From School Library Journal
Grade 5-9-Alia, a Trantian, wants to be a keenten, a warrior woman. As her 13th birthday approaches, she and her friend Kay hold pretend battles in hopes of impressing the adults who will choose new warriors. When the girls encounter two Beechian children, their savage enemies, and take them captive, Alia is certain that she and her friend will be praised for their bravery. Instead, the keentens are upset that they have taken it upon themselves to capture the enemy. As punishment, the girls must care for the prisoners. While tending to them, Alia begins to see them as people, and when they become ill, she quarrels with Kay over her decision to bring her healer cousin to their aid. Alia begins to question all she has believed in, including the honesty and integrity of their leader, the Divin Ospar. In addition, she discovers that she has an ancient and powerful gift. The rich characters, vivid descriptions, and suspenseful storytelling are well blended in this novel about war, enemies, and finding oneself. The unpredictable conclusion will give readers much to think about. The book is an excellent springboard for a timely discussion about war and the role leaders play in controlling conflict among nations and people.
Linda L. Plevak, Saint Mary's Hall, San Antonio, TXCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 5-7. Twelve-year-old Alia yearns to become a "keenten," a warrior woman, but she has little time to take part in the mock skirmishes because she is stuck tending her baby sister and doing all the indoor chores at home. The possibility of war with the Beechians makes Alia even more eager to earn an invitation to enter the keenten sisterhood. Her fortunes take a different turn, however, after she and her best friend, Kay, who also aspires to become a keenten, capture two young Beechians who have been hiding in mysterious Raven Wood, the site of an ancient, largely forgotten, magic. Kay scorns the captives, but Alia befriends them, learning a shocking secret about the leaders of her village, which, in turn, leads her to her own true destiny. This is McCaffrey's first novel, and both its setting and characterization are convincing. The story is also a solid blend of heartwarming coming-of-age tale and compelling adventure.
Sally EstesCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved