From Library Journal
At age 79, author, Mark Twain scholar and editor, and explorer Neider (The Grotto Berg) was diagnosed with prostate cancer (PCa). Neider wanted to know as much as possible about his disease so that he could participate in making decisions that affected his health and survival. This memoir is the result of his persistently inquisitive approach, which led him to interview doctors as well as a half-dozen friends and relatives who had undergone various therapies for PCa. Selecting the best therapy for the disease is a complex decision for a patient to make. There are quality-of-life issues (incontinence, impotence, and morbidities associated with any given therapeutic model) that each PCa patient must consider for himself. Neider's clear, down-to-earth, informative, and compassionate memoir also provides a no-holds-barred portrait of the medical profession good and bad. It will make a fine addition to consumer health collections that also have Ralph Berberich's Hit Below the Belt (LJ 3/15/01) and Saralee and Robert Fine's Prostate Cancer (LJ 9/1/99), which are also helpful in guiding readers through the morass of PCa therapies and its associated jargon (Gleason scores and PSA readings, for example). [Unfortunately, Neider lost his battle with cancer on July 4, 2001. Ed.] James Swanton, Harlem Hosp., New Yor.
- James Swanton, Harlem Hosp., New York Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Noted Mark Twain scholar Neider was diagnosed with prostate cancer early in 1993, when he was 78. His intensely personal yet scientifically informed account of the succeeding two years of tests, treatment, and his own thoughts and emotions show him to have been fortunate in his doctors and nurses and, especially, in the strong support of his wife, Joan. Hardly the typical cancer patient, Neider had made three trips to the Antarctic and was a MacDowell Colony resident 10 times; indeed, some of this book was written there. Hardly the typical patient's account, Neider's supplements his own experiences with those of two cousins, several fellow members of support groups in New Jersey and California, and other acquaintances. With the diagnosis, Neider's doctor gave him three options: ignoring the cancer because of his age, surgery, or radiation. Neider chose the third--38 sessions' worth. Early in 1995 the doctor announced, "As far as I'm concerned, you have a cure!" Neider lived on until July 2001.
William BeattyCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved