Customer Reviews

ADVENTURES IN GENTLE DISCIPLINE: A Parent-to-Parent Guide (La Leche League International Book)

5 star:		(16)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

In writing Adventures in Gentle Discipline, author Hilary Flower says she hoped to write the book that she felt was missing from the vast array of parenting advice already lining bookstore shelves. She has succeeded in writing that missing book, one that allows parents to "honor [their] own expertise, feel less alone, craft a livable discipline plan, and work with [their] own personal trouble spots." Unlike books that insist upon a strict regime of parent-centered scheduling and punishments, but also unlike compassionate but vague suggestions that if we just love our kids enough, discipline won't be an issue, Adventures in Gentle Discipline offers a practical, experience-based guide to compassionate parenting that is both realistic and useful.
As in Flower's last book, Adventures in Tandem Nursing, her scientific background shines through in her ability to clearly organize and lay out information in a way that is accessible yet not dumbed-down. The first part of the book explains why and how the book was written, a process that involved corresponding with around 200 parents about their families' problems, practices, and solutions regarding gentle discipline. As a result, the tone of the book is "parent-to-parent," rather than the "I'm the expert, you know nothing!" tone found in so many parenting books. In reviewing the foundations of and motivation for gentle discipline and compassionate parenting, Flower gives readers a chance to reaffirm their own beliefs and renew their commitment to respect their own needs, as well as those of their children.
Flower also takes the time to do a little myth busting, explaining the difference between permissive parenting and gentle discipline, as well as how punishment does not really equal discipline. She reminds us that the goal of discipline and effective parenting is a child who is ultimately self disciplined, and that this requires giving children some space to experiment and make mistakes. She also devotes considerable space to pre-emptive discipline--in other words, avoiding common pitfallas and limiting certain no-win situations, such as taking a tired, hungry toddler to go, well, anywhere. In one of the many quotes and testimonials from real parents, one woman shares her practice of checking "HALT," or Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired. If her child was acting out of sorts, or if she knew they would soon be entering into a potentially trying situation, those were the first things she checked for.
A few of the many other areas discussed are how to engage children in meaningful ways rather than offering constant (over)stimulation and entertainment, giving toddlers the language to express their emotions in more constructive ways, respecting the importance of play, and giving children who need a physical outlet acceptible options. On the flip side, Flower devotes considerable space to the needs of parents. She acknowledges the reality of parental anger and frustration, as well as the difficulty of letting go of old ideas about how children should behave and what parents are "supposed" to do to make that behavior happen. The tone is consistently empathetic and pragmatic, which makes it easy for the reader to honestly review his or her own parenting habits without feeling defensive or judged. Adventures in Gentle Discipline is an invaluable resource for parents trying to place compassion and respect at the center of their parenting.

From my review at Hylands Homeopathy, Rx:Chat Motherhood (www.hylands.com/forums/): Sometimes it's easier to focus on the parts of parenting that don't work, the times that are hard and frustrating. In contrast, I've been enjoying reading Hilary Flower's book "Adventures in Gentle Discipline." It's subtitled "A Parent-to-Parent Guide," and one thing I love is that it's filled with stories and statements by real and actual moms. Sure, some of them come off as too saintly for me, the type of mom who never raises her voice, who unlike me never gets frustrated or impatient. But that's a small percentage, and balanced by personal essays near the end that are exruciatingly honest, whether about being raised with very strict discipline and threats of violence, or another by a mom who confesses hitting her child, even though she doesn't believe that anyone should ever hit their child.

I've liked opening the book to random pages and reading sentences like "There will always be someone to tell you that you are being too strict, and someone else to say that you are being too lenient." Don't we all need to hear reassurances like this along the way? The book is so down to earth, so understanding that as parents doing our best we try hard, but, as Flower writes, "No matter how proactive you are, you can count on parenting, childhood, and life in general to be messy anway."

Since I tend to be the kind of parent who gets frustrated and says things like "If you do that one more time you will never ever eat dinner at my table again," it's helpful to be reminded that fanciful ultimata like this just don't work (though they may feel good for the moment before my daughter keeps on rocking the chair on two legs, or smashing ranch dressing into the placemat, or whining, or whatever else she's been doing to drive me crazy). Flower reminds us to empathize, be gentle, and to extend the benefit of the doubt, but within a framework that still wants kids to behave and to listen to us. The many stories give us lots of possibilities to try.And what is gentle discipline? "Gentle Discipline means, quite simply, placing empathy and respect at the very center of your parenting." It may not be that different from what many of us do. However, I appreciate the chance to be reminded of my ideals, and to be supported as a parent by an author and book that itself is kind and unscolding, that is, a book that places empathy and respect at its center.

As the mother of 3, stepmom of 2, and grandmother of 3, I was most impressed with this book! When I was raising my family, most books contained the seemingly expert opinions of a single person; Flower has compiled wonderful, VARIED advice from dozens of parents. Their ideas depict the wonder, the joys, and the confusion involved in this complex job of raising happy, healthy, capable little people. The personal essays section had some great pieces: "Have Mercy on Yourself", "Not Easy", and "On Losing My Cool" contained so much wisdom! Highly recommended for new parents or seasoned veterans, this book will remind the reader to trust their instincts and be gentle---not just with their kids, but with themselves.

