Most Helpful Customer Reviews
490 of 527 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This is NOT a Tom Clancy book - complete fraud, June 15, 2011
I'm a huge Tom Clancy fan and anxiously awaited his new book. However its quite clear that this is not written by Clancy, and he has just lent his name to a moneymaking exercise. Its a thriller, and I guess its ok. But its certainly not a Tom Clancy book. Its let down in the details which Clancy always gets right. For example in the book a drug dealer lets someone shoot him with a .45 to test out a bulletproof coat, and he barely notices the impact. In the real world the kinetic impact would break his ribs. In another chapter a navy seal picks up two pistols and runs at his enemies firing them two handed, something counter to every military tactic known. In numerous little details the author gets it wrong, where Clancy consistently gets it right. For this reason I doubt very much if Clancy even proofread the thing before adding his name to it. In character development, plot development... its average. Not bad, its certainly readable, but pure garbage. I wish I had 3 thumbs so I could give it 3 thumbs down
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
317 of 343 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Tom Clancy did not write this poor-quality work., June 16, 2011
I made it to page 2 before seeing proof that this is another non-Clancy work. Here's a part of a sentence describing the Pakistan Special Service Group: (it isn't dialogue) "...an organization similar to the U.S. Navy SEALs, but, ahem, their operators were hardly as capable." 'Ahem'? Amongst non-dialogue description in a book not written in any 1st-person narrative? C'mon. I stopped reading at page 14, and I'm returning the purchase. I'm sure it might be an entertaining read for some, but it's obviously a low-quality work written by an author who writes the fictional equivalent of B-movies. I worked at a Border's for five years, ending in 2006, and I'd never even heard of Peter Telep until now. The entire Los Angeles Public Library System only shows two other titles of his, written in '95, and '99, neither of which I'd ever heard of. According to Telep's blurb on the book jacket, we're supposed to believe that this is Tom Clancy collaborating with an author who's works include "science fiction, fantasy, military action/adventure, and medical drama, and film, television, and video game tie-ins." Seriously? ATTN ALL CLANCY FANS: Save yourself the curiosity. This item would be a waste of money.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
258 of 279 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
What a mistake, June 16, 2011
I have been a Tom Clancy Fan since I first read Red Storm Rising. Over the years I quickly read all of the Jack Ryan novels, many of them multiple times. I can even say that I didnt mind Dead or Alive. Now to Against All Enemies. I knew that it was a collaberation when I bought it. Once I started reading the first chapter I realized that Tom Clancy had nothing to do with the writing of this book. The style is very different, there is none of the descriptive writing that is Clancy's style. The writing in fact is very poor and vague. For fans out there that are on the fence, if you are buying the book for the plot line, then thats fine. If you are buying it with the hope that the book is in any shape or form Tom Clancy, dont waste your money. If you are at the bookstore undecided, grab a copy with a quick starbucks, and read the first chapter and make your decision then.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|