18 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Antique Trader Clocks Price Guide: Including All Types of Clocks - 17th through 20th Century (Antique Trade Clocks Price Guide), August 11, 2005
This review is from: Antique Trader Clocks Price Guide: Including All Types of Clocks-17th Through 20th Century (Antique Trader's Clocks Price Guide) (Paperback)
A brave title with "ALL Types of Clocks" and it disappointed as it did not include many (if any) small Boudoir Clocks. Few 20th Century clocks only 1 electric clock. Few mentions of swiss clocks of note. NO INDEX - what sort of book dose not have an index.
Like many American authors - if it does not happen in the USA it does not happen.
I would not recommend this book to those who collect clocks from "the world" as the world is greater than the USA.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, February 18, 2011
This review is from: Antique Trader Clocks Price Guide: Including All Types of Clocks-17th Through 20th Century (Antique Trader's Clocks Price Guide) (Paperback)
The Antique Trader's Clocks Price Guide, includes listings for all types of clocks from the 17th through the 20th century. It does not address any STYLES however. So if you happened to want to get an approximate value for a favorite, say, Art Deco clock, you would not be able to find it in this book - although it would be difficult to immediately determine whether your clock was listed or not because, incredibly, this book has neither a table of contents nor an appendix.
To locate a specific manufacturer of a specific type of clock, you must flip through the pages while scanning the header titles on each page. After locating the section covering your "type" of clock, you must then scan through the listings, which are organized by sub-type, within which the manufacturers are listed in alphabetical order. It is rather like looking through a yellow pages advertising section for a service with a particular address. I found it to be cumbersome.
Once you have located a specific clock type listing, the information provided is less than useful. The editors state that the information provided in the book comes from a variety of sources, and it looks that way. The scope and detail of each listing varies a great deal, an in my opinion does not even address information that strongly affects price.
For example - I looked up my "Black Forest Cuckoo Clock" in the guide. The listing for this clock did not identify it as a "Hunter Style" - they called it simply a "Black Forest" cuckoo clock. That's like identifying all Ford cars as a "Ford". They did not identify whether the clock had a 30 hour or 8 day movement, nor the manufacturer of the movement (or whether the movement had a maker's mark or not). They guessed the clock was "post WWII", but did not say why they thought so. There were no listings for Black Forest Cuckoo Clocks that contained music, or dancers - nor did they include any reference to other styles of cuckoo clock, such as the "Train Station" (or Bahnhäusle) style, which is more expensive than the clock pictured.
The listing descriptions really did not provide much more information than you got by looking at the picture alone (if you had an image of a clock with two finials on top, does it add value to state in the description that the clock has two finials on top?). The description should include information beyond the obvious physical features. The prices shown were apparently the sales or asking price of the specific clock pictured. You will have to guess (style, movement, age, condition, etc) how similar your clock actually is to the one pictured. I know for a fact that cuckoo clocks of the "Black Forest Cuckoo Clock" type listed in this book at a value of $200-$250 regularly sell on eBay for $125.00 or less.
Finally, there are 16 pages of color plates on high gloss paper depicting some fabulous museum quality clocks. The rest of the book has reasonably good black and white images printed on standard paperback book quality paper.
So if you have a clock, or are thinking of purchasing a clock, I think you can do better than this book; it will not likely be of much help in determining the value of the clock you are interested in. If you like pictures of clocks and are interested in what some specific clocks are valued at, then you might like this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Cheap Intro for a Beginning Collector, December 28, 2008
This review is from: Antique Trader Clocks Price Guide: Including All Types of Clocks-17th Through 20th Century (Antique Trader's Clocks Price Guide) (Paperback)
As one of the other reviewers wrote, this is NOT a catalog of all clocks. But it does serve a beginner well, with many fine pictures. However, the estimated values have nothing to do with reality. Although this book is many years old, the values are 3-10 times more than you'll pay on ebay, which, by the way, is the best place to buy an antique clock (as long as the dealer has a 98% or better rating). Prices are about one-fifth the price of antique stores.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No