2.0 out of 5 stars
Mediocre Selection for Beginner Chapter Book, September 30, 2011
Atwood, Margaret & Joyce Barkhouse.
Anna's Pet. 978-1-55277-718-3
Laurence, Margaret.
Six Darn Cows. 978-1-55277-719-0
Blades, Ann. 2011. 32 pp. ea. 414.95 ea.hc. Lorimer. Grades 2-3.
Anna, a young city girl visits her grandparents who live on a farm in the country and decides she wants a pet. She explores her surroundings and discovers there are many creatures that might serve as good pets, everything from toads and worms, to snakes and tadpoles. With each creature encounter she learns a little about its habitat and, with the help of her grandparents, draws conclusions as to why they would not make good pets. Anna is about to give up when her grandmother suggests a tadpole. Much to Anna's dismay, grandmother tells her that it's not the fish Anna believes it to be; instead, that it will grow and change into something brand new. The story concludes with Anna finally being content with her new pet and, although disappointed, understanding that when it becomes a frog she will have to release it back into the wild where it belongs. Her grandmother reminds her that it's hard to keep hold of anything forever, wise advice for anyone.
Although the writing style and story line is appropriate for the fiction genre, the interest level and reading level do not match the beginning reader category for which it is intended. The illustrations are lackluster and "not kid appealing" as per the first and second grade students surveyed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No