Customer Reviews

Agnes Grey - Illustrated

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Anne Brontė, the neglected sister, deserves to be read by anyone who likes JANE EYRE and WUTHERING HEIGHTS. Actually she reminds me more of Jane Austen than she does of her sisters. This novel lacks the gripping Gothic elements that are so prominent in the major works of Charlotte and Emily, but it does give an excellent picture of real life in the Victorian era.

Miss Grey holds the position of governess in two wealthy households, the kind of position that Anne Brontė knew very well, since she herself worked as a governess. It is a very awkward position, since the governess may well be the most intelligent person in the place, but she occupies a lower social status and cannot associate on an equal basis with her employers and their well-to-do guests; yet she is not a servant and therefore cannot freely socialize with the maids and cooks. If the children are tractable and if the parents are supportive of her efforts, the governess can feel a sense of accomplishment and pride. However, such an ideal condition does not exist in either of Agnes Grey's pedagogical situations, making her life a constant struggle, which she somehow manages to accept and to persevere with admirable equanimity.

The novel provides an insightful picture of social class distinctions, very convincing, if a bit one-sided. Our heroine is a deeply religious, but quite tolerant young lady who grows laudably with her experiences, developing a sure instinct to govern her actions expediently within the narrow confines of her niche in life. A growing love for a kind and conscientious young clergyman tests her emotions greatly, however, especially when she sees one of her beautiful young charges shamelessly attempt to ensnare him just to prove that she can do so. Eventually the plot ends in the desired way, although a bit abruptly.

The writing style is very direct and clear. The characters are exceedingly well drawn and consistent throughout. The dialogue is always believable and well worded. I recommend that readers give this younger sister a chance to prove her rightful place as a true and worthy Brontė novelist.