Customer Reviews

Adobe Photoshop Forensics

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This book is an enjoyable treatment of this topic for the general reader. When reading it from that perspective, it provides a great overview of what any of us might see in our day-to-day lives - altered political photos, actresses on the Photoshop Diet Plan, falsified documents on the internet, etc. Seeing the examples in Baron's book can make us a little more aware and a little more skeptical of what we see in advertisements, newspapers, magazines, and the internet.

This book is not, however, a technical book for the forensics professional - nor does it claim to be. As an expert in imaging forensics, I was careful when reading this book to not judge it from the wrong perspective - this book isn't intended to be a reference for those in my field. But, it still is an enjoyable read with some good information. I didn't care for some of the anecdotal treatments, and I disagreed with some of the content - but since it was written for a broader audience, those became minor points. If this were a technical text, these would have been more important issues.

Does the book belong on the shelf of every forensic image analyst? Probably not - but it will be enjoyed by anyone who is curious about this field, or who wants to be a bit more savvy regarding the photos and documents we are confronted with every day.

This was a fun read: a very interesting blend of historical (such as forensics on Civil War era images) and/or real life situations (such as counterfeit money) blended with a compendium of Photoshop tricks and tips. I use Photoshop frequently for work and in college classes, and as always I'm amazed at how many features are packed into the program. The author is able to bring many of these features to bear in clearly worded, step-by-step examples (such as modifing the a model's image to remove blemishes and punch up the photo's visual qualities for a magazine cover). The book will appeal to multiple levels of Photoshop users, from beginner to advanced, and will also go down well with anyone with an interest in history. Nicely done.

This book just isn't well written.

It's focus is meandering. Sometimes it's talking about photoshop... other times it's talking about Sacco and Vansetti. not to say it's not interesting, it's just unfocused and tends to ramble.

It has too little information to be an informational book, it's not entertaining enough to be an internaintment book, and the few tutorials it offers are so spread out in level of difficulty that no one person would find it applicable to their skill set.

The title is also poorlly chosen. Only the first few sections of the book have to do with photoshop in a forensics sort of way. The rest is more focused on teh ways photoshop is used to misrepresent reality. (there is a meaty chapter on photoshop's use in retouching fashion photographs.)

"Adobe Photoshop Forensics" is billed as a guide to forensic examination images for manipulation, and subtly implies that you, too, can become a forensic investigator by studying this book . . . Not so much . . . It is, however, a fun read, and a backwards introduction on how to do effective, convincing image manipulation. I blew through it in about 24 hours, and I'm not asking for the time I spent on it back.

"Adobe Photoshop Forensics" is divided into four parts:
"Counterfeiting and the Law," covers not just counterfeiting of cash, but also counterfeit IDs, photos used for insurance documentation or court cases, and other legal-ish or money-ish issues.
"Professional Misconduct" covers propaganda and political images, photojournalism and editorial shenanigans, and science-related images.
"Body of Evidence" relates primarily to image manipulation related to the human body, with a small foray into compositing and composite images.
"Outer Limits" scoops up more fringe-ey fun with topics like faking UFOs, ghosts, and urban legends.
Each of the four part is divided into chapters and sections, with each section having at least one sample image that is analyzed, and/or manipulated step-by-step.

I'm Photoshop-challenged and so only skimmed the tutorials, but they appeared straightforward. However, it also appears that this would not be a good book to actually learn image manipulation in any kind of detail from - these are more examples of one way (the simplest?) that the desired results can be achieved.

Related to that, some of the sample images aren't large enough to really show the effects of the steps they are supposed to illustrate. The publisher's web page for the book has links for errata and other information, in zip files. It appears that the author shared this complaint, I see several comments in the errata that the pictures are too small. In fact, the errata is not so much errata, as a copy of the author's comments to the publisher. The second download does contain some images that help, but not two that are completely missing from the text (referred to in the text and skipped over in the illustration numbering). Sloppy editing, particularly in a book all about image manipulation.

Not all of the manipulated images shown are actually results of digital manipulation, as the author fits "photoshopping" in the overall historical context of image manipulation, and discusses how Photoshop has made certain tasks easier, and how today's ease of image manipulations affects (or should affect) our perception of images used in advertising, etc.

All in all, an amusing introduction to image manipulation.

This book contains some textbook material for undergraduate students. 17 year old youngsters may learn from this book about the ethics and the political, economical and social implications of those quick mouse strokes.

It is an easy reader about the past one hundred years of art forgery, counterfeiting legal tenders and image manipulation for political propaganda. For each topic you learn how much easier this can be done with digital image manipulation. As such it is entertaining.

From the jacket description of the publisher I had expected a method on discovering manipulations in digital photographs. For such purpose the book is useless, even as an introduction. I regret having ordered it and having wasted my cash on it.

The author has assembled the materials of the book with obvious delight in the subject. The publisher did no favour to the author with his misleading advertisement.

This book is a quick, easy, and mildy entertaining read. It just doesn't deliver much of what the title would lead you to expect.

This book was a fun and easy read for anyone who would like to see some real world examples of Photoshop fakery. It doesn't claim to be a technical manual for forensic professionals/students or to be a collection of detailed PS tutorials, and it is not. If you are looking for either of those things this is not the book for you. If you are looking for an entertaining look at examples of the subject matter this book it worth a read.

The product itself is great, but I was unable to track the shipment. Other than that, I am very satisfied with this purchase. Excellent quality for a used book. I needed this book for my college course, and it would seem a common complaint is that the book is "misleading", but since it really is intended more as a college textbook it is easier to understand when you are using it with a college class rather than just general reading material.

I am enjoying this book very much. It makes for a really good read. However, if the files for the book had been included or down loadable, it would definitely been 5 stars.