Customer Reviews

Anthology 1935-1973

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I agree with all the reviewers who rave about the music of Bob Wills and the Texas Playboys. This is irresistable western swing that has to leave you smiling. When the Anthology was released, it was by far the most complete collection available on disc and was worth the price for that reason. Now, however, more recent discs offer nearly as complete a sampling at a single-disc price, basically omitting only the very late works which, while of historical interest, simply aren't as good as during the peak of Bob's career. I now consider this collection to be only for the fan who wants to own it all and certainly not the best introduction for new fans. Indeed, neither disc in the set is as good as the two better (in my opinion) single-disc collections: "King of Lonestar Swing" and "The Essential Bob Wills", the first one of which has 28 tracks, versus 32 on the two-disc Anthology.

If you like the hot club of Cowtown, you will like this. This is the period of Wills' band that their work is founded on, listen to the Devilish Mary on here that they made the title of an album. Listen to the great masterful Sally Gooden, so good to be believed. This is great and hot and sometimes just so good you cannot believe it. This is more a guitar and steel guitar and mandolin players record than a fiddling record. It is also significant that while most of the Western Swingers went into the Hollywood Cowboy, mellow singing, buisnessman's bounce phase typified by Spade Cooley and Hank Penny, Will's band here in the postwar years stays red hot jazzy, bluesy, and fiddlin it all the way out!\

Without getting into the history: this is just good music suitable for anyone at any time with ears.
This is the real deal in regard to Western Swing. The Tiffany recordings were done for the Tiffany Furniture Company of Oakland in the period after WWII. They were sold to radio stations as music to play over the air along with or without commercials for the furniture company. This was done when playing normal commercial records on the radio was a rare and new thing.

If you look on the discography you will find there were more than 200 recordings done by Wills over the years for this operation. So even if Rounder has put out ten volumes of this music, they are still just offering the best of the collection. These were rare treats among the collectors. I remember first hearing about them around 1977 when a friend of mine who lived in NYC mentioned he knew someone in Indiana who had taped copies of these records. I remember how I treated the tape he made me like a golden jewel, carrying it with myself personally when I moved.

People I know who actually heard the Texas Playboys play during the 1930s and 1940s say these recording say this is the way the Playboys sounded at their best live. This is the repertoire. Since it was officially a non-commercial recording, they recording all the songs they would play at live dates, and not just songs they recorded which were usually filtered by the Columbia, MGM, and MCA operation to make sure they recorded songs that had the right publishing andwere charting for others.

On other Tiffany recordings you can hear the Playboys make wonderful music on Nat King Cole's Straighten up and Fly Right, Basie's Swing Blues, Ellington's Take the A Train, Dinah Shore's Sentimental Journey, and even a gret instrumental on the theme from the movie Mission to Moscow!

The recording quality isn't always as good as the Columbia and MGM sides, but that is because they simply recorded all day whenever the tour schedule took the Playboys into San Fransisco, cutting tunes without rehearsals, on the first take, cutting five or six or seven sides in a day, as opposed to the standard recording studio concept of 4 sides in three hours, which was never met. However, on a number of these tunes they really cut lose in instrumentals they way they don't on the commercial disks. If you love the repartee between Bob and the Band, you get a lot more of that on these tunes.

What these records represent for the history of Western Swing is priceless. The guitar trio sound grew out of the duos that Eldon Shamblin and Leon MacAufliffe did with Wills before WWII. When Jimmy Wyble (who went on to be one of the key Jazz guitarists of the 1950s and 1960s) and Cameron Hill came in during the War and were joined by Noel Boggs, that sound was perfected. On these sides we hear it bluesier and hotter played by Junior Barnard or Eldon on guitar, Tiny Moore on Mandolin, and Boggs or Herbie Remington on steel guitar. You don't get as much of this on the contemporary Columbia sounds, although you did on the first MGM sides there was a revival

If you have one CD, get this one so you can listen to the Sally Gooden on it. It is a unique recording, of which the Hot Club of Cowtown is only a pale imitation, since they only really have a trio, and this adds in guitar, steel guitar and other instruments. You must have that cut!

