“The tale of Mary Lincoln's mental derangement, her incarceration in a mental hospital, her release four months later, and her subsequent estrangement from her only surviving son forms one of the saddest chapters in the Lincoln family saga. When Jason Emerson wrote his revelatory study The Madness of Mary Lincoln
(Southern Illinois University Press, 2007), he utilized valuable new letters he had discovered. In the present volume, he makes available the text of those documents and the dramatic story of their recovery from historical oblivion. Emerson deserves the thanks of all Lincolnians.”
—Michael Burlingame, author of Abraham Lincoln: A Life
“Jason Emerson is a rising star in Lincoln studies, and this volume is further evidence that those of us who never tire of learning about the life and times of Abraham Lincoln are in his debt. This carefully crafted volume illuminates dark corners of Mary Lincoln's life and enhances our understanding of the First Lady after that night at Ford’s Theatre. —Michael S. Green, author of Lincoln and the Election of 1860
"Not only has Jason Emerson uncovered letters by Mary Lincoln, he has uncovered an entire manuscript by James and Myra Bradwell's granddaughter, who tried to use her privileged position to sell the story to the less-discriminating press of her day. It is good to have the Pritchard manuscript in print at last, after eighty hidden years-to have both its insights and its embarrassing sororal prejudices. Emerson, by unearthing a new landmark in the historical treatment of the tragic Mary Lincoln, helps to reconfigure how we view the tragic ex-First Lady." - James M. Cornelius, curator of the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum
"With this edited volume, Jason Emerson makes an original and valuable contribution to our scholarly understanding of Mary Todd Lincoln's later years. It succeeds and builds on the intriguing and fruitful detective work that the editor achieved in The Madness of Mary Lincoln
, which provided the most important and original insights into her later years that have been produced in at least the preceding generation. The result is a long-missing, yet vital puzzle piece that has long been missing that helps to complete our understanding of Mary Lincoln's commitment proceedings and her eventual release and final difficult years." -Kenneth Winkle, Thomas C. Sorenson Professor of American History, University of Nebraska-Lincoln
"The Dark Days of Abraham Lincoln's Widow: As Revealed by Her Own Letters. By Myra Helmer Pritchard. Edited by Jason Emerson. (Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press, c. 2011. Pp. xviii, 186. $19.95, ISBN 978-0-8093-3012-6.) Myra Helmer Pritchard lays bare the hidden story of Mary Todd Lincoln's brief confinement in an insane asylum through a series of letters between Lincoln and Pritchard's grandparents, James B. and Myra Bradwell. Held from publication by Robert Todd Lincoln's family, the 1927 manuscript depicts Abraham Lincoln's oldest son, Robert, as a selfish, conniving caretaker who wished to rid himself of his troublesome mother. Meanwhile, Mary Lincoln appears as an embattled woman neglected by the nation after her husband's death and unjustifiably sent by her son to an insane asylum in 1875. Only the BradwelIs remained true friends in her greatest time of need. As editor of Pritchard's account, Jason Emerson explains that the narrative acts much like a "defense brief against the notion of Mary Lincoln's insanity," as Pritchard attempts to vindicate her grandparents' role in Lincoln's release (p. xvi). Emerson's excellent recto notes counter Pritchard's rather biased tale, allowing the reader to quickly ascertain the inaccuracies and exaggerations of her chronicle. Reading these notes in conjunction with the reprinted letters, a more accurate account of Mary Lincoln's insanity emerges. Rather than an unjustly imprisoned former First Lady, one finds a woman overwhelmed by grief and neuroses, grappling with the shadows enveloping her mind. Robert Lincoln, the Bradwells, and Mary's sister Elizabeth Edwards struggled to find an adequate solution to Mary's mental instability, reassuring her that she was not insane but hesitating to press for her release from the asylum. Thus, despite Pritchard's careful shaping of the historical record, Emerson reveals through Mary Lincoln's few friends and relatives the sad truth of her insanity." --SARAH BISCHOFF, Rice University
(Sarah Bischoff The Journal of Southern History
In his The Madness of Mary Lincoln (2007), Emerson drew on much of the evidence he has compiled, edited, and annotated in this volume. This companion to that monograph contains both thevoice of Mary herself as well as an account of the (largely successful) contemporary efforts to silence her. Those wishing to retrace Emerson's detective work will find this illuminating.
(Patrick A. Lewis The Register of the Kentucky Historical Society
About the Author
Jason Emerson, the author of The Madness of Mary Lincoln, is an independent historian and freelance writer whose articles have appeared in American Heritage, American History, and Civil War Times magazines, Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society, Lincoln Herald, and Lincoln Forum Bulletin. He is writing a biography of Robert T. Lincoln, to be published by Southern Illinois University Press.