5.0 out of 5 stars
Aaron Burr by Milton Lomask, November 14, 2009
This review is from: Aaron Burr: The Conspiracy and Years of Exile, 1805-1836 (Hardcover)
Best biography (most researched and cited) of Aaron Burr in print. I recommend it. Most biographies of Burr are slanted in favor of Jefferson and Hamilton; they are full of historical innacuracies and personal opinons of the writers. Most are heavily influenced by other prejudiced writers and historians. J. Parton and N. Schectner, however, are good. But Lomask had access to archives unopened until recently. He spent two years examining only the letters, diaries,newspapers and official records of the period. His writing is surgical. It is a consumate, well-balanced review of the life of Aaron Burr. [Also see "Fallen Founder," a new, well researched biography, but with a few arbitrary calls by the author.]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The wacky world of Aaron Burr, May 9, 2005
This review is from: Aaron Burr: The Conspiracy and Years of Exile, 1805-1836 (Hardcover)
This extremely compelling (and, unfortunately, out-of-print) biography picks up Aaron Burr's life after he killed Alexander Hamilton in U.S. history's most famous duel (which, by the way, took place in Weehawken, New Jersey, along the bank of the Hudson River) and after the conclusion of his vice presidential term. In fact, Jefferson and Burr were sworn enemies, and their mutual hatred only increased over time (Burr was vice president for only the first of the two terms that Jefferson served).
In 1805, the cash-strapped Burr, already widely considered a scoundrel, became basically a con artist, who attempted to raise money by telling people of means what they wanted to hear. To ambitious Americans, he was leading an army to "conquer" portions of the now-southern United States and Mexico, which were controlled by Spain, if and when the U.S. and Spain went to war. For those less aggressive, he was simply leading a group of pioneers to settle what were known as the Bastrop lands. The story he told to potential Spanish and British backers was quite different: he was raising an army to conquer "western" U.S. States bordering the Mississippi, which would then be allied to Spain or Britain (depending on whom he was talking to) although no one could ever prove that this was his real intention. While some of his backers and allies were sincere, others, like General Wilkinson, the "dictator" of New Orleans, and on the payroll as an agent from Spain, turned out to be an even bigger scoundrel than Burr, and betrayed Burr to Jefferson. When Jefferson began taking the threat of Burr seriously, an army was raised to defeat Burr's "army" which consisted of 60 to 100 men, women and children which could not have invaded a small island, not to mention an entire State.
Ex-Vice President Burr was then put on trial for treason, presided over by Chief Justice John Marshall acting in his capacity as a circuit judge, and, after hearing from 50 or so witnesses, a jury eventually acquitted him of all charges (thanks in large part to Marshall's instructions to the jury regarding the law). Burr than fled to Britain to escape his numerous creditors, and criminal charges in different states (including the murder of Hamilton). In Europe, he basically lived like a nobleman at night, and a pauper during the day. Eventually, he returned to the U.S. and, at a relatively old age, resumed his profession as a lawyer, but always remained in debt, and in search of a "get rich quick" scheme. Always, throughout his life, Burr stayed extremely close to his daughter, Theodosia, one of the few people who Burr ever truly respected. Late in life, he also developed relationships with the children of various women he had affairs with after his wife died.
Burr's life was incredibly bizarre, much stranger than fiction. Milton Lomask does an admirable task in trying to convey Burr's life, although I got the feeling that he grew maybe a little too sympathetic to his subject. Lomask, however, is not in the same class of biographers as, for example, David McCullough or Ron Chernow. That is why I believe the definitive book about this fascinating and complex man has yet to be written. I do, however, recommend Lomask's book about the second half of Burr's life, and I plan on reading his other biography about the first half.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No