Most Helpful Customer Reviews
41 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Eloise, I mean Flavia, at Christmastime, October 27, 2011
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Buckshaw, the huge house of the de Luce family, is mostly shut up. There is very little money to maintain the house and Colonel de Luce has had to agree to allow a movie crew to use the house as a film set just to make enough money to fend off bankruptcy a little longer. Eleven-year-old Flavia de Luce regrets that the crew's use of the great hall means the family won't be able to put up the usual Christmas tree and decorations, but she plans to compensate for the loss with the entertainment of secretly observing the visitors. As always, Flavia is also deeply occupied with various experiments in her fully-equipped chemistry laboratory, originally outfitted by her uncle Tar. At the moment, her chief experiment is a fairly simple one. She has whipped up a super-sticky birdlime to coat Buckshaw's chimneys. This is intended to prove her hypothesis, much derided by her elder sisters Ophelia and Daphne, that Father Christmas exists. If he does exist, Flavia expects to find him adhered to the chimney on Christmas Eve and to join all of the house and surrounding countryside in admiration of the stupendous fireworks display Flavia has planned with all the firepower she has managed to cook up in her lab. Before all that, though, there is another exciting event. The vicar has persuaded lead actors Phyllis Wyvern and Desmond Duncan to help raise funds for the church roof project by enacting the balcony scene from Romeo and Juliet in the great hall to an audience from the nearby village of Bishop's Lacey. During the thrilling show, a blizzard rages on outside, snowing in the villagers. That means we have a normally nearly-empty Buckshaw now full to the rafters with the family, the film crew and half the village. A perfect setup for a murder, which obligingly occurs. Of course it's Flavia who discovers the body, and she is determined to crack the case, despite the usual dire warnings from Inspector Hewitt to stay strictly away from the murder scene and refrain from conducting her own investigation. Flavia's sleuthing results in a dramatic Christmas Eve resolution in which the case is solved and Flavia's chemistry experiments play out in wildly unanticipated ways. If you're not familiar with Flavia de Luce, she's a little like Eloise: endlessly curious, irrepressible, no fashion plate, and a constant trial to her relations and acquaintances, but endearing in spite of it all. I also think of her in some ways as the anti-Harry Potter. Supremely confident in her intellectual powers and chemistry expertise, where Harry is self-doubting and hopeless at potions (at least until he finds that book . . . ). But they have some things in common, too. Both have suffered a parental loss that affects them deeply; Harry being an orphan and Flavia having lost her mother and living with a distant, heartbroken father. Both are tormented by other children; Harry by his cousin and by Draco Malfoy, and Flavia by her sisters. And, most important, both are featured players in a series of books enjoyed by adults. I enjoyed reading this fourth installment in the Flavia de Luce series. Alan Bradley is skilled at characterization and setting his scenes. In this entry in the series, he subtly advances the background plot of Flavia's mother's loss and Flavia's difficult relationship with her sisters. He's not as strong at mystery plotting. In the end, his whodunnits tend to resolve themselves more than to be solved through hard evidence and deduction. But the charm of the books generally overcomes this weakness. Anyone who enjoys a lighter mystery should give the series a try. It's not necessary to read the series in order, but if you would prefer to do that, here they are: The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie: A Flavia de Luce Mystery
The Weed That Strings the Hangman's Bag: A Flavia de Luce Novel
A Red Herring Without Mustard: A Flavia de Luce Novel
I Am Half-Sick of Shadows: A Flavia de Luce Novel
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Flavia Stocking Stuffer, November 11, 2011
I liked this one, but not as much as the others in the series. It took a while to get going. The entire book is set in Buckshaw, Flavia's epic estate. This incredible mansion would be a fine enough setting, but I missed Flavia zipping around Bishop's Lacey on her trusty bicycle, Gladys. At the half-way point, the residents Bishop's Lacey comes to Buckshaw for a show. Ah-ha, Flavia doesn't need to travel to Bishop's Lacey; Bishop's Lacey will come to her! This is when I finally became invested in the book, only to be a little disappointed when the quirky residents are under-utilized. I've wanted Flavia to have another chat with the town's little gossip maven, Maximillion Brock, ever since her debut novel. Many of the new and returning characters are also haphazardly sprinkled about. Two or three of movie crew seem to exist purely to lurk around and be shady suspects, and a returning character from The Weed That Strings the Hangman's Bag makes an appearance that serves absolutely no narrative purpose. Flavia does spend a bit of the novel pre-occupied with capturing Saint Nicholas. Her brilliant scheme to trap him--of course involving an ingenious chemical mixture--reminds us that despite her brilliant scientific and deduction skills, Flavia is still an eleven-year-old girl. There are some funny and tender moments, but this holiday Flavia is more of a delightful stocking stuffer than a filling Christmas feast.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Still enjoyable, but the mystery is half-baked at best, November 11, 2011
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
There is plenty to love in this installment of Flavia de Luce's adventures, especially if you are her existing fan. "I Am Half-Sick of Shadows" is a Christmas story, with a great infusion of some new blood, which is a must for any series focusing on such a tiny place as Bishop's Lacey. Flavia's father is forced to rent out Buckshaw to a movie company to film its new feature. When the star of the movie is found murdered, Flavia is on full alert. Now she has two Christmas cases on her hands - the murder and her project to confirm the existence of Santa. Whatever you liked about the previous books in the series, is all there - the humor, the charm, the interesting characters, the mischief. However, I feel that in their zeal to deliver "I Am Half-Sick of Shadows" just in time for Christmas, Bradley and his gang of editors and agents forgot to pay attention to the quality of this novel. To put it bluntly, it is half-baked. Besides the wonky motives of the killer, far-fetching backstories of some characters, multiple pointless cameo appearances of characters from previous books and half-hearted at best red herrings, this book lacks simple continuity. The part that especially stood out for me (unless, of course, I misunderstood it) was when a certain character in one chapter is sent out in a snowstorm to fetch a couple of people, in the next chapter is sitting in the Buckshaw's living room chatting and in the next is just coming from outside with the couple (if you are curious, I am talking about Sergeant Graves in chapters 13-15). How is it possible that an editor of this book didn't notice this discrepancy, if even I, a person absolutely unobservant, did? As usual in such cases, I am pretty sure nobody had read this manuscript before rushing it into print. In spite of its many obvious flaws, the book was still entertaining and funny. I just hope the next one is edited and constructed better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
