I have to confess...I've always liked Mandy Moore. I even like her bubblegum pop years that she's disavowed, but I think it's because even then I felt that she had a quality that separated her from the pop-tarts of the day. That feeling was vindicated with "Coverage", her all-covers album, and then the triumph of "Wild Hope", which blew away any doubt that Mandy had the talent to be a real singer and songwriter.
So where does "Amanda Leigh" fit into this? To me, it's a masterpiece in the original sense. This proves that Mandy Moore deserves to be recognized as more than just "singer/actress" or "that girl who wasn't Britney or Christina." The album is like "Coverage" without being covers, it's like "Wild Hope" but with less packaging. It's like a sampling of the best of the 1970s without being a rip-off, but also fresh and current. I imagine a lot of the credit for the arrangements goes to her producer, who isn't afraid to pair strings with steel guitar or wrap in other combinations that beautifully complement the melodies and Mandy's perfect voice. She's playful and lilting at times, sultry and moody at others, and always front and center.
Favorite tracks? All of them, I suppose, but Merrimack River is certainly at the top of my list (and first on the album).
This album should be on lots of people's lists. It will be a revelation to some who might be skeptics or curious about this "singing actress" or "Ryan Adams' new wife", and I think it also should appeal to fans of Kim Richey, Dar Williams, and similar singer-songwriters. A must-buy (and a no-brainer at the current digital download price of $3.99!)