
This is one of my staple films that I like to come back to every year or so, and it's an excellent adaptation of Orwell's novel (unlike the 1954 version that I once purchased out of curiousity).

Everything in Winston Smith's London has a poverty that rival's Moscow's during the Cold War, and the element of dread of the opressive INGSOC government and the Thought Police is conveyed perfectly!
I was quite pleased that this film had finally made it to DVD, but discovered much to my chagrin that the soundtrack wasn't the same one that I had been accustomed to hearing in all these years of seeing this film.
The soundtrack that is on the VHS and premium-cable version of the film was performed by the Eurythmics, and in my opinion enhanced the surreal feeling of dread and hopelessness that is at the core of this film.
On the disc, however, is the score that the director originally wanted - in the 80's it was replaced with the Eurythmics soundtrack in the American theatrical and video releases to make it more "marketable".
I could understand if perhaps the disc could have contained alternate soundtrack options - since this is a bare-bones disc that wouldn't have been too difficult, I imagine, but unfortunately we don't get a choice.
I'm not saying the score the director preferred is necessarily inferior - simply that, after years and years of watching this film, my mind associates certain scenes with certain scores, and now that all that is changed...well, I guess the only thing I can do is play my VHS recording of the film while watching the DVD picture.
We should have been given a choice in soundtracks, as Universal did with Legend.

This film was really made as a tribute to George Orwell's novel, not to entertain movie goers. That's why it was filmed in the same year and months that the book was set. I think this film is really for people who have read the novel. It tries to be faithful to George Orwell's description: dark, dingy and grim. It succeeds in that respect, and follows the story as closely as possible. Orwell used colour a lot when writing the novel.

John Hurt is the third actor to play Winston Smith (after Peter Cushing and Edmund O'Brien). He was suitably forlorn in the part. Richard Burton and Suzanna Hamilton were equally fine in their roles.

Michael Radford's film is superor to the 1956 version, which is unavailable. The 1956 version felt no guilt in distorting Orwell's story. There were minor things like Julia being blonde, and major things like the ending: Winston and Julia shouting "Down with Big Brother!" as they face execution by the firing squad.

Michael Radford's version of the novel is definitive, though flawed. As someone already said, it's hard to translate words to the screen and satisfy everyone. Many great works of literature have been unsuccessful as films. But they were made with the best of intentions. I feel "1984" is reasonably successful.

Hey guys! Are all of you peeved with the MGM North American DVD of "Nineteen Eighty-Four" which eliminates the Eurythmics contributions to the soundtrack in favor of the Dominic Muldowney-only score??

Well, I have good news for you. The British DVD from MGM features the Eurythmics/Muldowney score as you fondly remember it! In my opinion, the slip cover art and menu design on the British MGM DVD is also far superior to MGM's North American release.

The only catch, however, is that the British DVD release is of course in Region 2 PAL format, so you will require a DVD player which supports that particular region-coding and PAL format (I bought a multi-region DVD player from an online vendor over a year ago for under $100 and it works like a charm!).

The differences between the North American and British MGM DVD releases of "Nineteen Eighty-Four" are as follows:

* The North American MGM DVD is widescreen with an anamorphically enhanced 1.85: 1 aspect ratio; the color is brighter and more saturated.

* The British MGM DVD is also widescreen with an anamorphically enhanced 1.85: 1 aspect ratio; the color is desaturated to give the movie a decidedly gloomier tone.

* The North American MGM DVD features 20 chapter stops and runs 110 minutes in total.

* The British MGM DVD features 16 chapter stops and runs 106 minutes in total (I did not notice any cuts or scenes missing from the movie itself, perhaps the shorter length on this DVD is simply due to fewer credits tacked on at the beginning and the end).

* The North American MGM DVD has only one audio track: original English-language with the Muldowney-only soundtrack in MONO.

* The British MGM DVD includes an option of FOUR different spoken-language audio tracks to choose from: the Eurythmics/Muldowney soundtrack is featured on the original English-language and French-language audio tracks; it uses the Muldowney-only soundtrack for the German-language and Spanish-language audio tracks. All audio tracks on this DVD are MONO.

