Customer Reviews

The Amateurs [HD DVD]

5 star:		(21)
4 star:		(12)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(4)

 

 

THE AMATEURS is about as close to the quality of British film comedies (a high compliment indeed!) as we have seen, thanks to writer/director Michael Traeger. It is everything a small town community aura represents without the stumbling blocks of cruelty that so often provide the turning point in 'rural stories' that defame the simple homespun humanity that is too often foreign to the big city life. Perhaps to refer to it as 'sweet' will rile some review readers, but for this viewer the overriding emotion at the close of the story is just that - sweet, in the finest sense of the term.

The film is narrated by the down and out, unemployed, newly divorced middle-aged crisis victim Andy Sargentee (Jeff Bridges) who spends his time in the local watering hole trying to come up with an idea that will change his fortune - and life. Giving up his marriage to Thelma (Jeanne Tripplehorn) and his son Billy (Alex D. Linz) has been painful but Andy believes he will somehow regain their respect by discovering his 'big idea'. Surrounding him are other underachievers such as Some Idiot (Joe Pantoliano), Barney Macklehatton (Tim Blake Nelson) hopelessly in love with loony dreamer Helen (Glenne Headly), church janitor Otis (William Fichtner), local video store worker and video buff Emmett (Patrick Fugit), Moe/Ron (John Hawkes and Brad William Henke) who are never seen alone, the closeted gay Moose (Ted Danson), and bartender Floyd (Tom Bower) among other 'observers'. A wild idea occurs to Andy: he and his friends could make an amateur porn film and make money and gain fame. Out of both love of Andy and individual needs to make something of their boring existence in the little town, the group commits to helping Andy with his project. How the steps succeed and fail underline the integrity and unconditional friendship these simple people represent. Along the way we meet the porn film's stars including Valerie Perrine, Judy Greer, Fiona Hunter, Isaiah Washington, Melinda Dahl - all of whom eagerly participate in the 'very private' filming concept of an amateur porn film. How the final product is threatened and ultimately survives produces the warm ending to the film. And along the way we get to know Thelma's new husband Howard (Steven Weber) who breaks the stereotype of the rich new stepfather, and these small town folk including Dawn Didawick, Jayne Taini, Lauren Graham, and Eileen Brennan (who contributes a very special cameo role).

The film has been named THE MOGULS and DIRTY MOVIE in other countries and perhaps that confusion of titles has been part of the problem of the lack of promotion the film received in the theaters. But in a way, seeing this very special movie in home surroundings adds to the intimacy and the very warmly honest view of the genuinely kind and caring interrelationships among the people of this small town. There is much to be learned from this film and the added features include the writer/director sharing the experience with each of the actors in this truly ensemble work. Highly recommended. Grady Harp, March 08

The low-key effect of the film grabbed my attention from the beginning as actor Jeff Bridges began his narration of his life in the little town of Butterface Field. He introduced the characters while playing his character engaged in troubled thought, sitting alone, in the local restaurant bar.

Bridges is Andy Sargentee, a husband and father who places his impulses above the economic viability of the family by relieving himself on the desks of every supervisor he has had (and despises). His wife, played by Jeanne Triplehorn, sets off into divorce and the sunset with the station wagon and their son.

Bridges only support now is the town of Butterface Field, the place in which he was born and raised. The townsfolk know him well enough especially when he is about to come up with a brainstorm, which they are apprehensive about. Friends and neighbors at adjacent tables see the mental storm brewing. (He led them into a Ponzi scheme before just when the tulip bubble bubbled, proving his brainstorm nothing more than a light drizzle).

But now, he's got it!

He and the town will make a fortune creating a genuine, amateur porn film! He quickly enlists his friends to invest their meager sum and even more meager talents as actors, writers, directors and so on. They also have to get girls for the part, and enlist Black actors for their presumed assets. They find a young, counter girl from an ice cream store, an aging stripper, and a bedding store saleswoman, who insists on getting it on with the storeowner.

Jeff Bridges, Ted Danson, Joe Pantoliano, William Fichtner, Lauren Graham, Glenne Headley, Tim Blake Nelson, and Jeanne Tripplehorn make this "light" film work along with the superb direction of Michael Traegor. No actor overplays his or her part. The humor is subtle, even hilarious at some points. And for a movie about porn, there is no flesh or foul language.

A colleague at work recommended this; her stock has gone way up.

This is a keeper.

I can't quite put this up at the 5 star level, but it's awfully close.

Big props to the cast here as they really do a great job here and seem perfectly cast for the roles each is asked to play.

Lead actor Jeff Bridges puts on a great performance as a man (Andy Sargentee) that is looking for his one big break, but unfortunately has failed at everything he's ever tried. Early on we find that he lost his wife because he's just not able to be responsible and can't take care of his family because of his lack of steady income. His son's birthday comes up and he goes to the store to buy a gift for him only to realize he just can't afford the one he feels is right. Real embarassment kicks in when he goes to his wife's new home and finds that it isn't just a big home, it's a complete mansion.

From that embarassment springs inspiration as Andy sits deep in thought in the town bar. Eventually he's inspired to make a porn movie with the help and support of his friends, a cast of some of the weirdest and wildest characters you'd ever find assembled.

This film isn't a continuous laugh fest, but it is very entertaining. Some parts would seem predictable, but the story does a good job of planting timely distractions and diversions along the way that keep things very fresh.

While the movie is about the making of a porn film, the nudity in the film is fairly tasteful and there is no sex really shown in the film. There are however sexual references, sex toys and discussion of porn movies is prevalent so this isn't a film for the easily disturbed.

Well worth a purchase and priced at a fair level.

