Agent Orange on Trial: Mass Toxic Disasters in the Courts, Enlarged Edition [Paperback]

Peter H. Schuck (Author)

Book Description

Publication Date: March 15, 1988 | ISBN-10: 0674010264 | ISBN-13: 978-0674010260 | Edition: Revised

Agent Orange on Trial is a riveting legal drama with all the suspense of a courtroom thriller. One of the Vietnam War's farthest reaching legacies was the Agent Orange case. In this unprecedented personal injury class action, veterans charge that a valuable herbicide, indiscriminately sprayed on the luxuriant Vietnam jungle a generation ago, has now caused cancers, birth defects, and other devastating health problems. Peter Schuck brilliantly recounts the gigantic confrontation between two million ex-soldiers, the chemical industry, and the federal government. From the first stirrings of the lawyers in 1978 to the court plan in 1985 for distributing a record $200 million settlement, the case, which is now on appeal, has extended the frontiers of our legal system in all directions.

In a book that is as much about innovative ways to look at the law as it is about the social problems arising from modern science, Schuck restages a sprawling, complex drama. The players include dedicated but quarrelsome veterans, a crusading litigator, class action organizers, flamboyant trial lawyers, astute court negotiators, and two federal judges with strikingly different judicial styles. High idealism, self-promotion, Byzantine legal strategies, and judicial creativity combine in a fascinating portrait of a human struggle for justice through law.

The Agent Orange case is the most perplexing and revealing example until now of a new legal genre: the mass toxic tort. Such cases, because of their scale, cost, geographical and temporal dispersion, and causal uncertainty, present extraordinarily difficult challenges to our legal system. They demand new approaches to procedure, evidence, and the definition of substantive legal rights and obligations, as well as new roles for judges, juries, and regulatory agencies. Schuck argues that our legal system must be redesigned if it is to deal effectively with the increasing number of chemical disasters such as the Bhopal accident, ionizing radiation, asbestos, DES, and seepage of toxic wastes. He imaginatively reveals the clash between our desire for simple justice and the technical demands of a complex legal system.

This is a book for all Americans interested in their environment, their legal system, their history, and their future.

Editorial Reviews

From Library Journal

Agent Orange, a defoliant contaminated by the highly toxic dioxin, has stirred public interest on many levels. Schuck (Yale Law School) brilliantly tells the story of the class action suit brought by thousands of Vietnam veterans against the chemical companies that manufactured the herbicide. He probes deeply into the strategies of plaintiffs' lawyers, the novel defenses invoked, and the sitting judge's role. He not only tells of the legal questions involved and the practical ways they were addressed, but describes the bickering between the veterans' lawyers and the jockeying for preeminence in a case that potentially was worth billions. For general readers as well as scholars, this is a fascinating trip through the complexities of the law and the all-too-human response by all concerned. Daniel LaRossa, Connetquot P.L., Bohemia, N.Y.
Copyright 1986 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.

Review

A blow-by-blow account of the ferocious six year legal battle...In vivid, behind-the-scenes anecdotes, Schuck portrays the primary actors--judges, lawyers, clerks, and individual veterans--in a Dickensian drama of personality clashes, misguided idealism, power struggles, greed, immeasurable suffering and bitter disillusionment. (USA Today )

An engrossing tale of naive, angry veterans, their crusading, often self-serving lawyers, well-heeled chemical companies, and both ineffective and brilliant judges...Schuck relates this complex drama with colorful, novelistic detail, while always keeping present the essential purpose of his book, which is a critical analysis of the evolution of tort (personal injury) law in times of mass toxic disasters (asbestos, Bhopal, etc., as well as Agent Orange) and the growing use of class-action lawsuits to deal with them. (Los Angeles Times )

Extraordinary...In addition to providing a clear, easily grasped, but sophisticated summary of the evolution of tort law, [Schuck] shows how the Agent Orange case was a great morality play, a cathartic drama about the Vietnam War and about America's dismal treatment of the soldiers who fought it...These pages offer the finest in investigative journalism and are destined to join the ranks of classics in legal literature...It is a first rate introduction to the world of tort law, a tour de force of legal narrative, and a deeply thoughtful consideration of policy reform. (Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law )

[Schuck] brilliantly tells the story of the class action suit brought by thousands of Vietnam veterans against the chemical companies that manufactured the herbicide. He probes deeply into the strategies of plaintiffs' lawyers, the novel defenses invoked, and the sitting judge's role...For general readers as well as scholars, this is a fascinating trip through the complexities of the law and the all-too-human response by all concerned. (Library Journal )

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Paperback: 376 pages
• Publisher: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press; Revised edition (March 15, 1988)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0674010264
• ISBN-13: 978-0674010260
• Product Dimensions: 8.9 x 6 x 0.6 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #514,114 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Discover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.