From Publishers Weekly
Newbery Medalist George strikes just the right note of respect and appreciation in this unsentimental collection of profiles of animals "who became beloved in their own right." She describes Punxsutawney Phil, the "king of Groundhog Day"; Smokey Bear, the cub that became a national symbol; and Sugar, a cat that traveled 1500 miles to find her owners. Among the most fascinating characters here is Koko, a gorilla that learned to communicate in American Sign Language: "When asked the color of her white towel for a boring umpteenth time, she signed 'red.' When asked twice again, she replied 'red,' then carefully picked a tiny speck of red lint off her towel. She chuckled, and again said 'red.' " The lively writing will likely lead to use of the bibliography provided. Merrill--an animal portraitist making her children's book debut--favors a realistic but lush style, free of artifice, confident in the inherent beauty of the subjects. Pure delight for animal lovers. Ages 8-12.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 4-5-An uneven potpourri of 10 rather abrupt narratives about a variety of memorable animals, ranging from the sled dog, Balto, who won international fame in 1925 for leading the final laps in a life-saving mission, to a trio of gray whales trapped by Alaskan ice in 1988. Also included are a cat who followed her owners 1,500 miles to their new home; Smokey Bear; a pair of eagles; an elusive mustang; Meriwether Lewis's dog; a blind workhorse; Koko, the gorilla who speaks sign language; and the groundhog Punxsutawney Phil. While some of these creatures truly warm the heart with their pluck, diligence, and intelligence, most of the stories are so tightly encapsulated they leave readers dissatisfied. They do not live up to George's brief but emphatic preface (or to her many other fine titles). The handsome oil paintings are quite pleasing and are accompanied by a scattering of black-and-white sketches. In all, the book feels like polished notes for a more ambitious work.
Patricia Manning, Eastchester Public Library, NYCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.