Hilary Flower has written a wonderfully down-to-earth and real guide to gentle discipline -- a book that every parent will be able to relate to and that every parent would benefit from reading.

Unlike some other books in this genre that leave you feeling like you could never measure up to the author's standards of parenting perfection -- and that can therefore end up taking a toll on your parenting self-esteem -- "Adventures in Gentle Discipline" is empowering and, above all, inspiring.

By reading about how real parents have found practical ways to apply the basic principles of gentle discipline to everyday situations that you, the reader, can relate to, and by including chapters about parenting mistakes and how you can get yourself back on track discipline-wise when those parenting faux pas inevitably occur, Hilary Flower gives her readers the wonderfully liberating message that you don't have to be perfect to be a parent (thankfully) and that it's normal for parents to learn alongside their kids.

Learning from the experiences of other parents can be invaluable, both in terms of helping us to come up with new ways of dealing with particular parenting challenges and in helping us to develop a unique parenting style that works for ourselves and our children. This book takes that approach by bringing together the experiences of the true experts on gentle discipline: parents who have used this discipline method.

I highly recommend this book to other parents.

Update: It's been three years since I got this book and wow. I had no idea how many truly bad and self-righteous parenting books there were out there. I have re-starred this book at a five, considering its unique contribution to the gentle parenting canon.

First of all, it's not sanctimonious. This book will not tell you about parenting magic. It will not tell you that it has all the answers. It will not tell you that there is an "easy" or "simple" answer. It will not tell you that spanking is child abuse (though obviously it does not condone spanking, it does not label people who have used or considered using spanking, which is such a welcome relief- finally, book that is gentle with parents as well!).

It is full of anecdotes by parents and practical advice. It devotes an entire chapter to when you and your kids are NOT on the Gentle Discipline wagon, which is probably how I re-discovered it when I was at my wits' end with my 3.5 year-old and 1-year-old. What a relief to read an entire chapter of parents talking about how they were losing their minds and felt like they'd messed up, only to be told that that's life and it's not an all-or-nothing game. It will tell you that there's a time for just saying "no".

Okay, back to the original review:

I really think this book's capacity for encouragement sets it apart from the other books.

This book is a wonderful book to have on hand when you are feeling discouraged or need energy to come up with creative ideas to discipline your children lovingly and gently. It is a great alternative to theory-heavy books or books that focus on our own emotional hang-ups as parents. Filled with anecdotes and stories of women's own struggles and successes, it introduces and elaborates on gentle discipline in a logical sequence of chapters.

If you want to know why you build a house the way you do, you buy a book on physics. If you want to know HOW to build a house, you buy a DIY book. This is the DIY book.

My only disappointment was that this book was very mother-focused, to the exclusion (it seemed) of fathers. There were precious few anecdotes by dads and almost no discussion of how fathers' special gifts could be used in the gentle family for effective discipline.

This book is a breath of fresh air! I have read dozens of parenting/discipline guides by dozens of "experts", and all of them have been unrealistic in some ways and very, very few of them address the real feelings many mothers experience. But this book is fantastic! Filled with the wisdom of many real-life mothers who share their honest feelings about parenthood, this book provides valuable ideas and advice for day to day living along with a realistic definition of what discipline is. This book addresses the different feelings parents may feel and the challenges they may face with compassion. Unlike other authors, Ms. Flower paints a realistic, hopeful, and compassionate picture of the parent-child relationship that recognizes the dignity and humanity of both parent and child.

This book is basically a collection of tips, stories and insights from parents. The philosophy presented in the book is one of respect for children and their needs and development. I have gained insight and a few tricks from reading the book. I am going to keep it around for when we run into rough spots. The best thing about the advice given is that it isn't a one size fits all. Children and families have different needs at different times. This book will help you develop your own tools to help your children grow into responsible and caring adults.

...from the typical "how-to" parenting book! The chapters on how to discipline MYSELF were so incredibly helpful; I found those chapters just when I was reaching the end of my rope with my preschooler and was feeling like a failure. When I was feeling like I could never live up to my mental image of what "gentle discipline" should be, to read (in their own words) how other real life parents struggle with their tempers was so comforting. I learned that I don't have to serene and saccharine-sweet to be a gentle mama.

Hilary Flower collected suggestions and strategies from lots of different parents and presents them here. She focuses on toddlers as she says that is what new parents need. As the first-time mother of a soon-to-be two-year-old, I agree! I have several books with sound philosophy but I think this is the book that has the best concrete strategies for dealing constructively with your little ones.

I wish I had had a book like this to read when I was raising my daughter. I love the way you describe gentle discipline as a process of communicating and loving, not as something you master and do perfectly. You capture the struggle mama's go through with empathy and describe the joy of the result so vividly. I will recommend this book to ALL my mamas. This is a real gift. thank you for your very human approach!!!!