10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A more accurate title would leave out the word "greatest", July 26, 2000
This review is from: The 50 Greatest Movies Never Made (Paperback)
Did you ever see the Marx Brothers comedy A Day at the U.N.? How about the Roger Rabbit sequel where it turns out that Bugs Bunny is Roger's father? If you never saw these movies, don't worry--nobody else has, either. However, they are (or were) legitimate movie projects, well-chronicled in Chris Gore's book, The 50 Greatest Movies Never Made.
The book lovingly details 50 films which never got beyond the planning stages for various reasons. Many of them involved heavy Hollywood hitters, from Steven Spielberg (who helped to get the first ROGER RABBIT off the ground), to DOUBLE INDEMNITY director Billy Wilder (who brainstormed the aborted Marx Brothers film as well as a Laurel & Hardy comedy), to Alfred Hitchcock (who proposed a movie about a blind pianist whose sight is restored).
While the book is a fast-paced, popcornish read, the book's not-so-subtle point is to make film purists gnash their teeth at the thought of these potential film classics never getting made. For me, the book's only surprise was that they left out many of my favorites, including Buster Keaton's proposed take-off of Grand Hotel, Charlie Chaplin's The Freak (about a girl who sprouts wings), and an aborted Western starring The Beatles.
It's easy to cry about potential film masterpieces that never got beyond the planning stage. The trouble is that, like many real lost films that come to light after being re-discovered, they often turn out to be classics only if they remain lost. And considering some of the awful ideas which do make it to the light of a movie theater--as witness the recent bomb AT FIRST SIGHT, starring Val Kilmer as (shades of Hitchcock) a blind artist who regains his sight--maybe these movies have rotted in Development Limbo for some very good reasons.
That said, the book will be an eye-opener to novices who have never heard the term "turn-around," and brain candy for those who have seen awful ideas that *did* get made into movies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Was There An Editor?, July 5, 2000
This review is from: The 50 Greatest Movies Never Made (Paperback)
While I did enjoy this book somewhat, I was baffled by the overwhelming number of typos and factual errors contained within. This was an amazing distraction from the otherwise enlightening content that Gore's book provides.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Great idea, poorly executed..., May 22, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: The 50 Greatest Movies Never Made (Paperback)
Chris Gore was at his journalistic peak when writing and editing "Film Threat" Magazine. Then he sold out to Larry Flint. I believe that if Chris attempted this book a few years earlier it might be more of an honest endeavor. THE 50 GREATEST MOVIES NEVER MADE reads like tabloid journalism, and offers no serious or insightful cinematic commentary. Chris spends too much time talking about the stories behind the screenplays instead of addressing what makes them great. They are not presented chronologically, which might have helped his presentation. He could have grouped them by decades, prefacing his discussion of the screenplays with background information on the climate in Hollywood then. He rarely presents material from these unproduced screenplays, nor offers much insight in the form of quotations or interviews. The nature of his commentary leads me to question whether he actually read many screenplays he discusses. Further, several of his facts were not current. What should have been interesting quickly became boring and repetitive. Almost every chapter ends with an attempt at negative sarcasm on the film industry. I have no idea who the audience for this book is. Many people who would purchase a copy already know the stories, and probably have most of these screenplays in their collection. In addition, there are numerous free sites on the Internet that contain similar, if not more detailed and current, information on these projects. What should have been a memorable film book is reduced to a waste of paper in the age of the Internet.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No