Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Use and Abuse of Air Power, April 13, 2004
This review is from: Air Power: The Men, Machines, and Ideas That Revolutionized War, from Kitty Hawk to Gulf War II (Hardcover)
I'm always a little wary of long history books written by journalists, who sometimes present history as a tedious interview of various "sources." Stephen Budiansky, a correspondent for the Atlantic Monthly, is a happy exception to the rule. His prose is clear and crisp, and he tells an engaging story in a way that kept drawing me back to his rather hefty "Air Power." Budiansky begins his book by explaining why the accomplishments of the Wright Brothers were so remarkable. He then renders a detailed history of the military uses, both real and imagined, of aircraft. The result is a story of a rapidly emerging technology told against the background of the military theories of the 20th and early 21st century. Throughout his book, Budiansky takes issue with the views of theorists and generals who claimed that air power could be a "war-winning" weapon, either because it could be used to terrorize civilian populations into surrender or because it could cause rapid economic collapse by striking at the chokepoints in an enemy's supply system. The author argues that, with very few exceptions (such as the interdiction of German oil supplies in the last year of World War II), air power has not performed very well as a strategic tool and has always been far more effective when used as a tactical weapon in support of forces on the ground. In this sense, the Second Gulf War in Iraq can be viewed as the apotheosis of the effective use of air power: with the advent of readily available precision weapons, even "strategic" aircraft such as the B-1, B-2 and B-52 bombers have been used to great advantage in the role of close support of ground troops. In the aftermath of the opening phases of the Second Gulf War, air power is for the moment ascendant on the battle field. But if there is anything to be learned from Budiansky's meticulous history, it is that military innovation is a very Darwinian business. Plenty of bright people are studying the successful American and British invasion of Iraq, trying to make sure that the air power strategy used in that conflict will work just as well in the next war--or, for those worried about being on the receiving end, trying to prevent that strategy from working at all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A terrific survey, May 1, 2004
This review is from: Air Power: The Men, Machines, and Ideas That Revolutionized War, from Kitty Hawk to Gulf War II (Hardcover)
As someone with four decades of professional experience with air power both as a military planner and aerospace engineer, I was initially a little skeptical about a survey to be written by a professional writer with no direct background. In fact, however, Stephen Budiansky's book, is an extremely impressive accomplishment -- it is hard to imagine that anyone could do it better. It is very thoroughly researched and sets a high standard for accuracy and thoroughness, but never gets bogged down in the details. Budiansky fashions his immense collection of data into a coherent and fascinating story, alive with real people and vivid action. There is always a sense of purpose and direction to his narrative and the reader never feels lost. The high quality of the research and writing is matched by the quality of the book's production. Its nearly 100 photos are well selected and very finely reproduced on high-grade glossy stock. Budiansky's concise, clear, and accurate explanations of battles and technologies are illustrated with well-drawn maps and diagrams. As specific aircraft are discussed, they are represented in the margins in clear drawings and basic data. Rather than clutter the text with footnotes, the extensive references are collected at the end, in a format which makes it easy to locate the source of every quotation and important piece of information. A bibliography of more than 500 items testifies to the author's thoroughness as well as providing easy routes to finding additional information. In every way, this is a great deal of book for the money, particularly at Amazon's price. Books about air power seem as common as clouds, and most have about as much substance. This one is a great exception, a volume packed with solid information, presented in a consistently clear and interesting manner. Will O'Neil PS. As a matter of full disclosure I should note that I am mentioned among Budiansky's acknowledgements. In reality, I played a very modest role in it, restricted to providing some research information and advice. It is in no sense my book, and I would not hesitate to criticize it if criticism were warranted. It is not.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
War and Peace, January 8, 2009
Before the Wright Brothers ever flew, authors like HG Wells were predicting that vast destruction would be wrought from the air in any future conflict. This is the story of how aviation technology slowly, fitfully came to deliver on that promise. From the first short hops at Kitty Hawk, Budiansky takes the reader from the anticlimactic debut of heavier than air craft in the Italo-Turkish war to the awesome power of the USAF during the two Gulf Wars. Without neglecting the obvious great battles and aircraft, he emphasises crucial peacetime developments, in both aircraft design and the equally important realm of tactics and strategy, that did so much to shape how wars were fought. The book has some minor flaws. British and American development of such technologies as the jet engine, radar, and swept wings are given exhaustive treatment, at the end of which we are informed that, by the way, the Germans had also made these inventions years before. It is also unfortunate to end any piece of writing with the statement "Rumsfeld was right". While the second Gulf war was a technological and military triumph, we are given no hint of the morass Iraq was to become or how ineffective all weather medium level precision bombing is against an urban insurgency. But these jarring notes are insufficient to spoil a masterpiece. Budiansky leaves us with the irony that air power has achieved its greatest success in the battlefield role that ambitious officers have been trying to escape since the beginning.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|