From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6-Sixth-grader Leah's sense of self is badly shaken when she learns that her mother's weeks-long silence has been hiding a cross-country move that doesn't include her. The fact that her "mother" is actually her stepmother is only gradually revealed to readers. As Leah starts to let go of her bitterness, she makes tentative progress toward a solid relationship with her father and a restored sense of who she is. The strengths of the book are Leah's well-developed character and the realistic nastiness she displays as an outlet for her misery. Her inability to focus on schoolwork and her purposeful attempts to wound her father's new wife both help to capture the extent of her loss. The close friendship she forms with a boy is less convincing, given sixth-grade social norms. In addition, her father is drawn as a puzzlingly positive character, which seems at odds with her previous lack of relationship with him. Readers who enjoy quiet stories of personal growth will likely overlook these slightly implausible plot elements and respond to Leah's journey as she seeks a place to belong.
Faith Brautigam, Gail Borden Public Library, Elgin, ILCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 5-8. Sixth-grader Leah is stunned when she is suddenly thrust into her father and new stepmother Gail's life after her mother suddenly leaves. New in town, she's an outsider at school until Will throws her a lifeline and tries to be her friend. As the two lonely kids secretly explore the darkened auditorium to get away from the cafeteria crowd during their lunch period, they start to build a trusting relationship. At home, though, Leah's anger and feelings of abandonment make for difficulties with distant Dad and overcompensating Gail. Cautiously, Leah finally begins to confront all that has happened to her, and with Will's steadfast encouragement, she takes some positive steps: she tries out for a play and stands up to a girl who harasses her. Will's wisdom and manner belie his age, and Leah's growing strength and self-knowledge evolve a little too quickly as the story spins toward a happy ending; but the characters are very appealing, and the plot will hold readers' attention.
Anne O'MalleyCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved