3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A comprehensive exploration of the boundary between land & sea, January 3, 2009
Nature's "edges" brim with intricate lifestyles and habitats: the succession margins between wood and meadow; the neither-nor pockets between mountain and plains; and of course, the dynamic shorelines between land and sea. Author John Stilgoe uses his home base of coastal Massachusetts to explore in detail each and every nuance of the latter.
More specifically, his narrative dwells most often on life in and around Scituate, Marshfield, and Duxbury, several bayside towns lying between Boston and Plymouth. (The Gulf of Mexico and the Pacific Ocean shorelines are specified on occasion; but in most instances, the information presented here is somewhat universal.) Referring to himself as "the barefoot historian," Stilgoe analyzes the ongoing relationship between humans and the water's edge. The subject has a language all its own, with words like looming and chartreuse, not to mention glim, guzzle, and gundalow gunkholing.
Stilgoe additionally uses sociology, history, science and literature to explore every aspect of the place he calls "alongshore." He expounds on the virtues of the salt marsh. He lists the qualities of a proper skiff, and ponders the differences between a boat and a yacht. He peeks into a WWII observation tower. He describes the fate of the wooden wharf. He notes the continuing lure of discovering treasure trove. He documents the visitor's desire to take home part of the sea, which results even today in inland aquariums and decorations for knick-knack shelves. He debates the issues of swimming suits vs. bathing suits, to tan and not to tan, and the acceptable forms of near-nudity on public beaches. He tells potential beachside builders that the land they see is "not real estate, but realm." He scrutinizes alongshore portrayal by writers, artists, and the popular media. (What is a seascape? A sea-story?) In doing so, he presents an exhaustive study of the literature, both fiction and nonfiction, and leaves us with a stack of suggestions for further reading. Surely he has left no stone unturned.
His pre-2001 perspective about possible attacks on American soil is eerie to see in print. Yes, we are familiar with our continuing it-can't-happen-here mentality. But to read a quote from an 1884 Army officer report that "Manhattan is an island, an island trap," is to remember scenes of towers falling, dust whirling, and people running. It is all too true.
Many b&w photos and illustrations are scattered amidst the text; and they serve to keep the reader interested in each one of the author's themes. Stilgoe has obviously spent much time in this environment and is entranced / mesmerized by it. Still, it takes a dedicated reader to stay with his ramblings -- not because the writing offers rough going, but because it is chockfull of details. You must be a shoreline aficionado yourself to continue to turn the pages. And those sheets are bound in a book that is almost square. It's a bit tricky to hold comfortably, thus requiring again a deliberate undertaking by the reader. The experience is well worth the effort, however. You will never again give a mere casual glance to any sand-blown beach or murky marsh. In fact, upon finishing "Alongshore," you may want to drive to the nearest ocean and dash into the surf, just to honor it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No