Customer Reviews

Annie, Between the States

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

While Ann Rinaldi has done surprisingly well with her historical novels, I found each of them to be dull and rather unbelievable. In "Annie Between the States," L.M. Elliott does a MUCH better job of conveying an interesting story along with good morals to the reader, combining history, action, poetry, and romance to form an intoxicating mix of emotion and excitement.

In L.M. Elliott's delightful tale, we find ourselves walking through the events of the Civil War with Annie Sinclair, a spirited, highly moral heroine with red hair. (Why include this fact about her red hair? you ask. And I say: READ THE BOOK!) Annie at first comes off as weak and potentially spoiled, but that disappears quickly, and her unspoken quest for strength was interesting to follow. Her love of poetry gives her character unimaginable depth--if you are an author you will understand that if you can give your character a deep passion for something, then they will come alive and become very believable. Ms. Elliot does this job very well.

All right. Perhaps the history comes across as too much of a narrative in parts. Perhaps the writing is a bit plain sometimes. Perhaps the author even has some trouble using the active voice. But I could quickly overlook these things while I was reading because Ms. Elliott could make me care about the characters, could make me see things through Annie's eyes and see them rather well. And so I give it a 5 star rating--because I enjoyed it and think that the author has mastered things more important than active voice and elaborate writing.

Highly recommended.

For Annie Sinclair, the Civil War is more than simple conflict between North and South. Since she lives in Virginia, she is straddled between the two sides, surrounded by family and friends whose views about the war are usually conflicting. Annie's older brother Laurence is a soldier in the Confederate army who is increasingly dismayed by the viciousness, confusion, and senselessness of the war. Her younger brother Jamie, however, seems to embrace the very aspects of the war that Annie and Laurence hate. Annie is coming to realize the immorality of slavery, but she is still willing to take daring measures to help defend her homeland from Federal troops. Yet perhaps the hardest part of the war for Annie is that she begins to fall in love with Thomas Walker, an honorable man who shares her love of poetry, but is a Yankee.

"Annie, Between the States" is an excellent novel largely because it forces readers to realize how strikingly heart wrenching the Civil War was, especially to those who lived in border states. More than glamorized novels like "Gone With the Wind," this book shows how war often offers no solutions and no black-and-white courses of action.

L.M. Elliott developed her main character superbly as well. In the opening chapter of the novel, Annie seems overly "ladylike" and a bit spoiled, frightened to the point of inaction when war is near her. Annie soon overcomes these tendencies, however, and before the war is too far along, she is displaying the kind of intelligence, strength, bravery, and maturity that will have readers lost in 1860s Virginia. Her two relationships-with Thomas Walker and the Confederate soldier William Farley-are incredibly moving as well.

Initially, the historical facts woven into the storyline seemed too much like something in a text book. Yet quickly, Elliott seemed to become much more adept at keeping the battle details from being too cumbersome. The intriguing Southern general Jeb Stuart and the one-of-kind Confederate soldier John Mosby were perfect additions to this story.

This is about as well-done a historical fiction novel as you are going to find. With its ordinary yet compelling main character, suspenseful action, and emotionally-charged romance, it will stay with you much longer than any history book chapter on the Civil War.

What an amazing book! I don't typically like historical fiction. I actively dislike stories about the Civil War. However, someone raved so about this book that I figured I'd give it a shot. It blew me away.

The story is not of the Civil War, but of Annie, a farm girl who strives to remain true to herself in the midst of family turmoil, confusing relationships, and a war that's happening in her own front yard.

The characters are so real you feel like you've known them your whole life. The setting is described in such detail that it's like you're there. Anyone who reads this book will love it. My only concern is its size. It might be a bit intimidating to kids who don't like to read, but if they give it a shot, they won't regret it.

I just finished reading this book and it is one of my favorites! (This is saying a lot since I read a book or two a week!) I couldn't put it down and read it all in one sitting. I strongly recommend this book for anyone who likes action along with romance, coming of age, and history. THIS IS A GREAT BOOK!

