Most Helpful Customer Reviews
49 of 51 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Compelling book!, June 13, 2006
This review is from: Agincourt: Henry V and the Battle That Made England (Hardcover)
On October 25, 1415, English King Henry V stood facing a French army that outnumbered his six thousand men by as much as five to one. The campaign that would culminate on the field in northern France in proximity to a castle known as Agincourt had started with an English invasion of France and the capture six weeks earlier of Harfleur, the highly valued strategic port in Normandy.
Henry was exercising what he deemed his god-given right to recapture the lands of northern France that were lawfully his by hereditary claim.
In Agincourt, author Juliet Baker has done yeoman's work in researching the historical record of French and English archives, and previous texts written by eyewitnesses and contemporaries of the time. The book is divided into three main parts detailing what circumstances lead the young English King to his expedition; what took place once the fleet had landed, including the siege of Harlfleur; and the confrontation at Agincourt.
Lastly Barker details the battle's aftermath and the serious impact the loss of an entire class of French nobility had on the French people and the English dominance of the region.
The account of the battle has been told many times, but with recent forensic studies and technologies available, the true impact of this disastrous loss by the French finally becomes known.
Chivalry was at its height. This dictated that the initial waves of the French attack were composed primarily of nearly every noble Prince, Duke, Baron and Knights from northern France. As is well known, the use of the deadliest of medieval weapons--the English longbow--has been given as the main deciding factor for the wholesale slaughter which the French suffered in a few hours time on the battlefield.. Those that were not slain or mortally wounded were captured and taken to England until their ransoms could be raised. Many were eventually released, but in fact many never returned home.
Juliet Barker's compilation of the facts of the English victory at Agincourt will stand as one of the truly great resources for generations to come.
Armchair Interviews says: Any military historian worth his salt should feel compelled to read Agincourt.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It was a different world, August 26, 2006
This review is from: Agincourt: Henry V and the Battle That Made England (Hardcover)
I've been interested in Agincourt from high-school medieval history when we were told, tho' not quite accurately, how Englishmen with their longbows, eventho' greatly outnumbered, defeated the French armored knights and changed the practice of warfare. Then forty-some years later, I saw Branagh's 1989 film of Shakespeare's Henry V and was stirred by the king's Crispin's day speech the morning of the battle. So I ordered Barker's book before it was released in the US and when it arrived, first read Chapters 14 & 15 about the battle itself, then Chapters 9 thru 18 about the whole campaign and its aftermath, and finally Part I `The Road to Agincourt'. But rather than impulsively reading about the battle first, I'd now recommend reading the book from the beginning to understand the battle's background.
It's a fascinating book which Barker has thoroughly researched in order to give a comprehensive context. But she gives more details than I wanted to know about many of the players, their names and lineages, including many of those killed in the battle. I found it confusing trying to follow who was supporting, opposing or betraying whom, since I'm not intimately familiar with the geography and aristocracy of England and France (the book was first published in England). What it illustrates was the medieval mentality regarding land and nobility which wouldn't begin to change until 260 years later when in America it was proclaimed "... that all men are created equal ..." It also portrays their unquestioned belief in God's Providence which for many today still hasn't changed.
On the other hand, she also explained many interesting details about the preparations for the campaign and contemporary technology. For example, I was pleased to learn how longbows and arrows were made and used (pages 86-9) and how an arrowhead, lodged six-inches deep into Henry's face during the battle of Shrewsbury, was extracted afterwards (pages 31-2).
A seeming inconsistency is that the battle and the book are referred to as `Agincourt', but the castle near where the battle took place is called `Azincourt'. After the battle when Henry asked the French herald the castle's name, Barker quotes Henry on page 296 as saying (in French?) "... this battle will now and for ever be known as the battle of Azincourt." That's how it's spelled in National Geographic's Atlas too, but she doesn't explain how it got Anglicized to Agincourt.
This book is a tribute to Henry V. Having read Barker's account of Agincourt, I'll have to get the DVD of Branagh's film and rewatch it with much greater understanding.
A warning: After reading this hardcover book, I loaned it to friend and when she returned it months later, the spine was cracked its full lenght seperating the pages into two booklets. She's a gentle person who doesn't abuse books, so I examined the crack carefully. Apparently to save a pittance, the printer/binder didn't use a backstrip! So be careful.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great History and Great Writing, July 10, 2006
This review is from: Agincourt: Henry V and the Battle That Made England (Hardcover)
A beautiful narrative overview of Henry V and Agincourt. Highly readable and very informative. Enough detail to bring this era to life for those with little background in it, yet not overwhelming in terms of detail. The author does a wonderful job bringing many of the important personalities to life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|