149 of 171 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
crackling with humor and intelligence, January 12, 2010
This review is from: 36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A Work of Fiction (Hardcover)
Goldstein is well known for writing heady fiction that doesn't sacrifice on heart (The Mind-Body Problem, Properties of Light), but this book does both so magnificently it almost seems she's created a genre all her own. Cass Seltzer, the atheist with a soul, guides us on a romp through the religion and science debates that manages to be both the subtlest treatment of the subject I've yet seen and also ridiculously funny. Along the way, she also introduces us to the heartbreaking Azarya, a little boy you will not be able to resist, and the rollicking Roz, a glamorous wild-woman you won't WANT to resist. Cass, too, is eminently likable, making this one the most enjoyable groups of characters with whom to spend an afternoon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
81 of 92 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
almost persuaded by a marvelous read, January 17, 2010
This review is from: 36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A Work of Fiction (Hardcover)
Having taught a boy genius the fundamentals of musical composition, I found the descriptions of Azarya both accurate and inspiring. Goldstein's latest is one of the most enjoyable books I've read on the recent faith and reason discussions. It is also a splendid satire on academe, a fun novel with engaging characters (who are defined as much by the complexity of their ideas as by their personality traits), and a passionate defense of secular humanism, with excursions into such areas as Hasidic culture and the seductions of number theory (why 36? read the book!) The appendix alone is worth the price of the book: the clear deductive presentation of the 36 arguments allows theists, agnostics, and atheists many opportunities to clarify and organize their thought. (It should stimulate believers, especially, to seek "flaws in the flaws," assuming there are ones). These arguments are in splendid counterpoint to the more tumultuous "arguments" that constitute the main body of the novel.
Cass Seltzer's moving discussion of moral progress and the View from Nowhere almost persuades me. But in this pleasure-dome of the Golden Rule, I still hear "ancestral voices prophesying war." Beethoven wrote to someone: "I don't want to know anything about your system of ethics. Strength is the morality of the man who stands out from the rest, and it is mine." Could those terrifying words overwhelm Cass? Should he have debated Beethoven rather than the trendy neoconservative Findley?
Also, I am "almost persuaded" about the potential depth and vitality of a "third culture." As the humanities become increasingly absorbed into the necessary world of science, can they retain their traditional richness and vitality? This novel and other work of Goldstein encourage this hope.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
87 of 100 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
As is suggested of Cass's book, Couldn't the book be the appendix?, February 4, 2010
This review is from: 36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A Work of Fiction (Hardcover)
First the good news: The appendix, which includes the actual arguments for the existence of a god, is everything that the rest of the book is not: pithy, direct, accessible, amusing. I would love for that section of the book to stand alone. Alone and far away from the laborious, pretentious mess that comprises the body of the work.
As an atheist--a New Atheist, even--I went in to this work of fiction with the highest of hopes. After battering my head against pages of vapid, indulgent narrative, practically unbroken by anything like dialog, plot, or characterization, I gave up. How, you ask, can I judge a book that I did not finish? That is my judgment--it is unreadable (again, except for the excellent appendix).
I feel like a traitor writing this, but if you to want to read a book set in similar environs, centering on a similar topic, try John Updike's "Roger's Version." With its vivid characters, lush descriptions and lively dialog, it is a far more interesting and entertaining read (even though I profoundly disagree with Updike's theistic leanings).
And if you want to read great atheist writers, Salman Rushdie and Ian McEwan are among our finest contemporary novelists, and both are outspoken atheists. But their fiction does not often address atheist themes directly (nor should it--propaganda makes shoddy art).
What I await is a work of popular fiction with atheist themes that sparks and moves. So far the closest thing I know of to a contemporary example is Philip Pullman's fantasy trilogy "His Dark Materials." Surely now that the best-seller lists have been conquered by atheist nonfiction writers, atheistic fiction page-turners cannot be far behind?
I give Ms. Newberger Goldstein a great deal of credit for the work she put into this novel, for the courage it took to write it, and for her obvious intelligence and ability. But what ultimately results, for an average reader like me, are sentences so pregnant with apparent meaning that each must be tediously midwived. Without attractive characters to invite me in, a compelling plot to push me ahead, or intriguing dialog to pull me along, I just can't be bothered.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No