Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
34 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic, Entertaining and Informative Overview of American History, May 23, 2010
This review is from: America: The Story of Us (DVD)
I think all of the people complaining about the lack of academic level detail and scholarship in this series are missing the point. This 12 episode series is a really fantastic overview of American History. Oftentimes when we study history in school, through long, detailed books, over the course of several months, we tend to lose the forest for the trees. This medium of learning has it's place, watching this series you get a feel through a quick succession of stories, as to how America began and developed over the last two and a half centuries. What it lacks in "legitimate" scholarship it more than makes up for by it's production quality, compelling story-telling and entertainment. Another thing to note is the populist perspective of the series. Most history textbooks and academics focus too heavily on the actions of political leaders, but this series is truly about the "story of us" as indicated by its title. I was surprised to find that there was almost no discussion about the writing of the constitution, not much talk about the Presidents and the legislation they pushed through or the policies they enacted. Instead, the series incorporates a lot of anecdotes and stories of people and movements that shaped the course of this country, from the Chinese immigrants who built the railroads to the construction workers who built New York City, to historic figures like Frederick Douglas, Harriet Tubman and Andrew Carnegie. If I were a school teacher I would show my students this entire series at the beginning of each year, if for nothing else but to pique their interest in history and what they're about to learn in greater detail over the course of the term.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
40 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Highly enjoyable, May 25, 2010
This review is from: America: The Story of Us (DVD)
First off, I am well aware that this documentary is not perfect. Having studied history, I feel that this documentary was lacking in some parts. Still, this series is solid and tight.
I learned a lot of neat trivia from this that I had not known before. This documentary feels to be geared more towards beginners, rather than scholars. If you're a history expert, you will find some parts lacking. (I am not a expert, but I do love history) but you will also most likely also learn some new things here. This would be a fun documentary for middle or high school students, as well as people who would like a basic (NOT a complete) overview of American history. I mean, it's impossible to give a complete overview of 400 years of history in twelve episodes, (less than twelve hours when you take out the commercials)
I can't say that I enjoyed all of the guest speakers, but some of them were rather relevant. Donald Trump talked about the Great Depression. Al Sharpton talked about the role of black people. And so on and so forth. Some of the guest speakers were better suited for their roles than others - I can't imagine why they would have Sheryl Crowe on this, but Rudy Guilliani was good. My biggest gripe was that they had P Diddy on there. COME ON. Why him? They also had the guy from Pawn Stars in the final episode, and I was excited to see him, but he didn't really contribute anything worthwhile, what he said didn't add anything to the documentary.
This is different from other History Channel documentaries in the past. It concentrates more on PEOPLE, not things/artifacts (this is why it's called The Story of *Us*) and the struggles, trials, and tribulations of a growing country. Yeah, this series did not say much about World War 1 or the War of 1812, but remember, the History Channel has separate documentary series on all different wars and other things, so if you wish for a more complete overview on a particular war or event, you can search the History Channel site or YouTube for documentaries that are more specific on one subject. This is not a documentary about war or politics, but how we have changed through our history, what innovations effected these changes (the Transcontinental Railroad, the Model-T and assembly line production, etc)
The writing's solid and fairly well-written. If you're looking for a documentary that is fun and interesting to watch, this is the one for you. Kids will also enjoy this. My roomate (who's not a geek like me) found herself enjoying this and learning a lot from it even though history isn't what she is interested in. I will say that some things became more clear for me in this documentary - some 'aha! I get it now!' moments. A few parts were repetitive, but overall the series moved at a smooth pace.
If I had to grade this, I'd give it a solid B. It might not be History Channel's best series, but for those of you wishing to learn something new or want a different perspective on American history, it's worth watching.
It would be cool to see a 'Story Of Us' for other countries, though since most countries are older than America (China's history is over 5000 years old) that would be a difficult task that needs to be carried out carefully (meaning no celebrity speakers who have nothing to add to the documentary!)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
42 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Excellent Synopsis of US History, April 28, 2010
This series is clearly not for serious historians. I have always had an interest in US History, but my expertise ended with a 5 in AP US History in 11th Grade 23 years ago.
My wife, who is a high school English teacher, and I thoroughly enjoyed the first 2 hours this past weekend. We have set the rest of the series to record and I have pre-ordered the BluRay set. The first 2 hrs covers about 160 years of US history from 1621 thru 1782, which includes the first settlements in the US thru the end of the Revolutionary War. Obviously 90 minutes of television is woefully inadequate to cover such a time period and such pivitol events.
Still, the episodes fly by and they do a great job of including key events along with highlighting key individuals who are less known. They also provide a great deal of context into what is going on.
I would give this 5 stars if they had stuck to credible people to discuss some of the events. The first 2 episodes include sound bites from Rudy Guliani, Michael Bloomberg, Donald Trump, Michael Douglas and I saw Cheryl Crown in a preview for the next episode. I think they should have limited themselves to actual historians for the commentary. Still, probably most of what they say was scripted, so it isn't a total farce.
I feel i covered most of this information in jr. high and high school. Still, i think there are many people who can benefit from this series. My parents are not from America and they won't have covered any of this in school. I live in Miami which is full of immigrants who also might not know a lot of American history. I think that it is entertaining enough that children who find history boring might give it another chance. Covering almost 400 years in 12 hrs isn't going to give you the difinitive work on American History, but it is great for people who might not realize how rich this country's history is.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|