58 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A worthy successor to the Age of Empires franchise, October 20, 2005
= Fun:4.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Age of Empires III Collector's Edition (CD-ROM)
Age of Empires 2 is my favorite PC game ever (see my review) but I've been anxiously awaiting the release of AOE3 since I read about it a couple months back.
Here's my first take of the game. I'll post an update in a month or two.
The Collectors edition is very nice; I personally think it's well worth the $20 extra if you're a AOE fan. A pocket strategy guide is included and provides pretty good information and is enough information for anyone who has played AOE2. (Saves $20 on the regular strategy guide). Read above for the other stuff included - but let me say that I think it's a heck of a deal.
My hardware - I play it on a P4 2.5 Ghz, 512 MB ram, ATI Radeon 9200 256MB. The game loads and plays fine. This game requires a massive video card to have smooth-scrolling during gameplay, and mine barely cuts it. If you can live with a little chop, it should play on almost any recent card. My laptop with Intel Integrated Graphics even plays it just the same without any problems (even though the card is not specifically supported by the game).
About the game - The neatest feature is called "home city". It gives each civ some certain advantages and creates a more challenging gameplay since not only do you have to collect resources for your colony, you also must send resources back home to mommy and daddy. Sending certain things gets you certain things in return; this is handled through the "cards". I'm not a big fan of the 'card' method because it reeks of Civ and other kiddie RTS games, yet the idea is good.
I've not yet tried any of the campaigns so I will not comment on them, but playing single player has been fun. The map is much smaller than AOE2, and I have yet to figure out how to change the size without adding more players (if it's possible to do so). The interface is 3-D and is very similar to Empire Earth and Age of Mythology. The buildings look very sharp and villagers need to mine silver, food, and wood. (I haven't yet seen stone).
There are lots of different military units; this gives a different dimension to gameplay although some (archers, calvary) are very familiar to AOE2. Work on gathering resources, building armies and buildings, trade, and barter with Native Americans (a new, interesting feature). Managing a home city also provides a different dimension that presents it's own challenges.
Comparing AOE3
1. Empire Earth II - I find EE2 overloads me with information. Just playing the game is almost too much work. It looks like AOE3 is quite a bit less complex although creating a huge village, fighting strong players, and managing a home city might prove to be a little more "challenge" than a casual gamer would like to take on.
2. Rise of Nations - I consider RON to be the real update to AOE2. It has a very similar look and feel to AOE2. I find RON to be too much about upgrading civs but if you set up the game to have only 4 civs the gameplay is almost exactly like AOE2 with better units and graphics.
AOE3 is very similar to Age of Mythology in game play. I was not impressed with that game so after playing AOE3 a while I'll have a better feel for how long it holds my interest.
Complaints - My main complaint about AOE3 is the graphics size. I love huge screens and small resolutions (1280x1024 or larger) but the game characters seem way too large, like the game is being played in 800x600. I hope that ES fixes this in a update or future version. I much prefer the size of the Rise of Nations characters, even if it involves a little less detail.
All in all, my early judgement of the game is that of a winner. I only give 4 stars though because of the resolution size. I'm also leery of the 'cards' system for shipping back things to the home city. If I wanted to play a 'turn-based' game I would have looked elsewhere. Hence, I'll reserve final judgement until I get to play with the game more.
I would say that anyone looking for a true updated AOE2 should look at Rise of Nations in addition to this game. I'm probably not alone in saying I would be more than happy to buy another update to AOE2 with more CIVS and a RON graphics look and feel.
Good luck and happy gaming.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excelent choice, October 30, 2005
= Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Age of Empires III Collector's Edition (CD-ROM)
As a fan of this kind of games and an owner of previous titles and similar games like Command and Conquer and Empire Earth series, I can say this game is great, the visuals are amazing, and in some aspects this game is more realistic, for example:
An unit which uses a gun, in any preious game this unit will fire his gun even when the enemy is close in this one it will just take out a sword and use a diferent attack, also you can command your units not to use the gun and use its melee attack instead.
The visual are great, when a cannon ball hit a building or when you hit infantry and you see them flying around.
The game play is similar to this kind of games but you have to activate options to enable use of formations or diferent tactics.
I also the like the option where your home city sends you supplies, men, boat, artillery etc.
I have it running in my laptop and i have not have any single problem so far, and i am not using any patch i am using the game as it came from the box so i don't share this kind of comments where people say the game doesn't works, because it does :)
Get the game if you like this kind of games and if you have a computer which has the requeriments you won't be dissapointed
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining though it's a bit of a letdown, December 5, 2005
= Fun:3.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Age of Empires III Collector's Edition (CD-ROM)
I've been a fan since AoEII and I must admit that I was fairly stoked when this game was first announced.
I went ahead and purchased the limited edition and was extremely impressed with the packaging. It's a nice box and the art book and soundtrack more than made it worth it.
Now onto the game. I'll be honest and say that I am not the biggest fan of 3D games as a whole as I feel that in the attempts to transition from 2D that most companies rush their products and the ends are just...not so good. AoEIII unfortunately feels that way. The graphics are beautiful without a doubt, but play mechanics could have been improved. Unit graphics and animation on the other hand is a bit weak and stilted. Also, given that this period of history (despite how important it is) is not so interesting in terms of military and historical points makes it less than interesting.
Certain aspects were also strange. I am of course referring to the trade posts that (as they get upgraded) can accomodate trains. However, the train just randomly appears then terminates from blank points which kind of reduces the realism. The fact that you can walk your army through a train passing through (which would otherwise scrap your army instantly in C&C: Generals) is kind of odd. The inclusion of the Ottoman is a nice touch, but their involvement in the storyline is...weird.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No