Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Nothing More Remarkable Has Ever Smelled of Stars Than This, November 18, 2009
This review is from: And (American Poets Continuum) (Paperback)
Michael Blumenthal's AND is that rarity among recent books of poetry: a book that functions on two distinct levels of literacy. First it engages the reader aurally, the high lyricism lilting and soothing; next it invites the reader to, at his or her leisure, explore the glades and backwaters of its world by defining words and connecting ideas in a chain that afterwards binds the reader to self-reflection. At times Blumenthal's lyrics, and his delicious juxtaposition of ideas ("Nothing more remarkable has ever smelled of the stars than this," "semicircles of perambulating wings and hoots") seem almost chimerical, but when an author takes 12 years to write a book of poetry, even the improbable becomes likely. His language is (sometimes distractingly) latinate and intellectual--possibly a result of his legal background--but he counters with a poem like "And There Was No More to Give the World," where he says, "in the bayous of Louisiana, the mix was ready to welcome feud victims and alligators." Some readers may find Blumenthal's poetry overly wordy and even sentimental, but he speaks in a clear voice that is both entertaining and intellectually stimulating, and poetry needs more poets like this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Ambition of Blumenthal's And, November 16, 2009
This review is from: And (American Poets Continuum) (Paperback)
Michael Blumenthal's recent book AND attempts to evoke a Whitmanesqe sense of life, full and exuberant, using an Eliot-like, or rather modern, grasp of vocabulary and syntax. At first glance, the occasional four plus syllable Latinate word seemed out of place, pretentious maybe, though in the last poem, "And the World After All Is a Good and Gentle Place," I thought, perhaps after reading the word "tintinnabulation", these words are strange, strange in the way of the world, and here it didn't matter really what the word meant because poetry can be expressed without denotation, thus without language. The foreign word, though not fully comprehended, still communicates euphonic or cacophonic syllables, metrical or improvised rhythm, constant or various, among other elements of the sound of poetry. This particular poem, which can be seen and heard on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7z7MgIIyFXY, expresses modern Whitman, though Blumenthal deliberately states "I am not Whitman..." toward the end, and even Whitman was not himself.
Aside from the prologue, which in its definition-like structure alludes to several genuine connotations of the word, particularly "its lust for listmaking" which forever holds its place in American literature with Emerson's essay "The Poet", but in its italicized monologue seems distant and not quite together (I've never known anyone to feel "revivified", and if they did, they did not say this inexpressive word), the poems move very pleasantly, from one to the next, one person said, like a piece of classical music. At least, this is the idea of it. It seems like one person one time said, "In poetry, one can only come so close," and one might agree; in Blumenthal's book, he comes close to the idea several times. Two of my favorite poems are the last two in the book, as he embarks on his long "and-ish" good-bye.
One final thing, "And There Is So Much Ink in the World. And So Much Shit." follows a long, never-ending line of contemporary poems written by English professor / poets about the bad poetry of the world. I find this phenomenon very interesting, and I find the line, at least most recently, beginning with Kenneth Koch's "Fresh Air". The thing I like about Blumenthal's poetry is that, compared to many contemporary poets, he shows a little more restraint, and a genuine appreciation for the words he is using. In fact, in this poem he seems to be satirizing the talkative nature of some of the poems in the current scene: "meanwhile there was so much ink waiting / to be spent, so many trees to cut down, to hell with the screech owl / and the pileated woodpecker, there were stories that needed to be / told, every I crying out its I into the world...". Blumenthal adds a fresh variety, and ambition.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Blumenthal - self-titled work?, November 13, 2009
This review is from: And (American Poets Continuum) (Paperback)
After dipping my toes into Blumenthal's book of verse and casually wading across his first poem/prologue "And" in which he summarizes all the uses of that said conjunction - how it can "simply introduce the next thought, or the next item on a list, or suggest that there is more to the story" - I wondered if I could really call this poetry. I thought to myself, "This guy's just simply listing what he thinks about an insignificant little word - who cares?" But even as I continued to the next page and the next poem, I wondered if I was missing something - if Blumenthal's seemingly trouble-free words do more than what first meets the eye. Critics have accused Blumenthal of sentimentality, with language that is sometimes too stuffy (i.e. "when it comes to amour, we urge what we can/ out of the resonant silence, the forced tendresse, the dress lifted passionately..."), his terminology too restrictive ("prearranged for davening" and "pileated woodpecker"), and even, too an extent, too philosophical and vague ("what could be better for us than to simply allow the voice to speak,/ whenever it wishes, its little sympathy of regrets and inadequacies?"), etc. etc. and so on and so forth. Like any good poet, though, Blumenthal chooses his words carefully and their stifling flowery-ness is completely intentional. Daringly, Blumenthal dives headfirst into the pool of past exhaustingly romantic poetry and rather than swimming along on the surface with those other poets who have been accused of sentimentality (i.e. Whitman, Frost, Joyce Kilmer), Blumenthal sinks to new depths. The themes and messages hidden underneath the murky exterior of his poems jump out at you ever so subtly and force you to look inward, remembering forgotten things about yourself, nature, God, love, sex, fate, free will, and really -above all else- the possibility of something more. You will find that "and," that deceptively plain three-character conjunction, "[carries] many times its own weight," "has its own priorities," and makes "whatever has been said thus far [suffer] from congenital incompleteness." Certainly, it should be noted that Blumenthal has much in common with the title of his work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
Class Book Review
AND threatens the average
AND flustered me within my fleeced blanket confusion
AND speaks of God, sex, joy, sex, gods, regret, sex, God, puberty, arts
AND...
Read more
Published on November 13, 2009 by C. R. Brooks
|