Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hardly a Mockery, August 9, 2008
This review is from: Angel Falling Softly (Paperback)
I consider calling Angel Falling Softly a mockery (of Mormonism, LDS doctrine, LDS culture) to be odd in the extreme. It is, in fact, a story about a woman's relationship with God; it is the furthest thing from a mockery. People who covenant with God are usually not squeaky-clean individuals carrying out squeaky-clean agendas with squeaky-clean results. Such men and women are real, flawed individuals who fight and argue and weep and (even) bargain with God. God, as He points out to Job, is big enough to take it; so is the God of Angel Falling Softly (nowhere in the novel does the narrator/author state that any of the characters know God's mind absolutely and are thus, automatically, carrying out God's will). Redemption doesn't happen easily. It doesn't happen over night. It doesn't happen in 236 pages, and it certainly doesn't happen without people making some fairly awful decisions to begin with. SPOILER ALERT: In fact, the book ends on a remarkably judicious note. Characters who were heading in a spiritually unhealthy direction, end facing in a spiritually healthier direction. I am not referring to Rachel, who pays a serious and heart-breaking price for her decision. What God thinks of that decision, the author humbly does not attempt to answer. In conclusion, and getting to the vampire element of the novel, I consider the assumption that Rachel, for all her flaws and justifications, has "damned" her child to be faintly ridiculous. The original Dracula by Bram Stoker does link vampires to damnation and is about as replete with sexual imagery and allusions as a Victorian novel can be, but it hardly makes sense to refute the sexual link yet adopt Stoker's theory of damnation. Nowhere does the author imply that Miladi is anything more or less than a flawed, even sinful, daughter of God who has managed to overcome (to a degree) a horrific past. Nor does the author imply that her condition is anything more than a rather troubling disability (and, yes, seemingly unending mortality can be a troubling disability, a view that is in keeping with LDS doctrine). I agree with previous reviewers that the description of Miladi's "disease" is incomplete. I also agree that the sex scenes may seem overly detailed (as an active Mormon, I did not find them troubling, but I realize others might) although I consider them necessary to the plot and to character development. However, I find previous reviewers' apparent disgust and anger that Angel is somehow deceptive to be unfair to the author, the publisher and to the true hardiness and depth of LDS doctrine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Several very positive reviews, July 26, 2008
This review is from: Angel Falling Softly (Paperback)
Here's a collection of reviews from several well-respected authors and critics: William Morris, founder of the literary blog A Motley Vision: Mormon Arts and Culture: In melding the vampire genre with Mormon literary fiction, Eugene Woodbury has created a hybrid that is startling, fresh, insightful, and heartbreaking. What's remarkable about Angel Falling Softly isn't just that Woodbury does something new with vampire themes or that he provides a complex, touching portrait of a Mormon mother desperately trying to save her terminally ill child. It's that he weaves these elements together with well-deployed literary allusions and quotations (often Biblical) that add substance to the questions raised about belief, redemption, desire, sin and death. The novel is insistently literary while being solidly genre-based. What most amazed me is that he pulls it all off without violating the supernatural and metaphysical boundaries of Mormonism or of the vampire genre. He plays the two worlds against each other in a way that maximizes reading pleasure and says something new about the Mormon experience. Angela Hallstrom, author of the novel Bound on Earth: This tale of two women--one a vampire, the other a bishop's wife--is more than a good read. It is a provocative meditation on life and death that will leave readers both satisfied and unnerved. It kept me reading, and it kept me guessing. C. L. Hanson, blogger and novelist: Woodbury captures human relationships with realism and depth of feeling. He also paints a warm and homey portrait of Utah Mormon culture as seen from a sophisticated worldly perspective. All this is woven into a suspense-filled tale of a dangerous friendship as two women--born lifetimes apart--find the desperate courage to bet it all. Moriah Jovan, novelist: This isn't just a vampire story. It's a character study of the things Latter-day Saints might do when pushed into a corner with no apparent way out. The theme of the entire book can be summed up in one line: "Christians claim to believe in eternal life. So why are you so afraid of death?" Woodbury does nothing the easy or expected way in this story. There are a lot of questions and almost no answers--and I liked that. More, please.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Flair and Fangs, March 19, 2010
This review is from: Angel Falling Softly (Paperback)
Angel Falling Softly contains extraordinary writing and fine storytelling. Eugene Woodbury's brilliance and depth of knowledge is clearly evident. However, mixing LDS fiction with vampire fiction limits its appeal to a narrow audience. Congratulations to Woodbury for pulling off this bizarre combination of genres with flair and fangs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|