From School Library Journal
reSchool-Grade 1-Square-jawed, muscle-bound Jack awakens and embarks on a host of fabulous adventures. Shot from a cannon directly into a spiffy blue suit, he grapples with an alligator and conquers a space alien and giant robot from the wings of his personal airplane- all on his way to work as Chief Flavor Tester in the World's Best Ice Cream Company. But then things start going a little funny. Gone is the suit, with a ballerina's pink tutu and baby's bonnet appearing in its place. Gone too is Jack's airplane, replaced by a tricycle. All of a sudden, the coppers are after him. What's happened to Jack's perfect day? Obviously it's all a bad dream and, with a little help from his pajama-clad, apple-cheeked alter ego, young Jack wakes up surrounded by the toys that gave rise to his extraordinary dream in the first place. MacDonald's exuberant illustrations are curvy and bold and hearken back to a bygone era of pulp comics. Characters speak and think in dialogue balloons; exclamations like "Oww!" "Poof!" and "Eeeek!" abound. The book is rich in visual imagery, like a double-page slapstick drawing of a fire hose run amok, or cameos of a chirping robin and warm toast in a toaster. Sepia shades infused with blue and yellow and creamy paper stock reinforce the old-fashioned look. Simple text contrasts delightfully with the energy of the illustrations (a picture of hero Jack holding up a locomotive is accompanied by, "but by now he was running late- so he caught the train-"). Another Perfect Day satisfies the unabashed superhero in all children.
Mary Ann Carcich, Mattituck-Laurel Public Library, Mattituck, NYCopyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
K-Gr. 2. The art is the thing in this delicious parody of a businessman's day. Jack jumps out of bed, so ready for work that he shoots himself out of a rocket, wrestles an alligator for exercise, and catches the train--in both hands--as a little boy in his pajamas slips in and out of the pictures, watching his accomplishments. "This is going to be my most perfect day yet," he remarks. But then things go horribly wrong. Jack's blue suit suddenly turns into a pink dress, and his mode of transportation becomes a tricycle. The little boy tells him to wake up, and Jack tries, but it's not until the child talks him through--with bluebirds, sunlight, and toast--that he succeeds. Then it's clear that Jack is really the dreaming boy. The it's-all-a-dream plot is old, and the story can best be described as simplistic. But the artwork is fresh and new, even if it is retro. MacDonald, a
New Yorker cartoonist, re-creates the cartoon-style artwork of the late 1930s and 1940s, starting with a hero who looks like Superman in his Clark Kent mode. He also captures the feeling of the period in the design, lettering, and in the unusual gold-and-blue palette. Even the buff color of the paper is right. Certainly, this will have lots of appeal for those acquainted with the era MacDonald evokes, but young children will also like the look, just as it delighted people the first time around. Come to think of it, the dream gambit may be new to them, too.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved