Customer Reviews

Abuelita's Secret Matzahs

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Abuelita (grandma) is descended from "crypto Jews" in New Mexico, people who hid their religion in the 15th and 16th Centuries when they left Spain for Mexico and the new Mexican territories. When her grandson, Jacobo, comes to visit around Easter time, he learns about her avoidance of pork and the secret flat tortillas (no yeast) she traditionally eats at this Springtime religious festival. Peculiar? Then Jacobo meets and plays with David. David's family also eats flat bread, lights candles on Friday night, and avoids pork. They are Jewish and celebrate Passover, not Easter. Jacobo, like David, asks a lot of questions. But unlike at a seder, there is no Ha Lachman Anya... abuelita keeps quiet. But after continued question, abuelita relents and tells him the story of hidden Jews. A lovely multicultural and historical story. The book ends with a recipe for Jacobo's favorite Sopa (although it is not a Passover soup since it uses leavened bread)

Jacobo's grandmother has a secret: she does things differently than his friends, never making his favorite sopaipillas with honey during Holy Week and celebrating some holidays differently. "It's the way of our family," she will only say when Jacobo asks her about the tortillas made without year - until one day she shares a family secret about their real heritage. Good reading skills will lend appreciation to this sensitive story.

Contrary to what another reviewer said, this book is about accepting and treasuring your family's heritage, not hating or hiding it. Crypto Jews represent a real chapter in Jewish history, and their story has not often been told.

This book is also a great choice for mixed-religion families; it sensitively portrays the choice Jacobo will face as he gets older and has to choose his own religious path, and it does so without a bias toward either Judaism or Christianity.

Thank you Sandy Sasso for another wonderful story for our children, and especially for those of us with Sephardic roots who have been left out of the conversation for so long. This lovely story reflects the emerging population of Conversos living in the Southwest and brings to light the conflicting traditions that have been buried for many generations. It also serves well our multicultural population, the foundation of America.

Even accepting that this book is targeted at very young readers, ABUELITA'S SECRET MATZAHS is sketchy in the way its story is told.

In fact, it is so sketchy that it virtually is worthless in conveying the history of those Jews who had hidden from Spain's Inquisition by concealing their religion.

There's a story here, an important story, but this author does not tell it.

This may be one of the most offensive pieces of anti-semtic trash I have ever read. This book teaches Jewish children that they should be ashamed of and hide their heritage, through the tale of a grandmother who denies her Judaism until her horrified grandson uncovers too much evidence to continue. I find it unlikely that the woman who wrote this book is really a rabbi, but if she is, she must have been ordained by an extremely reform, lax sect of judaism, or perhaps not Judaism at all. Keep your children away from this hateful offensive book.