54 of 61 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
SPECTRUM Children's Book Club GOOD READ!, November 24, 2004
When the initial PR on a book is about how much the publisher is going to spend on marketing the book, I feel it's fair game to factor this information into the review. Orchard Books ( a division of Scholastic) is positioning a British import, CHILDREN OF THE LAMP: THE AKHENATEN ADVENTURE, as the first installment of another flagship franchise. Two more books have been contracted and Dreamworks has purchased the film rights. Could it be another Harry Potter? Well...no. But CHILDREN OF THE LAMP if filled with potential.
THE AKHENATEN ADVENTURE has the scope of an epic adventure, moving rapidly from New York, to London, to Cairo, to Russia, and even to the polar ice cap. It's opening earthquake sequence in the Egyptian desert with a native artifact hunter and his son is evocative of an Indiana Jones adventure. It's London museum crime caper calls images of Thomas Crown or maybe Artemis Fowl.
The book is also populated by interesting characters including twins who are unaware of their destiny, an adventurous uncle, a one armed butler, and two dogs with a past. Like Harry, twelve-year-old John and Philippa Gaunt discover that they are not ordinary. When both have an early arrival of wisdom teeth, the truth of their heritage starts to emerge - they are part of a powerful clan of Djinn. Unlike Harry, however, the reader may find it hard to empathize with the twins who live in Manhattan, in an extremely privileged family, and seem to be spoiled beyond reason. Also like the boy wizard, the twins find themselves to be central characters in a great battle of good and evil - or more accurately, good luck and bad luck. You see, Djinn control all the luck in the world, and a population balance between the "good" and "bad" Djinn clans is essential to a smoothly functioning world.
There is also great potential in the magical world P. B. Kerr creates. The Djinn world is refreshingly different from the now overworked world of wizards and witches. Interesting ideas like what is life like inside a bottle? It is perhaps the set up of this world, however, that most directly keeps THE AKHENATEN ADVENTURE from our RECOMMENDED list. Kerr spends so much time having Uncle Nimrod explain the rules the Djinn world, and it takes so long for the twins to be come the active agents in the story, that the book fells like a very long prologue to a potentially excellent story.
On a more personal note. I am not a stickler for political correctness, but I had a problem with the part smoking plays in the story. I can understand its presence in principle, but it really is not crucial (at least in this book), particularly to the detail of naming brands. And this brings up another "what were the editors thinking" aspect of this book. It is filled with product placements. Do corporations now pay publishers for placements like they do film producers? Or is this a concession to the film deal already in place?
Reservations aside, I do look forward to the next installment, and I hope the trilogy lives up to potential.
SPECTRUM Children's Book Club - www.incwell.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Flat and Empty, December 13, 2004
AA is another overhyped children's book, attempting to grab a little of that Harry Potter sales magic. It starts with a reasonably promising premise - twins who discover that they are half-djiin - and has a reasonably well-thought out story. The problem is that it is all artificial. The author (a successful adult fiction writer) has no feel for the genre, and consequently the children are rather wooden, the humour forced, and there is no sense of wonder. Add to that the rather cynical elements such as setting the opening in New York and the slightly offensive names given to some of the foreign characters and you have a disappointing, bandwagon-jumping, pudding. Publishers and authors would do well to remember that we love Harry Potter because we sympathise and empathise with Harry, Hermione and Ron, and because they are tales of friendship, loyalty and courage. Our favourtie stories have heart and soul: it's not just a question of ticking off the ingredients on a childrens' book recipe.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An original fantasy series full of magic and adventure, October 22, 2004
John and Philippa Gaunt are the most unidentical twins ever. They don't look one bit alike or even wear the same colors. They do, however, think in similar ways. Their parents are wealthy, and another odd pair. Mrs. Gaunt is young, beautiful, tall and athletic. Her husband is very short with gray hair and glasses.
The twins would like to change the names of the family dogs from Alan and Neil to Elvis and Winston. Despite Mr. Gaunt's strenuous disapproval, they get their mother's permission. Somehow it doesn't seem all that unusual that the dogs take themselves to the vet when they're sick and put coins in parking meters. But the twins do find it odd that, when their wisdom teeth are removed, they share a dream under anesthesia --- a dream in which they meet their estranged Uncle Nimrod, who suggests they ask their parents to send them to London to visit him for summer vacation. Amazingly, their parents agree. Even more incredibly, their father acts rather afraid of his children.
Other weird things have happened to the twins lately. John had a nightmare and woke up to find the mirror on his wall cracked in the identical way that a wall in Cairo cracked during an earthquake. John's pimples cleared up. When people wish out loud around Philippa, their wishes mysteriously come true. But the most startling event of their lives will occur when Uncle Nimrod tells them who they really are. John and Philippa are off for a tremendous adventure, which will include traveling to Cairo, the Arctic Circle, and to the inside of a vase (!). They'll also fight evil for the good of mankind, giving them quite a bit of material for those "What I Did for Summer Vacation" school essays.
I wholeheartedly recommend THE AKHENATEN ADVENTURE to anyone who enjoys fantasy. This is not a Harry Potter knock-off (thank goodness), but is totally original and every bit as much of a great read. I can't wait to get my hands on the next two books in the trilogy. I'm sure they'll be, as this one is, the answer to my wish for a magical reading adventure.
--- Reviewed by Terry Miller Shannon (terryms2001@yahoo.com)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No