Customer Reviews

An All-Star Line-Up Performing the Songs of Pink Floyd

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(5)

 

 

This is an audio only tribute music DVD (various artists performing Pink Floyd songs) distributed by the Navarre Corporation. It is not a video DVD.

Printed on the cover of the DVD is:

An All Star Lineup Performs The Songs Of Pink Floyd.

The follwing information comes from the Navarre.com website:

Title: PINK FLOYD DVD
Publisher: CLEOPATRA RECORDS INC
Label: CLEOPATRA

Artist: VARIOUS

Format: DVD MUSIC

Rating:
Ages:
UPC: 741157135695
Selection: CLP 1356
Navarre P/N: 2123580
Carton Qty: 30
Release Date: 03/30/2004
MSRP: $14.98

Track Listing:
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
2. Money
3. Comfortably Numb
4. Welcome To The Machine
5. Have A Cigar
6. Us And Them
7. Run Like Hell
8. Any Colour You Like
9. Breathe (In The Air)
10. Young Lust
11. Another Brick In The Wall Pt. II

The Audio portion of the DVD is really good, the interpretations of classic Floyd songs are pretty fantastic actually with some very accomplished musicians sporting beautiful solos....Edgar Winters on sax and Dweezil Zappa on guitar to name a couple....each song has a different line up. If you have a 5.1 DVD player I highly recommend this. However, the Video portion is horrendous. I've never seen such lame visuals in all my life. It might look OK to the very stoned or hard tripping. Otherwise it stinks. So Actually I give the audio 5 stars and the video part zero stars, hence the 3 stars.

This tribute CD is very misleading on it's info on the back cover. It claims to contain "Stunning visuals...". Because of the very talented musicians involved in this venture, I was expecting state of the art computer animation similar to the exellent "Mind's Eye" series. Instead you get the most pathetic "visuals" I've ever seen. The music is ok but nothing earth shattering.

Try "Live at Pompei" or one of the 80's and 90's concert videos for a better experience.

They really should have made a CD of that s..t. The worst thing for me is that nobody thought of people like me who do not own a 5.1 system! There simply is no stereo signal on this DVD. It is annoying, not to mention the "movie" running on the screen which is not more than a cheap joke, I expected to actually see the musicians performing the songs (no budget here)! I guess if you have a 5.1 system the music might sound good, I don't know....

Yes the music is excellent, but this is not a DVD

just a pathetic "screen saver" type images during music

don't be fooled by the thieves that realese this edition...

Buy the CD.

I should have checked the reviews first...

I already owned this CD so I was excited with the prospect of seeing the All-Star Line-up... :(

This is just the audio of the CD recorded on a DVD format that features some graphs...

For the $1.98 I paid, I should not complaint... It sounds good on 5.1

I concur with all the reviewers listed here....this DVD is a complete waste of time and money....as for "stunning visuals", the most stunning visual is the picture on the DVD box cover, and you will find nothing within the DVD itself to match, or even come close to its quality. My nine year old child, using basic 3D graphics/animation software, has produced more exciting visuals than this! Whoever thought that these visuals were stunning must have been smoking the wrong stuff....

Music? Oh, yes....there is some music on the disc, but it's been done better by other artists....

En primera el DVD no tiene ningun folleto ni una maldita imagen de los músicos que tal que ni siquiera tocan ellos pero bueno la musica es buena del 1 al 10 le doy un 8 solo a la música, las animaciones estan del nabo, mejor apaga la TV lo mejor es poder ecucharlo en 5.1 si no tienes ese sistema le quitas un 50% de su valor musical.

le son n est pas bon, les images sont tres nul...n acheter pas ce DVD....c est affreux !!!

Perhaps it is this DVD we are dealing with:

I have received some details about a future DVD being released in the next few months. Released on the 'Classic Rock Legends Label, the DVD is titled 'Inside The Music - A Critical Journey - Pink Floyd. The film will be a critical review of all the Pink Floyd albums from 1967 onwards and will feature some very interesting interviews. At the moment this product is very much in the production stage and only these limited details are confirmed. The DVD release will be available world wide.