This is the third bibliography of Civil War books to be published this year, and it is the most comprehensive. Woodworth is a history professor at Toccoa Falls College, Georgia, and the author of several books and articles on the war. This massive work has 47 contributors, all distinguished scholars on the period. Some of the well-known contributors are John Marszalek, Mark Grimsley, Mark Neely, and Stephen Wise. The 47 bibliographic essays are divided into 11 subject areas (e.g., "General Secondary Sources," "Illustrative Materials," "International Relations," "Leaders, Strategy and Tactics," "The Home Front"). There is good representation of both social and military issues. Most essays range from 10 to 20 pages in length, including a bibliography at the end of the essay with full bibliographic citations. This book is intended to guide both the neophyte and the experienced Civil War scholar. The essays show trends and changes in historical interpretations and sometimes even mention areas in need of further research. A random examination of several essays shows most of the items were published since 1970. The essays cite 3,960 books, articles, dissertations, and such media as videos, television, and recordings. For example, the essay on musical and narrative recordings surveys approximately 955 titles. A random comparison of the bibliographies of 10 essays found very little duplication of titles. A large appendix provides information on 516 publishers and dealers of Civil War literature, with address and telephone number and occasionally fax and toll-free telephone number and e-mail address. The volume concludes with author, title, and subject indexes.
Guide to Civil War Books by Barbuto [RBB Mr 15 96] includes 320 current books and has outstanding annotations. The Civil War in Books by Eicher [RBB O 15 96] lists 1,100 historical and current books with critical annotations. In comparison, Woodworth's American Civil War has more entries and includes journal articles and media such as videos and recordings. It is current and extensive in its coverage. Academic, public, and Civil War collections should consider this excellent reference source for their collections.
Review
“Woodworth's handbook is an excellent guide through the immense bibliography of America's greatest conflict. More than 45 specialists provide bibliographic essays on a wide range of topics...Many of the substantial essays are important not only for their bibliographic content, but for their analysis of the changing themes and trends of Civil War scholarship....Scope and quality make this an ideal reference text for students, bibliographers, scholars, and curators of Civil War materials. Highly recommended.”–
Choice“This massive work has 47 contributors, all distinguished scholars on the period...This book is intended to guide both the neophyte and experienced Civil War scholar. The essays show trends and changes in historical interpretations and sometimes even mention areas in need of further research... It is current and extensive in its coverage. Academic, public, and Civil War collections should consider this excellent reference source for their collections.”–
Booklist/Reference Books Bulletin“[This work] is essential for Civil War specialists and highly recommended even for enthusiasts only slightly past the neophyte stage.... [It] is so readable and so impressively informative that [it] could be enjoyed in and of [itself], as well as used from time to time as [a] reference tool--as [it] no doubt will be by all serious scholars.... Woodworth's work...is simply a treasure-trove of Civil War knowledge, going well beyond the boundaries of books.... It is hard to say enough about how important and useful [this book is] and how important it is that all Civil War enthusiasts should know about [it]. I guarantee they'll treasure [it].”–
Civil War Times“Woodworth has orchestrated the contributions of librarians, museum curators, and historians, forty-nine strong, into a bibliographic guide that will help both the newcomer and the seasoned Civil War researcher sift through the masses of material published about that conflict, its causes, its conduct, and its aftermath.... the Civil War, at least for researchers, begins henceforth with Woodworth's handbook.”–
Rettig on Reference“This book will guide the reader to works and sources that will be valuable in a particular area of study. It should serve those who are turning their attention to one of its many facets they haven't yet explored....Using this book should save students of the War, new or experienced, false starts and wasted effort, and speed them on their way to the productive examination of America's "fiery trial"...”–
Confederate Veteran“The expertise, care, and clarity evident in [this] work will benefit researchers from beginners to scholars in all types of libraries.”–
Reference & User Services Quarterly“[I]mmensely valuable as [a] reference work. Steven Woodworth [has] provided [a] guide that will help professional historians and beginners sort out Civil War literature. [This] indispensible volume should be included in every Civil War library.”–
The Journal of Southwest Georgia History