Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Antiques and Murder - a Winning Combination!, April 23, 2008
This review is from: Antiques to Die For (Josie Prescott Antiques Mysteries) (Hardcover)
Josie Prescott and her best friend, Rosalie Chaffee, are indeed sisters of the heart. They have both lost their parents, a loss that undeniably has shaped the women they have become. While they don't have a whole lot else in common, this invisible bond makes them closer than one might otherwise expect. Rosalie is fun loving and carefree, qualities Josie envies, but she is also an exceptionally fine older sister and guardian to Paige, her 12-year-old sibling. When Rosalie washes up on the Rocky Point shoreline - the victim of a suspicious drowning - Josie is stirred into action. Rosalie has confided several things in Josie recently, any one of which might have some bearing on her death. In addition, Rosalie had garnered the attention of a creepy "secret admirer," whose unwanted attention seems to switch almost seamlessly to Josie once Rosalie is out of the picture. Rosalie also confided in her younger sister that they own something priceless for which they would eventually need Josie's expertise - although Paige and Josie have no idea what that item might be. In addition, when Josie starts probing, she finds out how little she actually knows about her friend. Although it is all but impossible to imagine Josie having such carte blanche to investigate a murder even if her boyfriend IS the chief of police, the plot was enjoyable and complex enough to hold the reader's attention through to the end. If you like a side of antiques with your murder mystery, you'll undoubtedly enjoy the Josie Prescott Antiques Mystery series. Carol Ann Hopkins 4/23/2008
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Imitation isn't always flattering, May 22, 2008
This review is from: Antiques to Die For (Josie Prescott Antiques Mysteries) (Hardcover)
It seems, in "Antiques to Die For", Ms. Cleland has once again paralleled Elaine Flinn's Molly Doyle Mysteries. Now, this could certainly be just a coincidence that so many aspects of Cleland's books seem to ring a bell if you've read Flinn's series. But it seems uncanny that Cleland's Josie Prescott left the NY world of antiques (auction house) under a cloud, so did Flinn's Molly Doyle (antiques shop). And JP moved to a small village to start over, so did MD. Both quickly found themselves involved in a murder, and butting heads with the local police chief, who, in each case, evolves into a romantic relationship. MD is a little behind JP though, since she's still married (her husband ran off with another woman and the law) and hasn't (so far) become intimate with her cop. But there is more in Ms. Cleland's books that seem awfully coincidental. MD's boss is named Max. JP's lawyer is a Max too. The main street in JP's `made up village' is Ocean Avenue, and that's the main street in MD's Carmel, California setting. And then there is JP's dead father whose sage advice she frequently recalls. MD `talks' problems over with HER dead father's photo. JP has a friend who has a small child is named Emma. MD's abandoned niece (who she cares for) has the same name! And now, in the latest episode, JP ends up taking care of her dead friends daughter who is 12 years old. Sunofagun! MD's niece was 12 when she showed up in Flinn's second book. I guess JP not having a best friend who owns a restaurant is a relief. Flinn's first book (DEALING IN MURDER) was published in 2003, with books following in 2004, 2005 and 2007. Cleland's first book was published in 2006. You figure it out. Ms. Cleland is certainly talented, but, while some may find what sure seems to me like imitation, as being the sincerest form of flattery - in this case I sure as hell don't. Isn't it time for Ms. Cleland to get a little original? What's she going to do if Flinn has Molly Doyle get a pet monkey? Could a baboon be in Josie's future? Full Discloser: Elaine Flinn is my mother. And, before anyone accuses her of putting me up to this - I'm 42 and don't need her permission to defend her.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Cold Blooded Murder in the Dead of Winter, April 15, 2008
This review is from: Antiques to Die For (Josie Prescott Antiques Mysteries) (Hardcover)
When Josie and Rosalie met, they became instant friends. So when Rosalie turns up dead one January morning, Josie is naturally upset. The fact that it was murder makes things even more upsetting. Rosalie was a woman of many secrets. She had a secret lover, a secret admirer, and a secret treasure. She'd just told her younger sister, Paige, about a treasure that would set them up for life. But what is it? While Josie tries to find this secret item, Rosalie's secret admirer seems to be transferring his interest to Josie. Is Josie in danger? Who is the secret admirer? Where is the treasure? And who killed Rosalie? Now if you are concerned about keeping all these potential plots straight, don't. I had to set the book down for a few days while reading it (too busy), and I had no problem getting back in the flow of things. Part of that is because of the strong supporting characters. They make it easy to keep everyone straight. Josie isn't nearly as emotional as she was in the last book, which I found a refreshing change. On the other hand, we get to watch Paige deal with her emotions, which made for some truly heart breaking scenes. While Josie is a little stronger emotionally, she still constantly shares nuggets of wisdom from her father. While that didn't bother me that much in previous books in the series, it really got on my nerves here. Not quite sure why. There were a few things about the plot that could have been stronger, but on the whole it was a good book that made me wish I had more time to sit down and read. Frankly, I'm not that interested in antiques, so the fact that a book centering around them can keep me entertained is a testament to the great characters, story, and writing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|