From Publishers Weekly
In Rodriguez's ponderous, wordy story, a Mixteca Indian girl living in a Chicago barrio struggles to find her niche in a hostile society. The author eschews subtlety: the ironically named America witnesses a sidewalk shooting while walking to school; the intolerant teacher of her ESL class dismisses her students as "difficult" and whispers to a colleague that America is "an illegal"; the girl's uncle is a drunk, her father gets laid off and someone calls her mother a wetback. The imagery is equally heavy-handed, as in America's description of the "desperate men without jobs": "They all seem trapped, like flowers in a vase, full of song and color, yet stuck in a gray world where they can't find a way out." America escapes this bleakness by creating poetry ("A poet, America knows, belongs everywhere"), but this flatly written tale doesn't serve its political agenda, nor does it transcend it. Vasquez's stylized art is also poorly targeted for the intended audience, who may be put off immediately to find that the young heroine looks considerably older than her nine years. La llaman America, a Spanish-language edition, will also be released. Ages 6-10.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 2-4-Nine-year-old America Soliz is an illegal immigrant of Mexican-Indian heritage living in the violence-ravaged Pilsen barrio of Chicago. Feeling unwelcome in her new country, she yearns to return to her native Oaxaca. Then one day, a Puerto Rican poet visits America's ESL class and tells the students that "There's poetry in everyone...and poets belong to the whole world." Soon, America begins to express herself through poetry, eventually coming to realize that as a poet, she is a citizen of the world with a bright future ahead of her. The story is generally well told, and its message is an important one. Dramatic, full-color illustrations that blend surreal and folk-art elements lend emotion to the text, and many of the drawings exhibit an interesting use of perspective. However, in most of the pictures, America resembles a mature adult instead of a little girl. A solid choice for bilingual and ESL collections.
Denise E. Agosto, formerly at Midland County Public Library, TXCopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.