14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Transforming Christian theology, indeed!, January 7, 2010
This review is from: Adventures in the Spirit: God, World, Divine Action (Paperback)
After reading Philip Clayton's most recent book, "Transforming Christian Theology", I turned to this one, his previous book that he says represents perhaps the last of his books aimed at the academy. Right up front, I want to make clear that my area of intellectual competence is not in the natural sciences (which this book discusses extensively). As a religious studies major in college, I of course took basic general education courses in biology and physics, but this book went far beyond what I learned from those introductory courses. I am grateful for my inquisitive mind though, because if it weren't for my extracurricular readings in the religion/science debate, as well as in philosophy and theology, I would have given up on this extremely dense book within the first few chapters. Clayton is clearly blessed with a sharp mind, which is an observation that kept me reading. Anybody who reads the book need not have an advanced understanding of religion, theology, science, and philosophy, but an understanding/expertise in one or more is definitely needed to grasp what is going here.
Even when I felt overwhelmed by the heavy ideas of this book, I was propelled forward by the challenge, by the questions, and by the momentum Clayton infuses this book with. I frequently thought to myself, "This is a book filled with challenging and fresh ideas. Just keep reading." By the last half of the book, I realized my intuition was correct and the pieces started coming together. This book is absolutely stellar for those willing to take the plunge, posing profound challenges to the reductionistic neo-Darwinism of Dawkins, but also to rigid Christian traditionalism entrenched in outworn theologies. By the end of the book, emergent complexity makes a lot of sense about the world as we know it today. Clayton urges the Christian church to step out of their protective walls and REALLY engage the scientific community. Clayton shows that to take science seriously does not eliminate the possibility of Christianity, but perhaps breathes new life into it. This new, integrative Christianity that Clayton is a proponent of takes scripture, tradition, reason, and experience seriously (of course, progressively)....and in the process a faith that is rooted in the past emerges with new and helpful insights from its interaction with the sciences. Be prepared to have your orthodox creeds challenged, but relativists should also brace themselves. Clayton isn't out to offer easy answers, but neither is he out to discuss a squishy relativistic faith. Theologically, Clayton covers a lot of ground: the identity of Jesus, the Trinity, scripture, and especially divine action. Open panentheism, the core theological idea explored in the book upon which everything else hinges, emerges from the most recent developments with science and philosophy, and Clayton makes a pretty convincing case that it can exist within the Christian tradition in a unique and powerful way. Sacrifices are made, true, but he is convinced it is better than the alternative. He may, in fact, be right. On the other hand, the larger theological conversation about divine action that Clayton is contributing to with this book should be considered alongside of these ideas. Theologians such as Keith Ward, John Polkinghorne, Robert John Russell, Denis Edwards, and Ian Barbour have important insights about divine action to consider as well. But surely, Clayton has given us one of the finest examples of progressive theology for the 21st century with "Adventures In the Spirit."
I will be revisiting this book many times in the near future. I have much to consider as I continue to reflect on a more vibrant and relevant form of the Christian faith for a post-modern, globalized world. Academics should definitely read this book, as well as motivated students of philosophy and religion, such as myself. I look forward to a future book by Clayton that would explore these same ideas in a more accessible fashion similar to the most recent "Transforming Christian Theology". These ideas, and Claytons work in general, need to get into the hands of the pastor and layperson.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, October 13, 2010
This review is from: Adventures in the Spirit: God, World, Divine Action (Paperback)
Reading this book, I kept thinking of the conclusion of C.S. Lewis in his great essay "Fernseeds and Elephants" - try being critical of your criticism for a change. Clayton is the type of Christian theologian happy to question the physical resurrection of Jesus. But he seems to have little or no interest in criticizing the pet theories of university academics. The idea that truth should be based on "intersubjective discourse" (i.e., what university professors think) is not only foolish, it is dangerous.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No