Customer Reviews

The American Enemy: The History of French Anti-Americanism

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Roger had an original idea and executed it perfectly: Rather than engaging in the endless debates pro or con about America, he takes a clue from Nietzschean geneology and traces the origins and historical path of the anti-American discourse in France. This is a refreshing change of pace from the recent controversies, replacing polemic with superb historical and cultural study. This great idea is backed up with wit and good writing, making it already an indepensible book on this topic. Roger's courage and originality have certainly paid off: His book was critically well-received in France--no light feat in nation with a tradition of historical analysis--despite its obvious contrarian critique. I recommend this book highly to anyone interested in France, the US, or how prejudices are historically constructed.

It is important to note that this book is written by a Frenchman, but one who is very sympathetic to the US. It is written in an academic style, and at times assumes a knowledge of French history and culture that may be lacking in the American reader. Nevertheless, it is a fascinating study of the subject, particularly the first bits concerning French attitudes during the 18th century about North America's degenerative qualities, and the French sympathy for the Confederacy. Some of the later bits were a bit drawn out, but all in all, very interesting.

The reaction of Monsieur Buffon to Thomas Jefferson's proof of Buffon's ignorance is but one minor example of the depth of France's, and by extension Europe's, pathologically irrational attitude toward America/things American....and it gets worse further on. The bad part, as authors such as Markovits and Revel exposed in their books, is that the anti-American psychosis of France's/Europe's "elites" has spread to a large part of the general population. It'll be interesting to see how long the French/Euros will continue to hold on to their illusion of America being the threat to their civilization & culture as their Muslim populations become increasingly Talibanized.

My college calculus text book was light reading compared to this book. If it is ever translated into English, I may try it again.