2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A N.....A D U L T ' S......A N D E R S O N ' S.....F A I R Y.....T A L E.....B O O K, May 15, 2009
It has beeb said that Hans Christian Anderson's tales...though full
of thought and enchantment, can be scary in the extreme. "The Snow
Queen", "The Red Shoes"....so many of these stories have strong
stories and stronger morals -- but are often too scary for children
to read.
Of course, not every story is like this. The enchanting "The Ugly
Duckling", and to a slightly lesser extent, "Thumbelina", (at least
ths has a happy ending!), are two of the tamer tales...and perfect
for children. The majority of Anderson's tales, however, can be
scary for children -- and the fascinating, though too-often scary
illustrations in this book, by justly famed illustrator ARTHUR
SZYK, show why!
Mr. Szyk's hyper-realistic drawings, with large eyes, and emphasis
on bulging stomachs, pursed lips, and scared or evil expressions,
add much to the general atmosphere of these tales. They are
true masterpieces of the illustrator's art -- but, for children,
(and even for sensitive adults), may be just a bit to scary for
comfort. They do, however, fit in with Mr. Anderson's tales very
well. One wonders what would have happened, had these two gentle-
men -- whose lives were separated by almost a hundred years, but
who seemed to have the same sensibilities of great empathy for the
under-privileged, a hatred of evil and unfairness, and great
compassion and hope for humankind, in spite of it all -- had been
able to meet and talk.
Well, in this volume, the reader has the next best thing. The
stories of Hans Christian Anderson, with Illustrations by Arthur
Szyk! Perfect together -- but be warned: these are VERY intense
"fairy-tales", combined with perhaps even stronger illustrations.
A connoiseru's Anderson's Fairy Tales, for sure -- but recommended
(strongly) only for adults, (and children), who are not prone to nightmares, due
to sensitive emotions. Read, and look at, with delight -- but also
with care!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No