This music is so great, so full of life, so musically excellent and also so much fun. I just wish that it was a 10 CD set and more of a complete collection of Wills' earlier music. Wills is a towering giant of the 20th century and some of his best moments are collected here. You would have to be remarkably morose not to feel happy with this music. Many of the musicians play brilliantly on several selections--this was an all star band of virtuosos. Like Duke Ellington's band, they did not get to stretch out for very long but they made every note count. Bob himself is such a joyful personality. This set is a treasure.

Bob Wills (1905-1978) is known for the distinctive style of music called western swing. This two-volume CD has him at his best. All of the good ones are here, and the quality is surprisingly good for music that was originally recorded mostly in the 1940's. "Faded Love", "Deep Water", "San Antonio Rose," this is music from the heart. The heart of Texas and the hearts of all of us that love Western Music! Man, I think you will ove this one and buy extra ones for your kids, or you'll be missing this one when they leave home!

This collection is bursting at the seams with ideas! Just listen to the guitar on 'Fat Boy Rag' - "ugly, ugly" and I'm sure you'll agree it is without parallel. If you don't move around to this one - you're probably dead! I too wish it were longer - just cain't get enuf of the Playboys and 'ol Bob! Wonderful, wonderful!

My late father was a Playboy, all sixteen years and hundred pounds of him working the tenor guitar [that's the one with only four strings in the many documentary photo's in this package]. They all learned their craft in the honky-tonks and on the roads of the dust bowl, playing the Depression into the past half the night and driving to a live morning radio show the other half. The fusion of eclectic musical styles and instumentation [a saxophone in a hillbilly band!] is matched only by the expertise with which these 'boys' could play. The sound quality is impressive as well. Many a party was graced with these old songs that everyone 'round here who 'picked up' an instrument seemed to know after a few bars were played, I'll swear to it. These CD's are an impressive and important collection of American music before cookie cutters were even invented. Fun, yes, but historic and bold too. What an anthology, and about the only place you'll ever hear a tenor guitar!

I own this really good set from Rhino and it has many of Bob Wills' classics on it. This set is fine but for the true Western Swing fan like myself I understand that the 11 CD Box Set "San Antonio Rose" from the Bear Family has all 300 of his early recordings along with a 1940 movie with Bob and Tex Ritter and to top it off a hard backed Book. I have purchased many of the Bear Familys great sets including Wanda Jackson, Jimmy Martin, The Louvin Brothers and the 7CD Anita Carter set that ran in price about as high as I can afford to pay (my Connie Smith set was about the cheapest). I would love to have this set from Bear Family but at $300.00 I don't think so. I think that I will stay content with my 2CD Rhino Collection. If anyone out there does happen to have a Bear Family set for sale at an affordable price I am interested!

"Enjoy" Joe Kopeck / Parkville,Maryland

This album is great. What an intelligent and brilliant combination of country and swing. It's like being in New Orleans with a band of country guys playing jazz. I recommend it without any doubt.

My dad grew up in Tulsa and made many of those noon shows at the Cain's Ballroom in the 30s. So did all of my folks from both sides of the family. Everyone stopped what they were doing to tune into KVOO at lunch time. Bob even played for some of the big ranchers in the area when they got an off night and were on the way to the next gig. Later in his life I bought every Bob Wills CD I could find and made Dad cassette copies so he could listen to Bob in his old pickup. Of all of them Dad said this one reminded him most of what he remembered about The Playboys. That says a lot.

It ain't Bob Wills without Tommy Duncan and Leon McAuliffe. This is the real thing.

No one can dispute Bob Wills' dominance of the Western Swing genre, even twenty-five years after his death. The thirty-two songs on this album are all classics, and they, along with the fairly extensive liner notes, provide a nice retrospective on Bob Wills' long career. For true fans who have the money, though, the Tiffany Transcriptions set is probably the way to go.