Other Sellers on Amazon
Against the Current
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
This film definitely is effecting, and very beautifully shot. I liked seeing the changing scenery on the riverbanks from the point of view of being in the water. The movie contained alot of humor, and it was delivered naturally and realistically.
The scenes with Mary Tyler Moore were funny but uncomfortable as well, giving me a sense on one hand that whoever she was addressing was a sort of trapped insect that she could crush without a second thought, yet on another, sometimes seeming as though she would be quite shocked that anyone would think her malicious. I think her daughter was the permanently trapped insect.
I thought that in their own ways, Jeff and Liz were just as lost as Paul was, as in Liz's case, with a mother who never really saw her or listened to her. We hear that Jeff's parents are also very wealthy and similarly uninterested/disappointed in him. Other than this, the characters are not very well developed, to the film's detriment.
The film did stretch believability quite a bit. One day a guy decides to swim 140 miles of the river, and so he jumps in a wetsuit and off he goes, with no training whatsoever, and despite swimming miles each day, never appears to be even tired, let alone sore and exhausted. Even professional swimmers have to train for endurance events. I thought it was funny that in the last scenes after getting out of the water, his hair was dry.
I have to say that you would have to go far to find someone more self absorbed and selfish than Paul. I understood that he was grieving, but as Liz pointed out in a great scene, everyone suffers, everyone loses those that they love, and most people find a way to go on.Read more ›
Joseph Fiennes plays a widower still reeling from the death of his wife and unborn child years previously. Nearing the fifth year anniversary, he embarks on a crazy quest to swim the length of the Hudson River. Enlisting his closest friend (Justin Kirk) and, rather arbitrarily, a random acquaintance (Elizabeth Reaser)--they set off on an adventure. That's really about all--the film fleshes out the dynamics of this threesome with relative success while they share various moments along the way. The largest diversion is at Reaser's family home with some comedic mayhem provided by Mary Tyler Moore. This section, while sporadically funny, appears as if out of another film altogether. The shifting tone is both one of the film's strongest attributes and one of its primary weaknesses. Reaser is lovely and appealing and lightens things up quite a bit and Kirk has his wisecracking shtick down pat. I appreciated the interplay between Kirk and Fiennes and found them quite believable as lifelong friends.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
A downplayed, but outstanding portrayal of a quiet young man's calm determination to end his life. Thought provoking story line and acting. Beautiful photography. Read morePublished 17 months ago by Gary Biggs
I'm just not the kind of person who likes sad, depressing movies. The whole time I was hoping something good was going to happen but it never did.Published 22 months ago by Candle Light
THIS DVD is 1 hour 37 minutes and I'm writing the review even though I've just passed the 41st minute
What I like is the plot - simple enough: guy wants to swim the 300+ mile... Read more
I really enjoyed this movie. The whole story starts off a bit slow and I wasn't really sure where it was going. It slowly began to revele itself as a beautiful reflective film. Read morePublished on November 13, 2012 by mdyer
This movie covers a man still dealing with his grief from losing his family. After 5 years he decides to swim the lower Hudson. Read morePublished on December 6, 2010 by movementrec
It's never easy to show depression on film. Because depression is personal and unique to each person, to play a person suffering from long term depression is quite a challenging... Read morePublished on December 2, 2010 by Deenirose
This is an unpretentious film addressing the issue of whether suicide ever makes sense as a human choice. Read morePublished on November 28, 2010 by rlv
This is not a very uplifting movie, but one that makes us realize how differently we all deal with tragedy, grief and loss. Read morePublished on November 21, 2010 by Eric C.