Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"To live means nothing but to grow", August 26, 2009
This review is from: Anna's World (Paperback)
Anna's World is a historical novel aimed at the young teen audience, but there's plenty here to make an adult smile too. Young Anna Coburn's life is turned upside down in 1845 when floods destroy her father's store and bring typhoid to her town. Needing to focus on rebuilding their future, he places Anna in a Shaker community where she finds life restrictive and longs for the day when he'll take her away again.
Authors Wim Coleman and Pat Perrin paint a rich picture of this strange and self-contained religious community, during the decade that saw it reach its highest numbers in the United States . Though Anna at 14 is considered a woman, not a child, she is able to attend school as well as share in the herb-processing work and other activities. The traditions and history of the Shakers are presented with respect and, as far as I know of Shakers, with accuracy. The authors portray a few of the Shakers as very real people who had real lives in the world before sequestering themselves in this celibate community.
The story deals with moral choices, but the public and private dilemmas are presented with a clever hand and never sound preachy. I was delighted to find Henry David Thoreau as a character in the book, introducing the themes of slavery and the Mexican War. When Anna's father eventually sends for her and brings her to his sumptuous new Boston home, these worldly issues have a surprising impact on her and, young as she is, she has to make some adult choices about how to live her life.
If you think a book about an all-but-defunct religious community sounds dull, read it for yourself and you'll be pleasantly surprised. Anna is a well-rounded main character, mature but not beyond a bit of mischief when the occasion arises. Her courage in the face of danger, her commitment to living the life that's right for her, provide a model for growing up that's as fresh as a new day.
I took one star off because of a concern that's admittedly subjective: in the epilogue, Anna reminisces about her father's position of conscience during the Civil War. I felt that his stance ws introduced with too little discussion, so that her acceptance of it was not well-grounded. This could (and should) be an opportunity for thoughtful discussion in the family if you bring this book home to a teen.
Linda Bulger, 2009
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
YA fictional account of life among the Shakers in the 1800s, August 17, 2009
This review is from: Anna's World (Paperback)
When a book of fiction brings history to life, the reader always benefits!
Anna is sent to live among the Shakers after a flood destroys her hometown and her father's store, and while she is recovering from typhoid fever. She is 14, and wants to rejoin her father, who is trying to build a new life in Boston.
The Shakers have firm rules organizing their society, and Anna slowly adapts to these conventions, learning the ropes of Shaker life and worship. Eventually, she is reunited with Papa, but the bright lights of Boston do not turn out to be as attractive as she may have wished. People are not always who they seem.
Anna's World, by Wim Coleman and Pat Perrin, was written to be an entertaining story for young adults (YA) as well as a tribute to the Shakers, a religious group that currently has, in 2009, three remaining members. Known for their plain dress, their commitment to do their jobs well, their religious songs and dance, their opposition to slavery and war, and their dedication to producing fine herbs and stout, well-made furniture (particularly chairs), Anna goes from observing their customs first as an outsider, then as an insider. She evolves with them and, in some small ways, they evolve with her.
Authors Coleman and Perrin clearly are enamored by the Shakers, and in Anna's World they are assisted with the fictional presence of Henry David Thoreau, who takes time away from his lone contemplations at Walden Pond to visit the Shaker community and meet Anna, and later see her again in Boston as he delivers his famous polemic against the Mexican-American War. Readers of this book will become more familiar with both Shakers and Thoreau, although the story itself is wrapped around the typical YA literature themes of growing up, looking for understanding, making hard decisions, friendship, and fitting in.
This isn't an overly religious book. Discussions of God the Father and Mother come through Anna's discussions with the female leadership. As far as I can tell, the authors did a nice job with issues relating to historical accuracy.
I have to admit a bit of rolling the eyes as I started reading this book, but I ended up being captivated by Anna's story. What was she going to accomplish with the Shakers, and in Boston? Does Papa ever listen to that wise (now) 15 year old? Is Eldress Clara a dictator or not? Does Brother Seth have a memory problem, or something more sinister?
I would suspect that any new visitor to a Shaker community, even in 1840, would get an orientation to the history of this church. This would have been helpful to share with the reader, since few kids today would have any sense at all as to what a "Shaker" was. Alas, in a few years, the extinction of Shakers from this planet will make this book a reflection on a different time and culture... that one can only read about. Hence, the value of Anna's World in our school libraries.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great book for the Tween to learn about this period of history, August 15, 2009
This review is from: Anna's World (Paperback)
This book is written with the Tween reader in mind, yet as an adult, I found it enjoyable. I always like a book that can teach me things and this one did just that. I have known about Shakers and their wonderful woodcrafts but I never knew they were versed in herbs and what they could do for medicine. I also didn't know they were Separatists in that they did not live as husband and wife or that they took in orphans.
Anna Coburn, age 14, is left by her father with the Shaker Community after her town suffered a horrific flood. She doesn't want to be there with all the rules the Shakers have. Life is dull to Anna.
She makes friends with another young girl, Sally who is a monitor in the Shaker school. Yet, there are some things that happen in the community like Henry David Thoreau speaking at their school and this catches Anna's interest.
Sally talks Anna into helping her to run away so she can marry the boy she loves and Anna's father finally sends a servant to get her. Her father has been able to start a new business in Boston and has married and is now able to have Anna with him. Anna goes willingly but soon finds Boston is not the town or the life for her.
ANNA'S WORLD tells of life in the late 1840's, the war with Mexico and the lifestyle of the Shakers. It is written in easy to understand language. It is a good book for the Tween in your life to learn about this period of history in America.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|