"The Amateurs" Is a perfect little gem tucked between boxes of costume jewlery. With so many video choices out there just taking up space on the shelves, it is a pleasure to find a film that has real value.
When you finish watching "The Amateurs" you will feel like you have been given a very special gift. The framework around the substance of the film is recognizable: A father seeking a meaningful relationship with his son;"characters" in a small town who stumble around and win in the end- but the movie is much more than that. The characters have dimension, and belie stereotypes.
This film is about kindness, generosity, friendship, acceptance, and just doing the next right thing. Using the creation of such a crass commodity as a porno film as the vehicle these lessons arrive in is just sublime. "The Amateurs" may be rated R for language and sexual content, but I have never seen these potential offenders made so impotent than they are by their treatment in this film. If Frank Capra worked in 2008, "It's a Wonderful Life" might well have looked like this movie.
I keep very few films on video for repeated viewing. Most just don't have long-term presence. I'm keeping this one so my son and his friends can watch it- seven years from now.

"The Amateurs" won't change your life, but it may make it a little easier to bear.

Yes, it's heartwarming. Yes, the little town is filled with the predictable eccentrics who do the expected offbeat things. Yes, everything ends well for everybody (except the big brother). Despite all those drawbacks, this movie is funny. Great casting, great writing, great acting (as much as is demanded by the material).

The Jeff Bridges overstory and narration is the glue that brings all the individual characters and their lines into one whole; his gentle persona creates the film, not only in the story sense but in reality. A great entertainment if you're not offended by graphic but good-natured language.

Some critics panned this movie when it was first vetted. I say that they are simply jaded and completely misguided in evaluating what we like about being entertained. Being entertained is a simple proposition and this movie easily accomplishes that promise. Dad needs to feel that his son loves and respects him - a difficult enough proposition in today's world. of crazy influences. Among other things that make this movie so enjoyable is the obvious enjoyment of the actors for working with each other. The movie draws you in like an old friend, with, of course, a fittingly touching ending. A great movie for a cozy night/rainy day with the fire burning ...

"I'm a trier, not a doer." This is a great movie that I laughed almost all the way through. Its unfortunate that movies like this don't play to larger audiences. There's nothing new here in terms of a story of a father who proves to himself that he can accomplish things and be a good dad because he really is a good person. Just a really good movie.

i seriously don't get how hollywood blockbusters with their contrived plots and dusty old jokes get glowing reviews but stuff like this gets panned for not enough character development of the peripheral characters. give me a BREAK.
this is a great movie- great cast, great script and inspirational w/o hitting the cheese factor too hard. i really don't say it lightly bc i'm picky as hell.
for anyone looking for the inspiration to achieve the impossible, this is your movie. this, and 'my date with drew.' WATCH IT AND BE CONVINCED.

In 2004 Joe Pantoliano starred in a great little movie called "Second Best" in which he played the leader of a bunch of losers whose lot is never going to change. In 2005 he starred in another movie with a similar theme, but this time the losers win in the end. This second movie, originally released as "The Moguls", is now making the rounds of the video stores under its rechristened title, "The Amateurs," and it is a charming, disarming flick that will take you by surprise.

This time, rather than Pantoliano, the lead loser is Jeff Bridges, a guy for whom simply nothing goes particularly well. Unable to keep a job, divorced by his wife, in danger of losing the affections of his son and apparently completely beaten, he is nonetheless dogged in his belief that there must be SOMETHING he can do right in this life...and is inexplicably more than amply sustained in this fantasy by his own personal corps of loser, played notably by Pantoliano, Tim Blake Nelson, William Fichtner, and Ted Danson, as well as the rest of the town's fruitcake population, many of whom are losers in their own right.

Bridges' character, Andy, after much thought, finally comes up with an idea that he is absolutely positive will put them all on the map, and put much needed money into all their pockets. They should, he announces, make a porno film; what could be simpler?

The fact that this crew knows nothing about film, and worse, knows nothing about porn, sets the stage for what follows. As their Stranger in a Strange Land journey continues, Andy undertakes an academic study of the sort of scenes they'll need in their movie, Pantolaino is rendered speechless by a collection of sex toys, and, in a clear send up of his Sam Malone character on "Cheers," Danson proves not to be a ladies man at all.

One bit of pure genius occurs when, although played with a straightforward, small town earnestness, the film takes a Mel Brooks turn to absurdity as the stumbling, bumbling crew is amazed and tickled at their ability to find several more-then-willing local women to star in the film, but at the same time can't seem to find any well-endowed black males, or a single white male willing to play any part in the film at all, in spite of offers of payment and free sex.

This film was obviously a labor of love, as Hollywood stars such as Valerie Perrine, Eileen Brennan, Steven Weber, Brad Garrett and Judy Greer turn in marvelous, if extremely small performances, each adding a special something to the film.

Although this is a film about a sex film, there is literally nothing sexual about it, the small amount of nudity handled with wit and charm.

Although at times the film is downright silly, it is in the end uplifting, and simply a good movie. If you did not see it during its initial run as "The Moguls," by all means see it as "The Amateurs." You'll be pleasantly surprised.

This is a small movie with a big, big heart. For 95 minutes you get to hang out and drink beer with a genuinely nice bunch of hapless middle-aged "slackers" as they set out to redeem their lives by making a porn film. Everything about this movie is perfect: great actors, including Jeff Bridges and a dozen familiar faces from tv and small films; a wholly original screenplay; and lots of sex and lots of nudity. Er, the audience never really SEES the sex and nudity, but the clever way the director suggests-without-showing this important plot element is, like the rest of the film, utterly charming. Call a few buddies, grab a bag of corn chips and a six-pack, kick off your flip-flops and watch "The Amateurs" as soon as you can!