Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Vintage Jack Vance- highly recommended!, June 29, 2003
This review is from: Alastor (Paperback)
This collection of 3 novels shows Vance doing what he does best- creating detailed & exotic worlds with unconventional social systems, and telling an engaging story through interesting characters. 'Marune' finds a man without a memory- he slowly learns who he is, and who had stolen his mind and why. The answer leads him into Machiaviellian intrigue in a remarkable land of subtle noblemen. 'Trullion' is a water world with a mania for a competitive sport known as Hussade- and Glinnes Hulden has more to worry about than keeping his team together. All is not well among the deceptively tranquil islands. 'Wyst' is a look at a perfectly egalitarian society that is by no means a Utopia. "The trouble with Utopia is people". This book is worth the price for the settings alone- Vance is the best creator of imaginative and vibrant worlds. The plots are interesting as well- icing on the cake. Vance is a master science-fantasy stylist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good read, September 24, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Alastor (Paperback)
Alastor is a compendium of three novels set in the same science fiction universe: Trullion:Alastor 2262 (first published in 1973), Marune:Alastor 933 (1975), and Wyst:Alastor 1716 (1978). The name Alastor refers to a political entity of 3000 worlds comprising trillions of humans all ruled by the Connatic, a benevolent autocrat. Each story is centered on a particular world of Alastor, each with its own peculiar customs, a staple of Jack Vance's writings. Trullion is the weakest of the three stories. Unlike most of Vance's stories, this one never captures the attention of the reader. The wrap up of the murder mystery that is central to the plot is unconvincing as are some of the more arcane plot twists. It should be mentioned that the plot outline of Trullion in the book description above, as well as on the back of the book itself, bears little resemblance to the actual plot. Trullion is about a man who leaves his home to serve in the Connatic's space navy and returns years later to claim his rightful inheritance. Marune is a typical Vance story. The protagonist is a sympathetic character and the world of Marune contains all of the bizarre social conventions that one expects from Vance. My only complaint is that he pulls a deus ex machina to resolve the story. Wyst is a blatant critique of communism. Vance has a grand time ridiculing the inherent contradictions of a society that attempts to enforce a radical brand of 'egalism'. One aspect that makes this story unusual is the personality of Jantiff Rovenstroke, the protagonist. For much of the story Jantiff is a weak willed, unsympathetic, character. Towards the end, he is forced to fend for himself and surprisingly demonstrates much ingenuity and self-reliance. This transformation makes Wyst the best of the three Alastor stories.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Three worthy tales from Jack Vance, August 13, 2009
This review is from: Alastor (Paperback)
Jack Vance is the author of over fifty novels plus scores of short stories. With an output like that, there's guaranteed to be some variation in quality. The Alastor books are not masterpieces like the Demon Princes series or the Cadwal trilogy, but they are still good in their own right. In this trio Vance aims less for thematic elements than for entertainment. The Alastor novels are definitely crowd-pleasers. Each one features a hero struggling for justice against a swarm of criminal scum and triumphing in the end.
"Trullion" follows the adventures of Glinnes Hulden, the middle child in a family of three boys, as he briefly serves in the interplanetary starfleet known as the Whelm. He returns to his native Trullion and finds a host of problems waiting for him. His father and older brother have disappeared, his younger brother has betrayed the family, and a nasty band of backwoods locals have settled on his property. Circumstances lead him to become an athlete in the sport of Hussade. While the dialogue is often raunchy and funny, the Hussade sequences are difficult to follow, making the middle of the book something of a chore. The action picks back up at the end, as the various competing forces meet in the a series of showdowns.
"Marune" is a very different story, set in the same universe but having nothing else in common with "Trullion". A man with no name and no memory arrives at a remote spaceport. Experts can reconstruct only a small portion of his memory, enough to find his home planet but nothing more. Arriving home at the planet of Marune, he finds himself heir not only to a castle, but also to a endless series of mysteries and intrigues. "Marune" is certainly the weakest of the three Alastor novels. The language is often complicated to the point of distraction, and the plot has relatively few surprises.
"Wyst" shows us Vance back in peak form. This novel follows a young protagonist named Jantiff, who immigrates to the planet of Wyst in search of easy living and new vistas for his art work. Wyst turns out to have a centrally run economy aimed at maximum leisure. Everyone works only 13 hours per week and has the rest of the time off for whatever they choose. While superficially looking nice from the outside, Jantiff starts finding problems shortly after he moves in. Signs of social rot are everywhere, as young people grow obsessed with sex and violence and blind to intellectualism and social responsibility. (Sound familiar?) Among Vance's oeuvre, "Wyst" is unusual for its lack of fighting and big action sequences, and it's focus on social satire and ordinary daily life. (Ordinary being relative, of course.) Among short science fiction novels, it is one of the best ever written.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|