From School Library Journal
Grade 7 Up--Written in free verse, this novel is based on true events that took place off the treacherous coast of Newfoundland in 1828. Seventeen-year-old Ann Harvey helped her father rescue 163 passengers who were stranded after a ship carrying Irish immigrants ran aground. Major takes inspiration from the teen's proven courage, creating first-person poems in the voice of a dreaming, restless young woman eager to experience more of the world than her family's cod-fishing routine. Ann's poems alternate with those narrated by Seamus, a fictional shipwreck survivor hoping to find wealth and love in America. He entreats Ann to join him in his new life. Historical details, both real and imagined, make for a dramatic story. However, because the real-life Ann stayed in Newfoundland and married a local man, Major must attempt to explain her choice not to join the dashing Seamus. He has already established his heroine's character as stouthearted and yearning for adventure, so readers may question her decision to remain in her monotonous life. Atmospheric full-page illustrations in somber tones of gray add to the mood. Joan Elizabeth Goodman's Paradise(Houghton, 2002), which is also based on true events, presents a more compelling account of doomed young love and the rugged Canadian landscape. Libraries with either a geographic connection or a high demand for novels in verse should consider Ann and Seamus.--Eve Ortega, Cypress Library, CA
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 5-9. In 1828, 211 people were shipwrecked off the south coast of Newfoundland. This spare, melancholy novel in verse was inspired by Ann Harvey, the 17-year-old fisherman's daughter who helped row 163 of the victims to safety. Canadian writer Major portrays Ann as a restless dreamer who yearns for knowledge and broader experience but is grimly aware of her isolation, flatly lamenting, "What learning's here is fish." Ann's voice is briefly interrupted with that of Irish teenager Seamus, an invented character whose quest for a better life finds him aboard the doomed ship. When their lives converge, the romance that develops is not entirely convincing, perhaps because the constraints of verse hinder a full exploration of the characters' worlds. Even so, young readers will respond to the visceral language (the ship is a "lurching vessel of seasickness") as well as Ann's confusion as she contemplates her future. Subdued artwork in the bluish-gray tones of sea and spray sustains the brooding mood, and an endnote provides historical context.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved