31 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
In the glow of Lulu, June 3, 2008
This review is from: All About Lulu: A Novel (Paperback)
This is what Wally Lamb wanted to do with his novel "She's Come Undone" (1992)--write a bildungsroman about a sympathetic loser with a crazy family and a unique voice whose story, set over a span of decades, offers a glimpse of America's recent past. The difference is, Lamb almost pulled it off with a really good book. Evison not only pulls it off, but hits it out of the park with a great book--part "Catcher in the Rye," part "Lolita," part "Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius."
William Miller, his protagonist, is a wimpy vegetarian in a family of hulking, meat-eating bodybuilders. His step-sister, Lulu, is his lone comrade, and soon becomes the love of Will's life, the center of everything for him. Much of the novel dwells on what happens when his center abruptly abandons him, leaving him with a gaping hole to fill with something--Fatburgers, radio, Hot Dog Heaven, disastrous would-be one-night stands, even Kierkegaard. This idea of emptiness permeates the novel. " 'I feel like a bagel,' " one of Will's former teachers confides to him. " 'Like there's a hole in the center of me.' " Will's narrated response is succinct: "I lived that feeling for most of my life, but I didn't say so. There were times when I felt like the hole and not the bagel, but I didn't tell him that either."
Serious stuff, true. But rather than devolve into a whining diatribe, like a third-rate Holden Caulfield, "All About Lulu" is both very funny and very honest. Evison takes William, an outcast within his own family, and reveals him with all his flaws and pettiness as well as with his capacity to love and grow and learn. Nicely tied-up happy endings aren't plentiful in this novel. "No pain, no gain" is the Miller family motto, and William faces plenty of pain and loss, but all against a hazy background of hope against all odds. While William is by far the most engaging character, the supporting cast is solid--Big Bill, William's bodybuilding father; Eugene Gobernecki, ex-Soviet emigre and fierce capitalist; Troy, William's best friend and romantic rival; and, of course, Lulu, who is both stepsister and siren to William and is wisely kept off-stage for much of the novel by Evison. Her appearances are startling and convincing, and even when she is gone, Will--and by extension, the reader--basks in her afterglow. Along the way Will shows us life in America from the '60s to the '90s, from the Summer of Love to the Reagan Revolution and the grunge movement in Seattle. There's even a hilarious cameo appearance by a certain former bodybuilder turned movie star.
For everyone who's had to suffer unrequited or even semi-requited love, and that covers most people on the planet, "All About Lulu" is a must.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
wounded and beautiful, October 8, 2009
This review is from: All About Lulu: A Novel (Paperback)
i heard a friend describe All About Lulu as a book with a bruised heart. i can't think of a more apt description. wounded and bruised at it's core, it is also tender, insightful, loving, and often hilarious. characters that could easily have come off as cartoonish, or mere quirky templates, in Evison's hands become fully realized, filled with life, detail, and breath. the character's aren't just "lived in" (in the writerly sense) they are also lived with and learned from. Will's obsessive fixation with his first love, his enigma and stepsister Lulu, is rendered in a brutally honest way. filled with the bitter sting of youthful longing, it holds tight to that tension between the head's absurd grandiosity and the heart's attention to the softest, simplest of details. where it still holds true that all the answers to the universe are held within the smallest of minutiae.
admittedly, there were moments where the narrator's voice began to grate. i felt for him, but i wasn't sure i liked him or wanted to listen to him anymore. i had mixed feelings about the story's resolution. revelations that are meant to answer looming questions left me, a bit underwhelmed, with still more questions. while it made sense narratively, i just wanted the enigma back. at times, i feared that the writer's voice and ambition, were encroaching, threatening to overwhelm the narrative and the voice of the characters. all of this, however, is minor quibbling with a book this generous, with this much heart, capable of provoking this much emotion. for any personal reservations i might have had at first read, i know it's a book i want to share with others.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
All in the Family (For Meatheads and other lovable losers), June 4, 2008
This review is from: All About Lulu: A Novel (Paperback)
"All about Lulu" is a rare blend of books: a fun summer read with enough humorous philosophical asides to keep you thinking long after you've turned the last page; a coming-of-age story with an insightful maturity about what it means to be a part of an American family. (And no, not the kind of dour American family novel that makes you wish you had been raised by wolves.) It's a pleasure reading a book that continually surprises you and revels in its own Dickensian assortment of memorable characters
"How do you mend a broken heart?" the Bee Gees asked. I'd tell you how Lulu's narrator, William Miller, would answer that question - but that'd be giving away the ending. (And the ending alone is worth the price of admission.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No