* The North American MGM DVD includes optional English, French and Spanish subtitles.

* The British MGM DVD includes optional English, French, German, Spanish, Dutch, Swedish, Finnish, Portuguese, and Turkish subtitles.

* The theatrical trailer on the North American MGM DVD is more subdued and features the soporific Muldowney score with a British announcer advertising the movie.

* The theatrical trailer on the British MGM DVD is flashier with the Eurythmics song "Sexcrime" blaring throughout and features an American announcer advertising the movie as "coming to a theater near you".

You can purchase the British MGM DVD from www.amazon.co.uk or any other online vendor for a reasonable price. Or you can check out the product website at www.mgmuk.com

Orwell's 1984 is a masterpiece of dystopian literature. A truly frightening look at a world that very well could have been and may still be yet to come. Michael Radford's movie is a nearly perfect adaptation, so much so that if you haven't read the book, it would probably help in understanding the complex nature of this movie. If you have read the book, you are in for a treat as the movie literally brings to life a perfect window view of the world described by Orwell.

The movie, along with the book, is a bleak look at a world dominated by the ultimate extreme of totalitarian regimes. Every aspect of people's daily life is controlled and monitored by the ever present INGSOC (English Socialist Party) and its masthead, Big Brother. The story is set in a decimated but recognizable London and revolves around the central character of Winston Smith. The basic premise is the will of one man to maintain his humanity against the overwhelming force of an inhuman system. I will avoid saying more about the story except to warn that if you are looking for light entertainment, this movie is not for you.

In short, this movie is brilliant in it own right, with riveting performances by both Richard Burton and William Hurt. The sets, cinematography and direction bring to life a fictional world in such perfect detail that I have no doubt that Orwell himself would have been astonished. Not since BladeRunner has a world been so convincingly portrayed in a movie. This movies imagery will haunt you and its story will stun you. 1984 is mesmerizing, terribly disturbing and utterly believable.

The movie 1984 is as dark and foreboding as Orwell's original book. John Hurt and Richard Burton depict Winston and O'Brien well. Hamilton makes for an excellent Julia. The performances of these actors make this film believable and quite effective. There are some great lines in this movie. The dialogue between Hurt and Burton towards the end might make you cringe (given the setting) but it is memorable.

The screenplay follows the book closely, and focuses on the most important passages, a necessity due to the time constraints of any movie. This movie is long, but how could one make a short version of this story worth watching? The lighting and soundtrack add to the atmosphere or dread and gloom.

The messages conveyed by the book emerge from the dialogue and performance of the actors. The sets it was filmed on match this mood aptly. This is a rare instance where the movie version of a great story is as worthwhile as the book it drew upon. Though it is depressing, it is a profound and unique film that all who appreciate fine cinematography should watch.

This movie, a favorite of mine, is one of the best film adaptations of a novel I've ever seen. While a film of roughly two hours can only hope to scratch the surface of a novel as complex as "1984", this movie provides a good distillation of the book. It's all here, from the book's oppressive atmosphere of hopelessness and paranoia, to its timeless theme of the individual against the system. 1984 is a visually stunning movie you won't want to miss, particularly if you liked the book. (WARNING: Several people I know who hadn't read the book prior to seeing the movie found it confusing and boring, so if you haven't read the book yet, you may want to put off watching the movie until you've done so.)

The acting is first rate. John Hurt does an excellent job as the protagonist, Winston Smith (?), who wages a futile yet heroic battle against Big Brother. And Richard Burton is masterful as the cold, sadistic party leader who interrogates and eventually breaks Winston. (Incidentally, this was Richard Burton's last film role, and the movie is dedicated to his memory.)

The music, composed in part by the Eurythmics (get the soundtrack; it's some of their best work), is haunting, and stays with you long after viewing the movie (Juuulllliiiiiaaaaa.....).

One interesting note: the movie was filmed in the year 1984, in and around London, the exact time period and setting of the novel.

Don't miss this movie. It's a modern classic!

Note: This is a review of the VHS version of 1984, NOT the DVD version.