I have just finished reading ANNIE: BETWEEN THE STATES, L.M. Elliott's newest novel, and am thrilled to say that as phenomenal and accurate a piece of historical fiction as UNDER A WAR TORN SKY (Ms. Elliott's first novel) was, ANNIE exceeds it -- not only in excitement but also in the moral dilemma it both presents and resolves. This is a "must read" for teenagers, boys and girls alike, as it transports the reader back through time into an era of incredibly bloody strife marked by fanatical devotion and commitment. That Annie is so torn reflects the mental and emotional state of any teenager who thinks and feels as intensely as Annie does -- and is an eerily on-target rendering of true adolescent angst, regardless of the era. Until now UNDER A WAR TORN SKY was my favorite novel for kids; ANNIE has moved it over a notch, so that now both are mandatory reading for my own children and, as I am a teacher, for my students.

The great Civil War has broken out in America and Annie Sinclair is literally caught between the states. She lives in Hickory Heights, a small town in the state of Virginia that is right in the midst of the Union and Confederate army's attacks. Her family is caught up in the battle too. Her old brother Lawrence enlisted in the Confederate army and her younger brother Jamie joined the Gray Ghost, John Mosby. Annie and her mother cannot avoid the war either. Together they tend to the many wounded Confederate soldiers. The experience is very hard on Annie but she takes even more daring roles to help the Confederate cause. Soon she is dubbed Lady Liberty by Lawrence's commanding office Jeb Stuart for her acts to help the Confederate army defeat the Union forces. However Annie's views on the war change when a Union officer is dragged to her farm. Thomas Walker was saved from being hit by a bullet because of his volume of Keat's poetry and soon he and Annie connect because of both's passion for poetry. As tragedy and conflict erupt in Hickory Heights, Annie must question her stance in the war. Which side is really right? Which side is the one she believes in? I am a big fan of L.M. Elliot's Under a War-torn Sky. The book is still one of my all time favorite historical fiction stories. Annie, Between the States was not as good but it is still a worthy addition to my Civil War collection. Annie is a strong protagonist that most girls will connect with. A definite recommendation!

I liked this book. That said, I didn't love this book. The main character is likeable, and behaves in a manner true to her age. It seems to me that some of the other characters were templates, and bordered on stereotypes. The mother is Melanie, straight off of the plantation, and the black housewoman will definitely have you thinking that Annie lives at Tara. Annie loses a potential suitor, a young boy as sweet as Scarlett's first husband. The story is not Gone With The Wind, but you will hear echoes of Mitchell while you read it.

This book really brings you into the life of a young woman in the civil war. It shows you alot of the horrible things that went on, brothers fighting brothers, and shows and truly devastating it was. And how comitted some people were. It's not entirely fiction. Alot of the characters in this book were real people.
If your not really a history person (believe me, i really wasnt interested in anything to do with american history until i read this) there is also some ramantic aspects to it. It'll keep you glued to the pages. Hope you ejoy it as much as i did.

This book was okay for me. I found the synoposis to be really off. Only about half of it had anything to do with Annie's romance with the Northern soldier, and it wasn't well developed at all. If you like reading about war strategies and locations, pick it up! But don't read it for the romance. I couldn't say I would read this book again.

L.M. Elliot's book, Annie, Between the States is an incredible novel worth reading. I felt like I could really relate to the protagonist, Annie Sinclair. The book opens with a queasy Annie trying to aid a wounded soldier. Some think that in this scene, Annie seems like a spoiled brat, but I think that this adds depth to her character and makes her more believable. The book continues as Annie choose between her loyalty to the Confederacy and her love for kindred spirit, but also Union soldier Thomas Walker. (though she does not admit it herself until later on) Annie loves to read, and Ms. Elliot's allusions to poetry and to the classic novel, The Scarlet Letter, are excellent. Overall I have no criticism for this novel, and I have read it numerous times.