Most Helpful Customer Reviews
24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Destined to Become a Classic, December 6, 2005
This review is from: All American, All the Way: The Combat History of the 82nd Airborne Division in World War II (Hardcover)
As the fortieth and fiftieth anniversaries of the climatic D-Day invasion graced our television screens with dedications, speeches by honored dignitaries, and surviving veterans gathered on once blood soaked battlefields, serious efforts were already being undertaken to tell their stories, in their own words. Teams of academic historians and their assistants embarked upon immense oral history projects, combed the nation, for World War II veterans, conducted extensive interviews, recorded and transcribed their testimonies, and housed them in various university archival depositories. Soon places like the National D-Day Museum and Eisenhower Center in New Orleans, U.S. Army Military History Institute at Carlisle Barracks, Ohio State University, and Rutgers University in New Jersey, just to name a few, were stacked with thousands of oral histories of members of the "greatest generation" who fought and survived in the bloodiest war of the twentieth century.
And there they sit. Ordinary readers are not usually apt to travel to one of these great archival houses to delve into these oral histories. It takes the diligent and time consuming work of historians to compile and assimilate this vast storehouse of individual experiences into a readable format, and pass it on to the general reader. This is exactly what Phil Nordyke has done in _All American All the Way: The Combat History of the 82nd Airborne Division in World War II_.
At first sight, this massive book, 776 pages of written narrative, with over sixty pages of notes is impressive. An unknown author, and publishing house, for this reviewer, usually sends red flags flying as to the quality of its content, however. Not so in the case of this masterfully written chronicle. Nordyke's work is sure to take its rightful place alongside the classic unit and D-Day histories of World War II.
There are countless pitfalls that an author/historian can easily get swallowed into when undertaking such a project. Oral histories, though significant, are not the most enthralling testimonies going. It is amazing the peculiarities and incidentals a soldier focuses on and finds interesting in his small place of history, while an all-important battle rages all around him. And he is usually the only participant in that particular locale, and his input is sorely needed, and all he can do is complain about the contents of a K-ration box. They can bore the reader to death quickly. Nordyke has skillfully avoided these pitfalls, and weaved a captivating story together like a delicate ancient Norman tapestry. From recruitment and training; painful early lessons in North Africa, debacle at Sicily, near defeat at Salerno, and Anzio; the scattered night drop in Normandy to spearhead the invasion of France; the massive daylight drop in Holland opening "Operation Market-Garden;" to the Huertgen Forest, Battle of the Bulge, and the link-up with the Russians, Nordyke utilizes the skills of a veteran military historian, introduces the operations, and places the veteran's testimonies in proper perspective. Nordyke appreciates the value of good quality maps, and has sprinkled a generous amount of them throughout the book. Good quality glossy photographs are also present, reminiscent of older days, when publishing was taken more seriously.
This work is not for the faint of heart (over 200 pages cover the first week of June 1944 alone). Yet when I find myself wanting to read a few pages before bedtime, and two hours later I cannot put it down, says something about the content of this awesome unit history. The author has provided a valuable service to the veterans, their families, and World War II readers in general. There are tons of marginal quality military history books out there; this one is destined to become a classic. I cannot recommend it enough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Aren't You Glad Gen. Gavin & His Boys Were On Our Side?, November 11, 2005
This review is from: All American, All the Way: The Combat History of the 82nd Airborne Division in World War II (Hardcover)
If you were an American or British soldier, this is the infantry division you wanted in front of you and on your flank (that's right, after airborne troops land, they're infantry). After moving the front lines in Normandy for 33 days Gen. Gavin said of his men "The troopers had been splendid; resourceful and courageous in the attack, resolute in the defense, they fought superbly".
Phil Nordyke, in what was obviously a labor of love, painstakingly collected and corroborated oral histories and consolidated and interwove them with many existing written sources to be presented in this SUPERBLY organized and highly engrossing book. The situation maps in particular are better than any I've seen,including official U.S. Army maps (you can thank modern printing techniques for the subtle shadings).
I've walked through the woods, fields and towns of Cheneux, Trois Ponts, Baraque-de-Fraiture, Reharmont, Fosse, Goronne and Thier-du-Mont, Belgium. In Holland: Grave, Groesbeek, Beek, Mook, Plasmolen/Riethorst, Hunner Park, the Waaldyke and Oosterhout. Normandy contributed such towns as St.-Mere-Eglise, Chef-du-Pont, La Fiere Manoir, Cauquigny, Amfreville, Pont l'Abbe, Les Rosiers and St.-Sauveur-le-Vicomte. These places will live forever in the annals of WWII warfare and are a testament to the bravery and resolve of the men from this legendary airborne division who contributed so much to the final Allied victory in Europe.
Finally, we can thank recent movies and a TV miniseries for giving us a realistic visual glimpse of close quarters-no quarter airborne infantry combat in the towns and woods of Europe during WWII. Nordyke's book brings alive the voices, thoughts and experiences (some humerous) of those men. Every front line infantry division of WWII wishes they had a permanent document of their exploits as exceptional as this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best., July 25, 2005
This review is from: All American, All the Way: The Combat History of the 82nd Airborne Division in World War II (Hardcover)
I met Phil Nordyke in Reading, PA, in early June 2005 at a book signing with 82nd Airborne Vets. I looked at the thick, 800 + page book and thought, like I always do with books this big, "It has to be filled with a lot of B.S." When I had the chance, I asked 2 of the vets what they thought of the book. One said "someone finally got it right", the other said "it's our complete story and it's all true". I bought the book and was not disappointed. In fact, it's better than any book I've read on WW2, Stephen Ambrose books included. Phil obviously spent an enormous amount of time collecting the facts, double checking the facts, and having the vets re-check what he had written before releasing this book. It full of facts and stories from vets like no other WW2 book I've read.
Phil told me in Reading, "it's their story, I just wrote it down". He did more than write it down, he organized it and put it down in a fashion so that the events flow perfectly and the book reads easily. When you are done, you'll swear it was only 200 pages. It's how a book like this should be written.
If you are a WW2 buff, get this book. You'll fall in love with the 82nd Airborne, which is tough for me to say since I'm a 101st re-enactor.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|