Customer Reviews

Americans Who Tell the Truth

5 star:		(15)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(9)

 

 

I had the privilege of seeing the exhibit at Columbia University in June, 2005. It was elegant and inspiring. What makes America a great nation is our right to question the party line. Indeed, that's the only way progress has ever been made. I felt proud of my country walking around the magnificent setting of this display. These were and are courageous people.

The derogatory reviews on this website seem obsessed by notions of "Marxists" who "hate America," thus rendering the book "garbage," or worse. I suppose these folks want to keep young minds safe from the destructive thoughts of famous American traitors such as Dwight D. Eisenhower, Walt Whitman, Susan B. Anthony, Frederick Douglass, Chief Joseph, Martin Luther King, Jr., Henry Thoreau, Eleanor Roosevelt, Mark Twain, Helen Keller, John Muir, Woody Guthrie, Rachel Carson, Rosa Parks, and Bill Moyers, to name a few.

All Commies? Please! What are the detractors so afraid of? Can't they tolerate viewpoints that differ from theirs? The truth that America is not quite as "clean" as they'd like to believe? That we're a work in progress, and progress requires dissent, which involves uncomfortable soul searching?

See for yourself. Be inspired. Lord knows we need it now more than ever.

The responses to the book, "Americans Who Tell the Truth" were of great interest to me, given that I have used the book in the classroom and also worked with the artist, Rob Shetterly here in Louisville. While here, Rob worked with a middle school and high school program, both well regarded. Additionally, I wrote a curriculum for other teachers to share and to explore that appears on the website.
Neither school where Rob Shetterly worked and teachers pursued the curriculum, could be perceived as organizations interested in anything more than asking children to think and to ponder their place as citizens of this country.
When I wrote the currriuclum that accompanies the book and is published on the website, it had not occurred to me that anyone would use the book to persuade children to "hate" their country or anyone else in the world, for that matter. It had not occurred to me that we would be teaching children anything other than a way to look honestly at the country they live in and to consider those things that might impact the future they would inheirit. Rob Shetterly, in my mind and in my classroom, helped my students to understand that their voice DID matter.
We had students who did not agree with many of the things said by individuals in the portraits or with Rob, himself. But this was never the point of the study. The intention was to allow students to see first hand , from Rob himself, that when one has a feeling about one's country that using the gifts you have to express those can inspire and give hope to others.
I will ask anyone who sees this otherwise to look at student comments on the website and I will invite them to write reviews here of their experience. One fifteen year old student shared in her evaluation that until now she had never wanted to be involved as a citizen; like so many others, she didnt' think she could make a difference. What she saw in the portraits of Abe Lincoln, Thoreau and Amy Goodman and the many others , was that it WAS possible to be heard. Another student asked me why he had never heard of many of these people. Why, indeed?
To honestly look at our country and say, where do we go from here? This is the beauty and gift of the book.

...because this book is brilliant. Baseless, harpy reviews aside, this beautifully illustrated book is what America should be about. If one were to actually research what each of the members detailed in this book stood for, they'd realize that truth, integrity and honor are at the very core of their being.

The rants of the dissenters of this book sound amazingly Limbaugh and Coulter-esque, and therefore should be taken with a rather hefty grain of salt.

Finally, a book that doesn't include the usual faux USA heroes: George Washington, named the "Town Destroyer, who had innocent Iroquois women and children butchered and who praised his soldiers for skinning them and using their skin to repair their boots; Andrew Jackson who violated over 40 treaties w/ the Cherokee people and forced them off their land and sent them packing to OK ill-equipped (a death march called "The Trial of Tears") resulting in the death of over 1/5 of the Cherokee population; Thomas Jefferson who raped his 15-year-old slave Sally Hemmings, raped her repeatedly over the years, impregnating her, even as he inveighed against the evils of slavery; etc.

One way to measure the objectivity of this book is to note the unholy alliances it has forged among its detractors. Consider the review by the "liberal" Alan M. Dershowitz printed in the right-wing reactionary FrontPageMag.com. Why does Dershowitz find Shetterly's exercise in free speech so offensive? Apparently because Shetterly, appropriately, lists among the heroes Noam Chomsky and Amy Goodman.

