17 of 19 people found the following review helpful
on March 7, 2006
This book charts the early adventures of the Spectre, the Sandman, Hourman, The Golden Age Green Lantern, & the Golden Age Flash, as well as other, minor Golden Age characters. Pre-Justice Society, they establish the basics of these characters.
If you love Golden Age material, you will find this a very nice collection indeed.
I've been in fandom since the 60's. And these comics, they're still Golden, after all these years.
The Hipster gives it a Big Thumbs UP!
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
on February 14, 2010
I was worried about this one because I had read several reviews of later D.C. archive editions like 'starman vol 2" in which they just scanned old comics. All the other archive editions featured clean art and remastering or recoloring etc. This one is well done and features superclean reproductions of the first two issues of All Star Comics. They are pre war and filled with short tales about the golden age great like The Flash, Green Lantern, The spectre, Hourman and the Sandman. Superman and Batman are absent from these issues as they would be for most of the series run.
Other lesser heroes like Ultraman and Red white and blue also appear in this issue. The book is shorter than the rest of the all star reprint book series because it only features the first 2 issues. Even so if you tried to buy these two comics you'd spend many thousands and wouldn't even then get a cleaned up effort like this book. This is what needs to be done with old comics , when they are not scanned from a old comic and instead remastered you can really grasp what a great artform the genre really is. The third issue changed history with it's J.S.A supergroup and Wonder Woman debut but these two issues were pure golden age goodness from one of the better companies that still makes great comics to this day.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on January 10, 2014
DC Comics published 11 volumes of All-Star Comics Archives, reprinting the Justice Society of America stories from All-Star Comics #3 to 57. So what is in this #0 Archives? All-Star Comics #1 and 2, which did not feature the Justice Society. So, no JSA here, but most of the group members are here in solo stories. The non-JSA members featured here are Ultra-Man (a sci-fi hero), Biff Bronson (a detective) and Red, White and Blue (three military heroes). Some of these comics are dated by today's standards, but they are still enjoyable. Plus, getting this book is way cheaper than buying copies of the original comics.
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
on August 10, 2014
I know these are "Golden Age" comics, but I can't get past just how bad these stories are. Reading these I'm amazed the comics industry survived. Not only are the stories generally boring, but there are inconsistencies in them that are aggravating. In one story Green Lantern uses his ring to walk through a door, but then is captured by a net. In one sequence a hero clearly picks up an item with his left hand, then in the next frame throws it with his right. Jacket colors change for no reason in the middle of conversations between characters.
Maybe I'm expecting too much from these stories since comics have changed a lot since the 40's, but I've read other comics from this time period that are much better (Batman chronicles vol. 1 for example).
The quality of the book is nice, and the reproductions are pretty high quality. If you're a fan of these you will appreciate the quality of this book. If you're just interested in reading them for nostalgia's sake, I'm not sure they're worth the cost.