I suspect that Dershowitz opposes Chomsky's inclusion because he still can't comprehend the possibility of an intellectual Jew unwilling to sacrifice his moral and intellectual integrity for the sake of the real estate aims of the nation of Israel. And he might oppose Goodman's inclusion because her program (Democracy Now) occasioned Norman Finkelstein deconstructing Deshowitz's "The Case for Israel" on the 9.24.03 broadcast before Deshowitz's helpless eyes.

Dershowitz opposes the book because "some of [the] hard-left radicals" the book includes "provided justifications for precisely the kind of violence that occurred on 9/11." This claim is laughably preposterous and Dershowitz knows it. He knows perfectly well that "reasons" is not the same as "justification" logically, a distinction that the USA policy makers ignore at our own peril.

Many will continue to write negative reviews of this book. They must. It smashes the cliché icons by omission.

Ps. Jamescrock's and Antok's reviews below contain passages plagiarized from Dershowitz's "Hate-America Lies For Kids" published on FrontPageMag (7.21.05 issue). No one should be surprised.

I heard about this book from a friend, and was happy to find it on Amazon. It would be a wonderful book to share with children, but adults will gain knowledge from it as well.

A lovely book filled with emotionally compelling paintings and wise quotations. It expresses progressive values that I and tens of millions of other Americans would love to impart to the children in our families. It shows that dissent has played a key role in making America a decent and moral country - "with liberty and justice for all" -- not just for the rich and powerful. Why is it that, when we express these values, conservatives say we hate America? The people on the far right say they believe in freedom, but when a decent and talented person like Robert Shetterly expresses his freedom he is called a Marxist and accused of spewing out garbage. Quite frankly, the New Testament is more Marxist that just about any of Shetterly's heroes. According to the Book of Acts, the disciples of Jesus did not believe in private property and shared everything equally. Jesus told the rich man to sell all he had and give to the poor. Jesus began his ministry by declaring an acceptable year of the Lord, which is a Jubilee year when wealth is redistributed in order to help the poor and the disenfranchised. So why don't you right-wingers start turning your slime machine against the Bible?

Shetterly's heroes are people like Martin Luther King, Jr.; Dorothy Day; Amy Goodman; and Terry Temepest Williams. If this isn't your cup of tea, go buy a book about Social Darwinism or some neocon fantasy about American hegemony. It hurts me that you would share these values with children, but it is a free country.

Why on earth do people find this book so threatening? As a father and teacher - and as an American citizen increasingly concerned by the deadly admixture of Christianity, patriotism, and rightwing bigotry that is undermining democracy everywhere from New York and London to Kabul and Caracas, I am happy for this timely volume and its accessibility to teens. I plan to use it at home, and in my classroom, to introduce thinking Americans like Shetterly's subjects to my sons and my students. In a world where dissent is being criminalized by the thought police in the White House and the Pentagon - and on Madison Avenue, and in the newsrooms of Fox and CNN - it's reassuring to know that not everyone has been brainwashed (yet).

Shetterly profiles 50 Americans who have taken a stand -- some putting their lives on the line -- on behalf of others. Each person is represented by a head-and-shoulders portrait, with a representative quotation. The portraits are direct and spare, reflecting the loneliness that these folks must have felt (and do feel as many are still alive and agitating) when standing alone against the powerful. The selection is uniquely Mr. Shetterly's; although many famous American heroes are included -- Jane Addams, Helen Keller, Mark Twain -- many of the folks represented are lesser known, such as peace activist Kathy Kelley or anti-landmine activist Jody Williams. Geared to teens, this book is a good starting point for discussions on what it means to "speak truth to power."

This is a beautiful and inspiring book, with a collection of quotes to make you think about humanity and the true purpose of government, given by people who had courage to stand up in the face of angry opposition (see below). I highly recommend it, and I will be reading it with my teenagers to facilitate discussion of important issues.

Please disregard the negative reviews. They are clearly from people with extreme political viewpoints who are fearful of hearing any opinion other than their own.

Aside from the amazing portraits painted by Shetterly, there are also word portraits painted by the subjects themselves. In these difficult times, it is inspiring to be reminded of what this country can, should, could, and would be if these soothsayers were listened to. It is a book which should be in every school library throughout the USA.